Like Button

Sunday, November 15, 2009

"You don't understand!"

Most who are or who ever have been teenagers have, regarding someone in authority, either thought or said at some point, "You don't understand!" Kids of that age are pretty sure they know everything and when they are denied what they "know" to be a good thing, it's not pretty. Usually, of course, the authority figure (parent or otherwise) really does understand better than the teen realizes, but that's not how it feels.

We have a relationship with the Ultimate Authority, Jesus Christ. Sometimes He tells us things we don't like. And sometimes, either in the midst of His commands or just in the midst of life, we can think or even say, "You don't understand!" We're commanded to do things we don't very much like or we're denied things we very much wanted or ... you get the idea. How could He understand? He's God. He doesn't suffer. He doesn't lose. He never even sinned, for pity sake. And then we read this:
We do not have a high priest who cannot sympathize with our weaknesses, but One who has been tempted in all things as we are, yet without sin. Therefore let us draw near with confidence to the throne of grace, so that we may receive mercy and find grace to help in time of need (Heb 4:15-16).
On earth, Jesus experienced every form of temptation and trial that we do. Being human, He endured it all. Being God, He knows the best. He understands.

The author of Hebrews concludes that because He understands first hand, we can "draw near with confidence to the throne of grace, so that we may receive mercy and find grace to help in time of need." Like teenagers lashing out at our "foolish" parents, it turns out that we're wrong. He does understand and we can come to Him for the grace and mercy that we need ... even when it doesn't feel like it.

Saturday, November 14, 2009

I'm a Radical

There, I said it. I'm a radical, and I will proclaim it openly.

The dictionary has a list of definitions for the word, radical". Among them are the normal concepts that we're used to. There is "extreme" and "favoring drastic political, economic, or social reforms". Yeah, that's what we're familiar with. In the noun form, the first definition is "a person who holds or follows strong convictions or extreme principles; extremist". Yeah, yeah, that's it. Oh, wait ... "follows strong convictions"? Now, that's not quite what we had in mind. Interestingly, the very first (and then repeated on down the line in various ways) definition is "of or going to the root or origin". Synonyms include "basic", "essential", and "original".

The Latin source means "having roots". The original sense of the term meant a return to the roots. In the early 19th century, a group of men formed the Radical Movement seeking political reforms for the government. They were the first real push behind parliamentary representation and formed the basis for what would become the Labour Party in the UK today. Their opponents dismissed them and labeled them "radicals" for their reforms, and since then the concept of any extremist thinking has been labeled "radical" even if it isn't reform.

Me? I'm a Christian radical. I believe that too much theology today has drifted away from any genuine roots in both Scripture and historic Christianity. We find way too much "self-styled Christianity" that urges a feel-good approach both from the "name it and claim it" side as well as the liberal "social gospel" side. Instead of defining Christian theology from its root source of the Bible, too many have defined it by how it makes them feel or how it looks to others. If it appears, for instance, "too judgmental" or "too intolerant", they toss it out without regard to the reason that it's there. That is, if God is judgmental and intolerant about something, then His followers also ought to be.

So I'm a radical. I am in favor of a return to the genuine roots of Christian doctrine. Sometimes that won't feel very nice. Sometimes it may appear offensive, judgmental, intolerant, harsh. Sometimes it will feel ... radical. But I am in favor of a return to the source. The standard dictionary term for this, of course, has become its own pejorative: "fundamentalism". That was a return to the fundamentals ... you know, like the original definition of "radical".

I'm a radical, and I will proclaim it openly. In fact, you ought to be one, too.

Friday, November 13, 2009

God wants you to be happy

Facebook has an application called "On this day, God wants you to know ...". The application generates randomized feel-good messages from God. You know, things like "On this day, God wants you to know ... that you are unique and precious." More verbage, to be sure, but those kinds of things.

The other day one of my friends got this one:
On this day, God wants you to know...
... that you deserve happiness just because. There is nothing you need to do to deserve happiness. There are no 'minimal requirements' for you to fulfill before you can claim happiness. You deserve happiness simply by virtue of having been born. That's it. Nothing more is required. Be happy.
Mmm, yeah, that just feels so nice. Of course, it would be best, if you want to be most comfortable, not to ask questions like "Is it true?"

You see, it begs the question. Is it actually true that simply because you were born you deserve happiness? More so, is that God's big desire for you -- happiness? Are humans, as a right of birth, deserving of happiness? We'd like to think so, to be sure. We'd like to think that humans deserve happiness. McDonalds would like us to think so, wouldn't they? "You deserve a break today," they tell us. We're pretty sure that the pursuit of happiness is one of those inalienable rights endowed by our Creator (even though that Creator has been asked to leave our government, our schools, our public places, etc.). It is in the Declaration of Independence, you know ... a valid source of theological truth, I'm sure. God loves you and wants most of all for you to be happy. Sure it's true!

If you haven't figured it out by now, I'm skeptical. I don't actually think that God's highest priority is my happiness. Nor do I believe that just because I was born I deserve happiness. Why? Well, to me it's neither biblical nor rational. That is, it's not what the Bible seems to say and it doesn't make much sense to me.

Consider, for instance, the wrath of God. It's not a small subject in the Bible. So prevalent in the Old Testament was it that some considered the God of the Old Testament to be a different God than in the New Testament. Still, it doesn't take a lot of reading in the New Testament to find out that wrath is still there. There are warnings and curses and danger for all of us, but especially for the unbeliever. There is the promise of "scourging" from God to His own children. However you interpret "scourging", it cannot be read as "happiness". Indeed, it says, "For the moment all discipline seems painful rather than pleasant." And Paul tells us "It has been granted to you that for the sake of Christ you should not only believe in him but also suffer for His sake." Yippee! Suffering for Christ! Let's do the "happy dance"! No, that's not right.

Am I suggesting that God is a mean 'ol fellow, a cosmic killjoy, some divine curmudgeon who only wants to torment us? Not at all! The rest of the verse I mentioned about the unpleasantness of discipline ends this way: "... But later it yields the peaceful fruit of righteousness to those who have been trained by it." We have a promise that God works all things together for good to those who love God. We know that Christ's payment on our behalf has taken away God's wrath toward us. So what am I suggesting? I'm suggesting that God is much more mature than your average 2-year-old. All youngster knows is "Make me feel good now." His parents, on the other hand, know better. There are times that little Johnny needs to be made uncomfortable, like when he needs vaccinations or when he needs discipline. Why do his parents do that, knowing that little Johnny will not be happy? They do it because they are most concerned not with his immediate comfort, but with his best interests. And that is God's concern. First, God is concerned about His own best interests. He needs to be ... He's God. Then He's concerned with the best interests of His children. Now, remember, there is a biblical definition for "His children", and it's not "all human beings". "To all who did receive Him, who believed in His name, to them He gave the right to become children of God." It makes sense in human terms that a loving parent would be most interested in the best interests of a child. It only makes sense that a loving God would be primarily concerned with not so much the happiness, the best interests of His own children.

