It has been around for some time, obviously, but not like this. For a long time you could find some sort of online service for people like shut-ins or on a Sunday when the family was sick or something. It's not new. But, in a way, it is. It is in the age of COVID. It's new in the sense of "normal" where it was once "outside of normal." More and more people have been forced to experience online services rather than in-person services because, well, social distancing and all that. I mean, you don't want to kill someone, do you? Besides, the government deemed your First Amendment right to the free exercise of religion as nonessential, so there was no choice.
Things are starting to open up again. Our church has restarted. Well, sort of. You need to schedule a service because seating is limited. You need to wear a mask because the government says so. No hugging your church family now. Stay 6' apart. Sort of open. They still offer the online service and some of the groups also offer a Zoom option, but it's sort of open. What it is not is "the same." It wasn't the same when it was remote; it's not the same with its current limitations in person. It is different enough that some have come back, sampled the "new normal," and decided it wasn't for them. "We'll wait until the old normal returns," they say.
How many will that be? Worse, how many will not return? How many are finding advantages in the online version? "You know, it's kind of nice not to have to dress for church. It's kind of nice to able to have Sundays free and pick another time to catch the service. It's kind of nice to be able to mute the pastor at times or the songs we don't particularly enjoy. When they're praying, I get the chance to slip out and get some coffee without disturbing anyone." And so it goes. Predictions say that upwards of a third of regular churchgoers may cease to be churchgoers. Why? Because churchgoers are thinking like consumers and not like "the body of Christ."
I've written in the past about the "one anothers." Christianity is very much about others, starting, at its core, with "love God and love one another." The Bible says we are gifted by the Spirit "for the common good." (1 Cor 12:7) That is, 1) every believer has a gift (or more) and 2) the purpose of all gifts is "the common good." The church isn't designed for bringing people to Christ (although that can happen in a church) or a social club (although it should be sociable for believers especially); the design is "for building up the body of Christ until we all attain to the unity of the faith ..." (Eph 4:12-13). This cannot happen in the electronic church.
I start to wonder. There are lots of issues we see in today's church. There is a lack of biblical depth. There is often an absence of the practice of spiritual gifts. There are false teachers and wolves in sheep's clothing and personal conflicts that should never be part of a church. And these aren't new. They were present in biblical days. But they were addressed then while today many consider them normal. We live in a time when church is a commodity. Like some smorgasbord, we look around for what we like and see if we can get fed. We go to get, not to give. We are often not particularly dedicated or invested in a local body. It's just ... something we do. "I'm not too keen on the music at this church. Can we find something more entertaining?"
As it turns out, then, this COVID problem appears to be unearthing a church problem, because if we can be happy with a remote church experience, we don't really know what church is about. If we can be happy with no church experience, we really don't know what Christianity is all about. I'm starting to think that a pandemic is not really a good thing, but if it reveals some real problems that we can see and address, I guess a pandemic isn't all bad, is it?
6 comments:
I completely agree with this take. I would say that many of us aren't necessarily "happy" about video church, but realize that it's better than nothing.
I'm convinced that we are created for community and that anything less than physical proximity will not satisfy that need for community. I believe that the failure to acknowledge that this sort of community is essential, is why we are seeing increases in mental health issues the longer this goes on.
I will say that while video church isn't an acceptable substitute for live church, I think that the churches who learn to do it well will eventually better serve those who have no options for church other than video. I think this could end up being a small positive note in all of this. Unfortunately, I suspect that there will be plenty of churches and churchgoers who will settle for convenience and go all in on video church.
There are definitely those who cannot make it to church and we definitely need to be sure to minister to them, to bring the "one another" to them.
Yes, and I hope that this experience allows churches to do that part of ministry at a much higher level of quality. It definitely needs to be augmented by actual human contact though.
I was talking yesterday with some friends about the whole issue of communion. It's interesting because there is an obvious expectation of the community physically gathering to participate, yet I suspect this isn't the first time in history that believers haven't been able to gather for communion, and it probably won't be the last. I feel confident that there is a element of heart and motivation that is in play in these circumstances that we can't quite account for. While I'm sympathetic to those who argue that physical gathering is so vital to celebrating the Lord's Supper that it's better to postpone it, rather than celebrate remotely, I suspect that this might be an area where it's better to offer grace and charity to those who disagree.
That was exactly what I was thinking when I mentioned those who cannot make it. Imagine a ministry that would have people who go to the homes of those who can't come and be with them for the online service, spend time, minister, communicate. I know some pastors visit the house-bound, but I'd like to see more of it.
And I agree that grace and charity on this issue is absolutely necessary among churches. I can't find, "Thou shalt not be closed during a pandemic" anywhere in my Bible. In fact, I can't find, "Thou shalt build large buildings and assemble what will be called 'megachurches' in the future." So grace and charity is important here.
Grace and charity are almost always important, that's why it's so interesting to see a lack of both on the part of some.
I've seen what you're talking about, even, sadly, among Christians. I wonder how much is a carry-over from today's easily-offended culture.
Post a Comment