Like Button

Wednesday, September 09, 2020

Vote

I know this will come as a surprise, but it turns out 2020 is a presidential election year. Who knew, right? Kidding, of course. You can't escape it. So we now have two people we get to choose from -- Biden or Trump -- and you get to make your choice. Oh, that's called "vote." But just what is a "vote"?

According to the dictionary, a "vote" is "a formal expression of opinion or choice, either positive or negative, made by an individual or body of individuals." So, I don't plan to elect ... anyone. I plan to make a formal expression of my opinion or choice. For those who say, "My vote doesn't count," I suggest you are saying, "It just doesn't matter what I think." Maybe it's true, but if it is, you need to move. Find some island somewhere so you don't have to be a citizen of any country and "render to Caesar what is Caesar's" because that kind of thinking is neither biblical nor helpful.

So, let me lay down a few basics. First, there is no perfect candidate. Not one. Anyone that expects to find one is deceiving themselves. I don't. Not the point. Let it go. Second, no politician does everything right and no politician does everything wrong. As the saying goes, "a stopped clock is right twice a day." Similar to "no perfect candidate," then, it's important to note that everyone does something right and something wrong. Third -- and this is just me -- I do not have a representative government. By that I mean that there is no one currently in office or running for office that represents me. It's not there and I don't expect it. That's because a biblical worldview is not electable. Jesus said so (John 15:19). I'm not complaining and I'm not discouraged; it is what it is. No one represents me. Well, maybe a Mike Pence, but he didn't actually get elected, did he? He rode in on Trump's coat tails. I can't imagine the United States electing a Mike Pence for president, for instance. And, truthfully, doing politics changes you. It's hard to be there and maintain a Christian worldview and get anything done. In summary, then, I don't expect a perfect candidate and I don't expect a perfect performance and I don't expect someone who sees things as I do. None of the above. Ain't gonna happen.

So ... why can't I vote for Trump? He's imperfect. He hasn't performed perfectly the past four years. He doesn't represent me. Doesn't that qualify him? No, of course not, and that just my attempt to be humorous.

So, first, we need to be careful. We live in a loud "Trump-hate" world. For instance, the claim that "All living former presidents have publicly denounced Trump" is simply a lie. Bush didn't. (He has remained silent.) That leaves three Democratic presidents who, you would expect, would not endorse or defend the current Republican president. No surprise there. Further, despite claims to the contrary, the media is mostly left. Therefore, the political opinions expressed in those sources will, by definition, be opposed to anything right. Sources, then, are critical in the sense that they tend to be critical and critical in the sense that you need to be very careful about your sources.

There is the question of character. Trump was recorded in 2005 saying that he liked to grab women by a body part for which I won't use his word. That's not a left-wing smear campaign; that's Trump on Trump. The court ordered Trump to pay Stormy Daniels for his battle over hush money he paid. Oh, he paid it; he was just fighting that it was wrong for her not to hush up when he paid her to. No one really doubts that over his lifetime Trump has been an adulterer. There are lots of other questions of morality. It looks a lot like nepotism. It looks a lot like inappropriate relationships with family. It looks a lot like favoritism and cronyism. But we can debate that stuff. We can discuss the reasons, but it is undeniable that Trump's administration has been a "revolving door." They come and they go. Some leave out of disgust. Some leave out of disagreement (on one side or the other). Some even appear to leave from Trump's vindictiveness. It's disturbing the number of "pro-Trump" people who have come out of his orbit with a grudge. Trump's reputation from before his election was characterized in two words: "You're fired." It appears to not be a line from a reality show, but a character point. "Agree with me or face my wrath." And then there's Twitter. The worst place to look for Trump's positives is Trump's Twitter feed. Don't go there. Even the pro-Trump folk cringe from much of what he says there. The right mocks Biden for his verbal slip ups and, perhaps, rightly so, but it often is out of misdirection. "Don't look at what Trump said about drinking bleach; look at what Biden said about smelling women's hair." Not favorable.

Then there is his record. Pro-Trump folk claim, for instance, that "Trump has done the most to oppose LGBT issues." Really? According to USA Today, "LGBT Americans belong in Donald Trump's Republican Party." The author says, "Trump's agenda has been a boon to the gay community." The Federalist, a right-wing source, says, "Trump has been one of the greatest presidents for LGBTQ Americans in history." On his work for religious freedom, again, there is major disagreement. He's done some good and some harm. "'Far from protecting religious freedom, he's undermining it at every turn,' said Maggie Garrett, the vice president for public policy for Americans United for Separation of Church and State." The Frank Report lists "One-Hundred-Twenty-Five Amazing Accomplishments of President Donald J. Trump" including things like making animal abuse a federal offense and ordering his openly gay ambassador to Germany to lead a global initiative to decriminalize homosexual behavior across the globe. No president does everything right and no president does everything wrong, but raving about how wonderful Trump has been is more likely a "never Biden" call rather than a "he's our guy!" shout.

So, I'm going to vote. I'm going to express my opinion. I am going to deny that not voting for Trump is a vote for Biden because no one ever says, "Not voting for Biden is a vote for Trump" and because that is a fundamental denial of both "a vote is an expression of my opinion" and "Your vote counts." I'm going to deny it because it also assumes that God can't work without my vote in His favor. So I will vote. I will be disappointed in who wins. I will be castigated for failing to do what's right ... by people "on my side." I will be chastized by believers for trusting God on this. I get all that. I'm not upset; it's just the way it is. But my opinion still matters and I will express it. I will vote my conscience even if it doesn't agree with yours.

4 comments:

Craig said...

Well said.

Marshal Art said...

Not well said at all, really, particularly given some proven falsehoods, and other falsehoods unique to this post that by their presence belies the praise Stan's point was well said.

Stan said...

Proven falsehoods? Would that be the part where Trump admits to adultery or the part where Trump actually did pay the porn star hush money (his claim, not mine) or the claim that they call it a "revolving door administration" because of so many people coming and going or ...? Which were the "proven falsehoods"? He certainly has several family members on his staff (which is the definition of "nepotism").

I didn't include "Trump is a racist" because, having heard what he said versus what the left heard doesn't match up. I didn't include the accusations from Trump haters (whether they were always Trump-haters or just became Trump-haters after they were fired). I didn't include the story about the Fox reporter who told about the story of Trump maligning the military -- unconfirmed. That is, I pointedly avoided putting things in that were either questionable or untrue. I am unaware of any "proven falsehoods."

Craig said...

Stan,

I think that your point about Trump's policies being beneficial to the LGBT community is interesting. From a purely political standpoint, I think it's not a bad move. There is some percentage of the LGBT community that leans conservative on many issues, and it's logical that they would be welcomed in the GOP. Yet, as a Christian, some might not see this friendliness to the LGBT community as a positive. There's definitely a line between what's a good political move and what is in agreement with peoples beliefs.

Not to equate the two, but I keep seeing that Trump could pull double digit support from the African American community. Some are predicting that it'll be high enough to tilt the election to him. I think that (politically) anytime that it's possible to shift even a percentage of any of the knee jerk DFL constituencies to the GOP it's politically beneficial for many policy positions that I support.

As someone who's enjoyed the political "inside baseball" for years, it's hard but necessary to differentiate what is politically expedient from what is morally problematic.

Which is exactly where the decision to vote for Trump leads us.