Does God want you to know, then, that you deserve happiness? I don't think so. Does simply being human mean that you deserve happiness? Certainly not! Remember, there are "vessels of wrath prepared for destruction". They shouldn't be counting on God's generosity. There are what Paul refers to as vessels "for dishonorable use". There are those who are "children of your father, the devil". Being human does not confer, then, the divine right to happiness. Don't let someone try to convince you otherwise. If you're a child of the King, He has much better things in mind for you than paltry happiness. Count on it.

Thursday, November 12, 2009

The Factious Man

I was reading the other day in Titus and came across this: "Reject a factious man after a first and second warning, knowing that such a man is perverted and is sinning, being self-condemned" (Titus 3:10-11). Now, I have a pretty good vocabulary, so I was pretty sure I knew what "factious" meant, but better to check and be sure than to assume and be wrong.

Interestingly, the original (transliterated) word is "hairetikos". I'm pretty sure you can tell what word we get from that. In fact, the King James (and others) translates it "Reject an heretic ...". Okay, okay, we all know what a heretic is ... or, at least, we think we do. But what does the Greek word mean? " The origin is actually in the word that means "to choose" and references choices that are made. In context, it is the choice to be schismatic or to be presenting schismatic choices. In English, as far as Christianity goes, "heretic" references one who maintains religious opinions contrary to those accepted by the Church. It would stand to reason, from that, that the translation, "Reject a factious man ..." would make sense, since someone maintaining positions contrary to the Church would be causing division.

Now, I'm not, in this entry, willing to analyze "heresy". I'm not going to debate "doctrines accepted by the Church" either individually or as a concept. Here's what I'm wondering. Do we do this? Are we supposed to warn people, "You're being factious; you're causing division; you're being disruptive" and, after a couple of warnings, reject them? If so, what does that rejection look like? (Yes, if you haven't figured it out yet, this is another my question posts.)

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

No one does good

Now, I know that at least one of my readers is going to think, "This is aimed at me." Relax. It's not. The argument put forward by that reader/commenter isn't new. And it deserves a proper examination. So, if you feel like I'm talking about you personally, let me say that I'm not in the least. This is a discussion about an idea that has been floated for a long time.

The passage of Scripture in question here comes from Romans 3. I'll put it down here for reference:
9 What then? Are we better than they? Not at all; for we have already charged that both Jews and Greeks are all under sin; 10 as it is written, "There is none righteous, not even one; 11 there is none who understands, there is none who seeks for God; 12 all have turned aside, together they have become useless; there is none who does good, there is not even one." 13 "their throat is an open grave, with their tongues they keep deceiving," "the poison of asps is under their lips"; 14 "whose mouth is full of cursing and bitterness"; 15 "their feet are swift to shed blood, 16 destruction and misery are in their paths, 17 and the path of peace they have not known." 18 "There is no fear of god before their eyes" (Rom 3:9-18).
Here's the problem. People who believe that the Bible is the inerrant Word of God want to read this (and everything else) as literally as they possibly can. Still, this one is problematic. We're fine with a literal "There is none righteous" because we know that just a few verses later we will read, "All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God," and this agrees with that. But after that it gets a bit dicey. Really? None who understands? None who seeks for God? I mean, we have all heard testimonies of people who had a long search for God and finally found Him in Christ ... right? Sure, all have turned aside, but we really don't like that "they have become useless" thing much. And that claim that there is none who does good is really over the top.

One side of the discussion takes that claim literally and the other considers it hyperbole. Why? Well, because we know lots of good people who do good, so it can't be literal. If we admit that there is none who does good, and it is good to receive Christ, then we have a real problem, don't we? Of course, if you're not paying attention, the other side has a problem all its own. You see, if you stand on "It's intended to be absolutely literal," you've created a problem. The easiest way to illustrate the problem is to point to Jesus. He was sinless, right? So ... no one does good? It is, then, a problem for both sides. One side dismisses it as an overstatement and is left with no meaning, and the other side embraces it as absolute and denies Christianity. How do we handle this sticky situation?

I'm sure this will make some people happy, but let me say at the outset that the statement is hyperbole. Hyperbole is a figure of speech that makes an extravagant statement to make a point. We're used to it. And this one is hyperbole. We know this because we can name one person who did good, so "no not one" can't mean actually "not one". Further, we all claim that Christians do good ... or, at least, we're supposed to. So more than one does good. It is hyperbole. It is an intentional overstatement to make a point. There, I said it.

"Oh, good, now we're back at the other side that says it was hyperbole and we don't have to worry about it, right? We're all clear that lots of people do lots of good." And now we've walked into the other problem. We all know lots of people who do lots of good. So, if we admit that the claim that there is none who does good isn't actually literally true, what does it mean? I'll tell you what it cannot mean. It cannot mean that lots of people do lots of good. You see, hyperbole is intended to make a point. If "There is none who does good" is intended to convey "Lots of people do lots of good", we've erased any connection to rationality. It cannot mean that people do good all the time. You see, hyperbole has a purpose. It is intended to make a point. When the gospel writer says, "The whole city came out to see Jesus", I assume that the whole city didn't actually come out to see Jesus, but I'm pretty sure the vast majority did. If the truth turned out to be that only 95% came out, I'd say, "Yeah, that makes sense." If the truth turned out to be that only 5% came out, I'd say, "Huh? In what sense does 'the whole city' make that point?" The point of the that hyperbole was "a vast majority". The point of this hyperbole can only be that doing good is extremely rare, and the only remaining question is "How rare?" If the answer is "Oh, lots of people do good," then the hyperbole is meaningless.

So let's examine the text and see what we can find. What was the original question? Well, the short term question was "Are we (Jews) better than they (Gentiles)?" The answer was intended to be a resounding, "No!" The passage, in fact, is at the tail end of a long dissertation on the sinfulness of Man that started way back in Rom. 1:18. Paul is laying down the problem (bad news) for which the Gospel (good news) has an answer. The problem? This passage, then, is the summary, and the summary is that all are under sin. The problem is that both Jews and Gentiles are under sin, slaves to sin, without hope in themselves. There is no solution that we can drum up on our own. Reading on past this section, we find the solution that God provides. Chapter 6 tells us that God's solution to our problem of sin is ... death.
Or do you not know that all of us who have been baptized into Christ Jesus have been baptized into His death? Therefore we have been buried with Him through baptism into death, so that as Christ was raised from the dead through the glory of the Father, so we too might walk in newness of life (Rom 6:3-4).
This puts those "who have been baptized into Christ Jesus" in a different position than those who have not. Those who have not are slaves to sin. Paul tells those that have "do not let sin reign in your mortal body so that you obey its lusts", an option that a slave to sin does not have.

So where are we now? First, there is Natural Man. Natural Man is sinful by nature. God's description is "every intent of the thoughts of his heart is only evil continually." Paul's description is "dead in your trespasses and sins", "walking according to the prince of the power of the air," and "by nature children of wrath". Given this nature, it makes sense that "There is none who does good." In fact, given this description, if anyone does actually do what God considers good, it would be a choice that was against his own nature. Violating what you want to do would normally be recognized as a violation of free will. We call it "coercion". The hyperbole, then, that "there is none who does good" is appropriate 1) when you consider the standard that God uses for "good", 2) you recognize that Natural Man has no inclination to do what God recognizes as "good", and 3) there is a group of humans who, having died to their old selves, have a new nature with new inclinations to do the good that God considers good.

If you want to argue "It is hyperbole; lots of people do good", you've eliminated any meaning. If you want to hold to "There is none who does good" completely, you eliminate Christ as well as His followers. If you want to understand the intent of the statement, you need to see that righteousness does not exist among fallen Man, that doing good doesn't happen in fallen Man, and that the only answer to that problem is to die with Christ. A radical problem, you see, demands a radical solution. Or, you might see it as a not-so-bad problem. People aren't perfect, sure, but they're not all that bad. So what's the point of such hyperbole (as well as 3 chapters of explaining the sinfulness of Man) if it's just not that bad? I agree that it's hyperbole; I simply believe that it has meaning that is not so far from its extreme.

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

What Grace Does

One of the biggest distinctives about Christianity from other religions is this whole "saved by faith" thing. All other religions are on a "saved by works" plan. Christianity alone claims "saved by faith apart from works". This, of course, causes no end of problems. James assures us that faith without works is dead faith, not saving faith. So genuine, biblical, saving faith produces works, but is not conditioned on works. In the Reformation, the reformers held to "sola fide", saved by faith alone. The Roman Catholic Church protested. "That would mean that it doesn't matter what you do!" The reformers answered, "We're saved by faith alone, but not by faith that is alone." And today the problem continues. Many have confused the social gospel with the real Gospel. The "good news" is that we can be nice to people. In fact, the social gospel is a product of genuine faith, not an aim.

I was thinking about all this because I ran across this passage in Titus and found it interesting as it relates to the topic:
11 For the grace of God has appeared, bringing salvation for all people, 12 training us to renounce ungodliness and worldly passions, and to live self-controlled, upright, and godly lives in the present age, 13 waiting for our blessed hope, the appearing of the glory of our great God and Savior Jesus Christ, 14 who gave himself for us to redeem us from all lawlessness and to purify for himself a people for his own possession who are zealous for good works (Titus 2:11-14).
The topic here is "the grace of God" (one of the five "solas"). Like faith, we think of grace as something given, not something that actually does something. Look, however, at what Paul has the grace of God doing.

The grace of God has brought salvation. Yeah, that's the kind of thing that we would imagine grace doing. But there's more. There is another function of grace listed here: "Training us". That's right, the grace of God trains us. What does it train us to do? Well, it's a list of things ... a list of works. It is God's grace that teaches us to renounce godliness and worldly passions, to live self-controlled, upright, and godly lives, to wait for our blessed hope. Isn't that interesting? God's grace trains us to be what God wants us to be.

I maintain that the Bible teaches that we are saved by grace alone through faith alone. Works are not a factor. On the other hand, faith without works is not genuine, saving faith, and the grace of God teaches us to be godly. So, while works are not a part of our salvation, neither can they be ignored. Without the natural by-product of works, there is reason to question whether you have either grace or faith. We are saved apart from works, but works are a part of grace and faith.

Monday, November 09, 2009

The Effect of the Will on Salvation

It is the common belief that we become Christians by choosing Christ. You know how it is. You are told that you need salvation and you choose to accept Christ. Bingo! You're saved! Is that really how it works?

Paul was explicit. "For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast (Eph 2:8-9)." Why is salvation a gift? "That no one may boast." But if salvation is based on our making the right choice, isn't that something about which to boast?

Imagine the conversation you might have with yourself. "Why am I a Christian when others are not? Well, clearly I made the right choice and others did not. So ... why did I make the right choice and they didn't? Well, apparently I'm smarter than they are. No, wait ... that can't be right. No, it must be that I'm just more spiritually in tune. No, no, that's a problem, too. I'm more aware? No. Hmmm." You see, if salvation is based on your proper choice, it requires that there is something about you that is better than those who make the improper choice, and that is something about which to boast.

There is, of course, a volitional factor in salvation. We are required to place our faith in Christ to be saved. But is that a product of our choice, or not? The Bible says it is not.
All who did receive Him, who believed in His name, He gave the right to become children of God, who were born, not of blood nor of the will of the flesh nor of the will of man, but of God (John 1:12-13).

So then it depends not on human will or exertion, but on God, who has mercy (Rom 9:16).
John's gospel says that it is specifically not the result of the will of man. Paul says it is not our actions or our choices. We are not saved because we make the right choice. Instead, we are saved because God chooses to have compassion on some and to harden others (Rom 9:18). Yes, we make the right choice, but that's not the deciding factor. God alone is.

Sunday, November 08, 2009

The Promise

I really like this opening of Paul's letter to Titus:
1 Paul, a bond-servant of God and an apostle of Jesus Christ, for the faith of those chosen of God and the knowledge of the truth which is according to godliness, 2 in the hope of eternal life, which God, who cannot lie, promised long ages ago, 3 but at the proper time manifested, even His word, in the proclamation with which I was entrusted according to the commandment of God our Savior, 4 To Titus, my true child in a common faith: Grace and peace from God the Father and Christ Jesus our Savior (Titus 1:1-4).
Paul talks about "the faith of those chosen of God", and I like that. I have nothing about which to boast. I came to faith because God chose. Paul connects "knowledge of the truth" with "godliness". So many argue that doctrine isn't important, but Paul thinks that knowledge of the truth is interlinked with godliness.

It's the next phrase, though, that just thrills my heart. We have faith that we will have eternal life. Where did that concept come from? It came from God. He cannot lie. And before time (the literal translation of "long ages ago"), God promised that those He chose would have eternal life. It is that promise on which we rest. Nice! But think about this. If God made this promise before time, to whom did He make it? It wasn't to us. We weren't there. It wasn't to the angels. They were created around the same time we were, and, besides, it wouldn't matter if they were promised that we have eternal life. No, what we're looking at here is an inter-trinitarian promise. I fancy that it went something like this.

Father: "Son, I have a plan. How would you like a Bride?"

Son: "Excellent! Of course, she would have to be perfect."

Father: "Oh, of course! So here's my plan. I'm going to make a race of humans in our image. Out of that race we'll establish your Bride."

Son: "I like it!"

Father: "There's a catch, Son. They will sin. They will rebel. And since you need a perfect Bride, we will need to act to make them perfect again."

Son: "Seems good to Me."

Father: "That means that you'll have to die for them."

Son: "Great!"

Father: "Okay then! Let's get started. Spirit, you move across the face of the waters and then ..."

Do you get the impact of this notion? We are not chosen by God because we're so lovable. We're not saved because we're worth it. It is not intrinsic value that forces God to pull us out of damnation. No, it is Divine love for His Son. We are a gift from Father to Son, a love gift. He promised His Son before time began that He would do it, and we are the fulfilment of that promise. Wow!

Saturday, November 07, 2009

Last Days Madness

1 But realize this, that in the last days difficult times will come. 2 For men will be lovers of self, lovers of money, boastful, arrogant, revilers, disobedient to parents, ungrateful, unholy, 3 unloving, irreconcilable, malicious gossips, without self-control, brutal, haters of good, 4 treacherous, reckless, conceited, lovers of pleasure rather than lovers of God, 5 holding to a form of godliness, although they have denied its power; Avoid such men as these. 6 For among them are those who enter into households and captivate weak women weighed down with sins, led on by various impulses, 7 always learning and never able to come to the knowledge of the truth. (2 Tim 3:1-7).
I don't know about you, but I find this disturbing. It reads like a standard description of Americans in general. It certainly seems to describe our world.

There are some interesting points. That "lovers of self" would be first on the list is telling. That "disobedient to their parents" is on the list at all is surprising ... at least to most. I mean, listing off things like "treacherous" and "brutal" and "lovers of pleasure" ... sure, but disobedient to parents? It appears to be somewhat important to God, yet that's what too many parents today teach their kids. I was interested in the "unloving" there in verse 3. In Greek they have four basic words for "love": agape, philos, eros, and storge. The first two appear quite often in Scripture. The third doesn't, but I don't think it needs additional definition. The last one, on the other hand, doesn't actually appear in the Bible ... sort of. Storge is generally the concept of family affection. The word doesn't appear in the Bible, but astorge does, with the "a" prefix meaning "not". It appears here. The claim is that people will lose what is considered to be natural affection. And when you read the news about mothers abandoning children and father abandoning families and parents murdering their children and ... well, you get the idea. It's jarring. And the Bible called it.

Here's the most disturbing part. We can all sit around, nod our heads, and say, "Oh, how bad that this describes our society." But Paul warns Timothy "Avoid such men as these." Now, Paul was explicit earlier in his letter to the church at Corinth. "I wrote you in my letter not to associate with immoral people; I did not at all mean with the immoral people of this world, or with the covetous and swindlers, or with idolaters, for then you would have to go out of the world" (1 Cor 5:9-10). Paul warned them to avoid any "so-called brother" who was like this. He's doing the same here. These people are not "the world". They are inside the church. They are the religious. They ... are us. This warning about the last days is not a description of pagan America. It is a description of Christendom in the last days. And, sadly, it is too close to an appropriate description of many in our churches today. They hold to a form of godliness, but deny its power. They are always learning but never actually come to the knowledge of the truth. They seem to be caring, but are actually weighed down by sin and controlled by impulses. That is what I find disturbing. I expect the world to be sinful, but those who claim the name of "Christian" ought to be different. Are we?

Friday, November 06, 2009

Why I Believe

Why do I believe what I believe regarding Christianity? Well, there is certainly a large intellectual component to it. I am convinced, based on evidence and reason, that Christianity is true. I am convinced that the Bible is God-breathed and, therefore, inerrant. I can see things like fulfilled prophecy and the fact that it was written by some 40 authors over thousands of years without contradiction and with a single message and that's evidence. I am convinced by that same Bible that Christ, God's Son, became flesh and died for my sin, paying my debt. I am convinced that the God of the Bible is truly and uniquely Sovereign (capital "S"). The evidence, the texts, the reasoning all bring me to this place. A lot of people seem to have some rational difficulties, but in my mind I see a seamless structure that all just makes sense to me. (That is not to suggest that I understand everything. "Don't fully understand" is not the same as "Doesn't make sense".) In fact, a good portion of my theology has been arrived at against what I was taught earlier in life and told in more popular Christian circles. I didn't get here because I necessarily liked it or because I was brought up this way. I have become convinced by evidence and reason.

If I were to tell you that the only reason that I believe what I believe is evidence and reason, however, I would be less than honest. Very little in life, in fact, is that simple. Most things are complicated. There is a strong intellectual component to my beliefs, but there is also an important emotional component. Having arrived where I am theologically, I have become quite attached to what I believe. In fact, I will go so far as to say that I need it. I'm perfectly willing to consider other options and there are certainly things that are more peripheral than others, but there are core beliefs that, if you were to strip them away, would devastate me.

Take, for instance, the idea of God's Sovereignty versus Man's Free Will. The by-far most popular belief is that Man has Ultimate Free Will. God doesn't interfere with that. Why would He? He gave Man Free Will and humans can do as they please. Most people like that idea. Me? It terrifies me. If that is, indeed, the truth, then life is hopeless. Some argued, for instance, on 9/11/2001 that "God is a gentleman and doesn't interfere." Don't tell me that! I want to believe that God is in charge. I want to believe that they meant it for evil but God meant it for good. I want to believe that God works all things together for good to those who love God. On the other hand, if God has given free rein to Man, then Man has free reign ... and God does not. (That was not a spelling error in either case.) The image, then, is a god who is there in heaven, ringing his hands, trying to figure out how he's going to pull this one out. "Oh my, oh my ... I wish they wouldn't do that. How terrible! Now what will I do? I'll figure out something." That god inspires no confidence, provides no meaning, and gives no hope in times of crisis.

That's just an example. It actually affects all portions of my life. If I look to Judaism or Islam (or other religions), for instance, I am offered the "hope" of eternal bliss if I just be good enough. "Good enough" is a vague concept that, well, knowing myself, isn't going to happen. Without the Atonement, "good enough" isn't good enough to give me hope. If I look to atheism, I am offered no reason for anything except "Stuff happens". That happy old platitude "Everything happens for a reason" is bunk. Everything just happens. There is no basis for morality, no basis for meaning in life, no answers to evil (a contradiction in terms), and no way to make sense of life. No hope.

You may disagree with my theology. That's perfectly fine. And I'm perfectly willing to 1) discuss it with people who disagree (in a friendly manner) and 2) examine whether or not I might be wrong. You have to realize, however, that there is a lot on this side. My beliefs conform to the Bible as it is written. My beliefs conform to orthodoxy in the historic Church. My beliefs make rational sense to me, carefully enmeshed and intertwined. If you're planning to try to talk me out of it, you will need some new set of information or logic train because I've seen most of them, and you'll need to offer me some sort of hope in life because moving off of where I am thus far appears hopeless. Sure, sure, you're happy with it, but, trust me, I can't go there. Like the hymnist, "My hope is built on nothing less than Jesus' blood and righteousness. I dare not trust the sweetest frame, but wholly lean on Jesus' name." Anything other than the Sovereign God I know, other than orthodoxy, other than an inerrant Bible, other than a Savior who died on my behalf and paid my debt ... anything else may be a sweet frame, but it is not sufficient for my hope. It is ... sinking sand.

Thursday, November 05, 2009

How Free is Free Will?

I am not offering an analysis from philosophy here. I will not provide the popular view. I am going to offer the biblical account and you, the reader, can decide what you believe.

The popular perception is that humans are endowed with "free will", an apparently unlimited capacity to make whatever choice he or she pleases. Of course, a simple examination of that concept will tell you that it just doesn't make sense. You cannot choose to climb to the top of your roof, flap your arms, and fly. You do not have the option to choose to live underwater. These, of course, are silly examples, but the main point is that we cannot freely choose to do things that are outside of our nature. That should pose no problem. It should simply provide some clarity to the concept of "free will".

Enter the biblical pronouncements. The Bible is full of references to making choices. Of that there is no doubt. Perhaps the most famous is Joshua's "Choose this day whom you will serve", followed by the glorious, "But as for me and my house, we will serve the LORD." We are beings with the capacity of volition. But can we choose anything? No, not those things outside of our nature. So what does the Bible have to say about limits to our choices?

Well, from the famous heights of the "Hallelujah Chorus" taken right out of Revelation -- "The Lord God Omnipotent reigneth" -- to the depths of Lamentations -- "Who is there who speaks and it comes to pass, unless the Lord has commanded it?" -- the Bible is full of the Sovereignty of God. In the midst of his worst nightmare, Job asks his tormenters, "Who among all these does not know that the hand of the LORD has done this?" Jeremiah records the prayer of Baruch: "Ah, Lord GOD! It is You who have made the heavens and the earth by Your great power and by Your outstretched arm! Nothing is too hard for You." More than once the psalmists tell us, "Whatever the LORD pleases, He does." Paul tells Timothy that God is the "only Sovereign". We like to say, "Your freedom ends at my nose." The truth is that our freedom to choose ends at God's Divine Will. We cannot choose to do those things that violate God's Ultimate Will.

What else limits our choices? The primary inhibitor to our freedom to choose is ... ourselves -- our nature. We would like to think that any human is fully capable of freely choosing to do good, but God says, "No one does good, not even one." We would like to think that Natural Man has the full ability to choose not to sin, but God says of sinful Man, "Every intention of the thoughts of his heart is only evil continually." Paul describes believers as slaves of righteousness and unbelievers as slaves of sin. We want to believe that Man can choose to come to Christ, but Jesus said, "No man can come to Me unless the Father draws him." We'd like to believe that Man is fully capable of understanding spiritual matters but Paul warns, "Natural Man does not accept the things of the Spirit of God, for they are folly to him, and he is not able to understand them because they are spiritually discerned." We'd love to think that unregenerate human beings can freely choose to love God, but the Bible assures us, "The mind that is set on the flesh is hostile to God, for it does not submit to God's law; indeed, it cannot" and "The flesh profits nothing." How free is that? And there are a number of passages that go something like this:
God may perhaps grant them repentance leading to a knowledge of the truth, and they may come to their senses and escape from the snare of the devil, after being captured by Him to do His will (2 Tim 2:25-26).
"Yeah, yeah," we are tempted to say, "God grants everyone repentance." This claim denies the amazingly tentative nature of the passage. Do you see that? Paul writes with words like "may" and "perhaps" stuck together. The unavoidable conclusion is that God may not grant them repentance. Further, there are two things required here. First, God must grant it; it's not a certainty. Second, the only means of escape from Satan is ... captivity. Yep! These people who may be granted repentance (or may not) can only escape from the snare of the devil after being captured by God.

From a biblical perspective, how free is free will? Well, we're free to operate within the realm of our nature as long as God allows it. That nature, for unbelievers, is a sin nature, so the available choices are to sin a lot or sin a little, but never not to sin. No one does good by God's standards of good. And no one has the capacity to override God's will. In the Garden of Eden, Adam had the capacity not to sin. In the wake of Adam's sin, Natural Man lacks the capacity to not sin. Believers, given a new nature, have the capacity to sin or not sin, to operate in their own strength (sin) or in God's strength (not sin). It is only when we get to heaven that we will lose the capacity to sin. In other words, your free will, while certainly present, isn't nearly as free as you might like to think. That is ... if you believe the biblical version. I do.

Wednesday, November 04, 2009

Civility

This is one of my question posts. I don't have the answers. I'm hoping you can offer some.

I think that in our world today there is a serious lack of civility. When opinions differ, people tend to be mean about it. If someone does something wrong, we don't point it out quietly -- we make a scene about it. We're not civil enough to each other. And it's not just a "worldly" thing. Go to Christian discussions on the web and you'll find Christians arguing with believers and unbelievers in not-so-kind ways -- belittling, insulting, ridiculing. From Congress to the media to your workplace to your home, I suspect that you've experienced this lack of civility of which I speak. We're not as nice to each other as I would like us to be ... as the Bible would call for us to be. Worse, we embrace it, we defend it, we honor it. It disturbs me.

Still, if I were to argue that we should always be civil to each other, I'd be arguing against Scripture. Elijah walked into Ahab's court and, without civility, told him it wouldn't rain because Elijah had prayed for it not to rain. The prophets were known for being forthright instead of civil. You may try to dismiss what Jesus did to the moneychangers in the Temple as a misunderstanding, but there is no mistaking how He spoke to the Pharisees. "Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites!" (And if you understood the Jewish "woe", you'd see it wasn't kind.) Repeatedly He warned them that they were worse than the worst in terms that were not ... civil. When Peter addressed the Jews with the Gospel, he didn't soft pedal it. He told them that they crucified the Messiah. And when Paul confronted Peter's hypocrisy, he did it in public and without civility.

Clearly, then, there are times when civility is not called for. I am quite sure that most of the time we need to be more kind to each other, but there are times when rough, forthright talk is required to make a point. And that is my question. Clearly I think it is not all the times I've seen it done in person and on the Internet. Still, there are times. When? Under what circumstances are we called upon to be painfully honest instead of trying to word things kindly? When is it necessary to be uncivil? What determines those moments? I'd like to know.

Tuesday, November 03, 2009

The Radical Rule

One of the best known rules in the Bible is the Golden Rule. It's called in philosophical circles "the ethic of reciprocity". You know: "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. Jesus said, "Whatever you wish that others would do to you, do also to them" (Matt 7:12). Ask someone to explain what it means and you'll generally get something like this: "Don't do things to other people that you wouldn't want done to you." This concept is found in a wide variety of "scriptures", instructions for a variety of religions. You'll find it in the Bahá'í faith, Brahmanism, Buddhism, Confucianism, Ancient Egyptian, Hinduism, Islam, Jainism, Judaism, Native American Spirituality, Roman Pagan Religion, Shinto, Sikhism, Sufism, Taoism, Unitarianism, Wicca, and Zoroastrianism ... to name a few. It's not rocket science. We teach it to our kids. "How would you like it if someone did that to you?" Don't do to others what you don't want others to do to you.

While it's clear that Jesus included that thought in His command, this is not what Jesus said. Sure, that's good practice, but Jesus said something different. We see a lot of commands stated in the negative: "Thou shalt not ..." And the general understanding is in the negative: "Don't do ..." But Jesus's command was in the positive: "Do." And that makes this command somewhat more radical than we tend to think of it.

The question is not "How would you like it if someone did that to you?" The question is "What do I like?" followed by "Go and do thou likewise." Do you like people to be nice to you? Be nice to people. Do you want someone to comfort you when you're sad? Comfort people. Do you want people to be understanding when you make a mistake? Be understanding. When you are remorseful for doing something wrong, you want forgiveness. Forgive. In other words, the command is not to avoid harm, but to affect pleasure. Give to people around you the good that you would want them to give to you.

Face it ... we're not so good at that. We may avoid hurting people whenever we can, but we're not good at looking to find good things to do to people. We're good at finding out where others are wrong, but are we correcting them because we would want to be corrected (and in a way we would want to be corrected), or are we doing it for personal satisfaction? When we have excess, do we seek people to whom to give it? I know I'd appreciate it if someone who had extra would share with me. Are we telling the truth in love? I know that I appreciate the wounds of a friend because I know that friend cares. Are we actively seeking to do the good to others that we would like done to us? That is the Golden Rule. And that is radical.

Monday, November 02, 2009

The New Commandments

Thou shalt have no gods. Being "spiritual" is okay. A general belief in the existence of God is okay. And a general inclusion of all "gods" is just fine. But none of this "One True God" thing.

Thou shalt not have anything but images. The only true source of truth is science, and anyone who predicates their worldview on the Divine is wrong at best and evil at worst.

Thou shalt not bow down to your God. Humans are the most important beings in existence. All values follow. You may believe in this "God" of yours, but He has to submit to human standards and measurements.

Remember to party. Personal pleasure is the ultimate value. The worst thing you can be is boring.

Honor yourself. No one is more important than you are, and thinking of yourself first is the "greatest love of all".

Thou shalt not murder ... unless, of course, that murder takes place as a result of "a woman's choice", in which case it's a marvelous thing.

Thou shalt not commit adultery. Okay, only kidding on that one. It violates the "Personal pleasure as ultimate" rule.

Thou shalt not steal. Only talking here in mass quantities. There is great value if you can, for instance, steal from the government by cheating on your taxes. It's perfectly acceptable to steal time (and small office supplies) from your employer. We're just talking here about ... my stuff. Thou shalt not steal my stuff.

Thou shalt not lie if it isn't in your own best interest.

Thou shalt not condemn your neighbor or your neighbor's wife or his male servant or most anyone at all. That's our job.

Above all else, it is certainly evil to be sure. All of these things are pretty sure, but maybe not. What we require of you is that you do not claim to be confident of your beliefs to the exclusion of other beliefs. That kind of certainty is wrong ... and we will exclude your beliefs for having that belief.

Sunday, November 01, 2009

Teaching and Singing

Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly, teaching and admonishing one another in all wisdom, singing psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, with thankfulness in your hearts to God (Col 3:16).
Interesting concept. Teach and admonish with psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs. Do it as a product of gratitude towards God. Sounds a bit odd, I think, but interesting. Hey, maybe today would be a good day to try it.

Saturday, October 31, 2009

Sovereign ... or not?

In a recent conversation that wandered from "Can you lose your salvation?" to "free will", I made this statement: "You have a very scary God whose will is held captive by His creatures, since He is obligated to always allow them to do whatever they want to do. It is inevitable that at some point someone will do something that will be outside of God's will and God's sovereignty will be completely terminated (instead of 'mostly dead' like it is now)." This elicited the very understandable "Huh??!!" kind of response. "Are you saying that people NOW do everything that is within God's will? That when Hitler killed millions, THAT was within God's will?? That when rape and child abuse occur, THOSE are within God's will? I can't imagine you truly think that, but you tell me."

It is a reasonable response and demands a reasonable explanation. Am I actually claiming that all that occurs on this planet is within God's will? I mean, how can that be??!! And I see the problem ... but do you see the other problem? There are multiple places in Scripture that assign to God the term "Sovereign". In 1 Tim 6:15 He is, in fact, the only Sovereign. We also read in Eph 1:11 that God works all things after the counsel of His will. So now we have a problem. Either my outrageous assertion that everything that happens on this planet falls within the will of God is true as it lines up with these passages, or these passages are just as wrong as my assertion is. So what do we do?

Well, let's try it from a human perspective (first), understanding first of all that we are not sovereign. We only like to think we are. So, I tell my wife, "Wouldn't it be nice to have an RV to travel around in" or I tell my grandson, "Clean up your room" and I have expressed my will, have I not? Of course, these are actually two types of "will". One is a wish, something that I don't even expect to have, and the other is a command which may or may not be obeyed. The theological terms for these types of will are "permissive will" and "preceptive will". In one case I offered a desire with not real intention of fulfilling it, and in the other I offered a command that ought to be fulfilled ... but might not. As humans we can understand these categories.

God also has these two types of wills. We know, for instance, that God "desires all people to be saved", but we also know that it won't happen. This would be His "permissive will", something He would like but doesn't actually intend to fulfill. We also know, for instance, that adultery is against the will of God because He said, "Thou shalt not commit adultery." We know, again, that people commit adultery, so God's precept in this case doesn't occur. So God shares these two types of will with humans. There is -- must be -- a third type of will of God, however, if the passages I referenced above are to be held as true and valid. This will is not present in humans because God is the "only Sovereign". This will the theologians refer to as God's "decretive will". This will always occurs ... if God is actually Sovereign. This will is the one that agrees with Eph 1:11 -- God works all things after the counsel of His will. This will would encompass everything that occurs on this planet, and nothing that occurs would fall outside of this will of God.

Let me offer an example. Joseph's brothers first threatened to kill him, then sold him into slavery. It is not possible to call that "God's will" in either the sense that He would desire it ("Wow, I sure wish Joseph's brothers would toss him in a well and sell him off as slave.") or that it was in line with His commandments (as evidenced by the fact that they lied to their father about it). It was not in line with God's will in those senses. However, in the end, this sin saved his family and the Jewish race. So we hear Joseph say to his brothers, "You meant it for evil, but God meant it for good." There are multiple things in play in that sentence. First, they are not off the hook. It was evil and they are liable. Second, God planned for it to happen to bring about an end that He wanted. He didn't cause it. He allowed it because it fit with His plans. Third, He didn't merely work it out. "Oh, my, that's a bad thing! Now, how can I work this out so it becomes good?" No, He meant it for good. He used their sin for His plan.

Of course, there is a much better example. The sin of Joseph's brothers was minor compared to this one. This example is the murder of God's innocent Son. About this we read:
"The kings of the earth set themselves, and the rulers were gathered together, against the Lord and against his Anointed -- for truly in this city there were gathered together against Your holy servant Jesus, whom You anointed, both Herod and Pontius Pilate, along with the Gentiles and the peoples of Israel, to do whatever Your hand and Your plan had predestined to take place" (Acts 4:26-28).
On one hand, then, we have the very clear indictment that these people had set themselves against God, and on the other hand we have the undeniable claim that they carried out "whatever Your hand and Your plan had predestined to take place", an undeniable example of both evil and "God's will".

Logically, then, if the Bible is true when it claims that God is the only Sovereign and if it is true that God works all things after the counsel of His will, then it is unavoidably true that all things that occur fall within God's will in some sense. Biblically we know that 1) God states His will in ways that do not come to pass and 2) God works all things after His will. Experience tells us that some things will be a violation of His wishes (like people that aren't saved) and some things will violate His precepts (like committing known sin). But if we have a God who simply has things that occur outside of His ultimate, Sovereign will, then He is not Sovereign and we are without hope because the Creator has succumbed to the creation.

Friday, October 30, 2009

Possessions and Hyperbole

A few years ago I wrote a series on "Hard Sayings", including one on Jesus's words, "Sell all your possessions." That one recently sparked some discussion about how I was being hypocritical in my interpretation of the very clear words of Jesus and, if I were to be consistent, I'd need to sell all my possessions, and it was only my refusal to do that that made me read it as something else. Fine. Then, a local Christian radio talk show brought up the very same discussion this last week. Is it required of Christians to sell their possessions? Are we, if we are to be Christians or, at least, good Christians, required to be in poverty? The question comes from these types of passages and the frequency at which they are offered. Could it be that Christians in America are skipping directly over the very clear demand of Scripture that we should be in poverty simply because we don't want to be? I believe it is worth examining.

Is it possible that we are skipping over the very clear words of Scripture because we don't want to do it? Absolutely! And you ought to determine whether or not you fall in that category. Very important!

Moving on (for those of you who determine "No, I don't think I fall in that category"), this discussion ties in with some of the recent discussions regarding Hebrews 6 where the author of Hebrews claims that it is impossible to renew someone to repentance if they reject it. I held that it was intended as written. Others claimed it was hyperbole. I see nothing in the passage that calls for hyperbole. So, what about this passage: "Sell all your possessions"?

Here's my problem with taking that at face value. It presents insurmountable problems. We know, for instance, that Jesus owned a very particular garment, you know, the one that they gambled for when He was being crucified. It was something He owned. He didn't sell it. So, apparently Jesus didn't sell all His possessions. And it wasn't just Him. Peter owned a house. Paul was a tentmaker and apparently owned the tools and materials necessary to make tents. In one instance, Jesus told His disciples to acquire things for a missionary journey. Jesus never told His fishermen disciples to sell their boats. In other words, if "Sell all your possessions" was to be the Christian mandate, it was sure ignored by Jesus and His prime followers. Clearly, then, at least the "all" in this phrase isn't meant to mean "actually all". That is, no human being can survive on this planet without possessing something, if only clothes and food.

Okay, so maybe "all" doesn't actually mean "all" in this instance. Maybe that was hyperbole. But surely it seems that the purpose of that hyperbole was to convey that we should be in poverty, right? Sure, sure, own those bottom-line basics, but you cannot justify any Christian being rich, can you? (And, face it, folks, there isn't a "poor" Christian in America compared with the rest of the world.)

Well, the thing that really spurred this post was what I read just the other day in Paul's epistle to Timothy.
As for the rich in this present age, charge them not to be haughty, nor to set their hopes on the uncertainty of riches, but on God, who richly provides us with everything to enjoy. They are to do good, to be rich in good works, to be generous and ready to share, thus storing up treasure for themselves as a good foundation for the future, so that they may take hold of that which is truly life (1 Tim 6:17-19).
Do you see the problem? If the biblical standard for Christians, as suggested by Jesus's words to the rich young ruler and His repeated comments about "Sell all your possessions", is poverty, then Paul really made a royal mess of this passage, didn't he? He leaves some unnecessarily complicated instructions here regarding "the rich in this present age" (as opposed to those who are rich in heavenly ways). Don't be haughty. Don't set their hopes on riches. Do good. Be rich in good works. Yada, yada, yada. Paul, Paul, hang on here. This is much easier than all that. Just tell them, "Sell it all" and the whole thing goes away. Sheesh! It's not that hard!

No, Paul did not tell them to sell it all. He told them to do good, to not rely on their riches, and to be ready to share. He told them to have an "other-world" perspective, not holding onto the things of this world, but using them as God supplies for good.

I understood Jesus's words, "Sell all your possessions", to mean "Don't make your possessions your god." I understood Him to mean "Don't possess anything. Be willing to give it all up." I understood Him to say, "Don't own anything; it is all to be tools for God's use." I understood Jesus's words to mean essentially what Paul told Timothy about the rich. I understood it to be hyperbole. I understood it to be hyperbole based on the contradictions to what He and His disciples did. I understood it to be hyperbole based on passages like this 1 Timothy one that did not mandate that the rich become poor. I did not see it as hyperbole because I'm unwilling to be poor; it was the texts that drove me to it.

Thursday, October 29, 2009

What Standard?

Recently overheard: "How did you like the new church?" "Oh, it was great! We both cried."

I've been told before, "If you tell people that the Bible teaches that, it will push them away from Christianity."

"If it feels good, do it."

By what standard do we determine what is right and wrong, good and bad? It appears that the standard set by the world of the '60's has become the standard of determining right and wrong for all of us ... or at least most. "If it feels good."

As I said, it was only overheard, so I wasn't able to respond, but I wanted to ask so badly, "When did 'we both cried' become the criterion for good church?" Apparently so many of us now determine if a church is good or bad by whether or not we have the appropriate emotional response. If it doesn't "move me", it isn't good. If I feel something that I deem is appropriate from the service, then it is good. Really?

I had a conversation awhile ago with a woman who was preaching at her church. I asked, "On what do you base your idea that this is okay?" She asked, of course, why I asked, and I pointed out the Scripture that said it wasn't right. "Oh, that can't mean that," she told me. "If a person feels a calling from God, it wouldn't be right to stand in the way." I see. If we feel called to do something, then it's the right thing to do.

Lots of people today determine "good theology" by how people react to it. "You know, telling people they're sinners just makes them mad." It doesn't feel good to hear that stuff. "Good theology", then, is theology that makes people feel better about God and about themselves. You know, stuff like "God loves you" is good, but stuff like "God makes demands" is bad. Telling people "It is God's will that everyone be saved" is good, but telling them, "Some will not" is bad. Don't tell homosexuals that their activity is against the Bible because that will only alienate them and making them feel bad is not good theology. Don't tell women that the Bible forbids women taking authority from men because that will just make them feel lesser and feeling that way is not good theology. Don't tell people that Christ is the only way because that sounds arrogant and people don't like arrogant.

When did "how I feel about it" become the standard of morality, the determiner of truth? I suppose it has always been the way to some segments, but it is now largely the standard for those who claim to be followers of Christ. These followers of Christ, then, take up positions opposed to Christ because these positions feel much better than those ones that align with Christ and figure out ways to change it so Christ agrees with them. Oh ... that sounds bad, doesn't it? Yeah, actually, it is.

Wednesday, October 28, 2009

I love my wife

This isn't the first time I've made this statement on my blog. And I don't think it's too trivial to repeat. However, I recently made an interesting discovery that reinforced this fact -- I love my wife. The method of discovery was a bit odd, so bear with me.

In a typical month my wife might ask me to drop by the local pharmacy to pick up some prescription that's ready or some such. Fairly common. I'm happy to do it. And when I run the errand she asks of me, I will often walk down the "treats aisle" of whatever store I'm at to see if there's something there just for me, a treat, you know, for being a nice guy. Without fail, I will not buy said treats because my desire for something nice just for me is drowned out by "Do I really want to bother paying for it?" and "I don't really want it that bad" and "It's not really that good for me" and that sort of stuff. Or so I thought.

Recently we acquired some new "house guests". Instead of it just being the two of us in the house, we suddenly have a crowd including very young children. My wife is busy ... busier than she's ever been. She works from dawn to dusk and beyond trying to watch children and keep the house from total annihilation and counsel adults and ... well, she's pretty busy. And when I went to pick up something for her at the store, I did my typical "treat aisle" run ... and was overwhelmed by the "need" to get something just for me. The strength of the desire was somewhat shocking to me. And there were similar things going on in various parts of my life. Very odd!

Do you want to know what I discovered when I analyzed it? My wife is an amazing woman. She isn't extravagant or overt, but she does hundreds of little things in our marriage to keep me satisfied. They're not "loud". You likely wouldn't notice. Still, she is constantly in the process of doing things that say to me, "You're special." My wife has an amazing ability to keep me satisfied. That's why, when I would run down the typical "treat aisle", I would have no compulsion to actually treat myself. Right now she has her attentions drawn from normal living, but under normal circumstances I didn't need something special just for me because I was already being treated as special. That's why I didn't need what most men seem to need -- something that is just for me. It was because she always made me feel that I was special to her.

Now, you can brag about your beauty queen wife or talk about your loving wife or whatever you want. That's good. My wife is, in my book, of the highest caliber. She keeps me satisfied. She doesn't do it with words, but with deeds. She doesn't do it by being a doormat or in some fawning way (which would simply destroy the concept for me), but in quiet ways you likely wouldn't be conscious of. A little special something from the store there. A willingness to watch whatever I got from the video store here. The freedom to spend an hour on the computer without nagging me about it over there. Little things that say repeatedly, "I love you and you're special" without flying the flags that demand recognition for it. My wife keeps me satisfied, and that, dear readers, is one of the highest compliments a husband can pay his wife in my book.

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Are you lost?

Back in July I provided two lists of Scripture on a single topic that appeared to contradict each other. I asked my readers to figure out how to put them together -- not to mitigate one set or another, but to make them fit together. The topic of these passages was also yesterday's topic (although yesterday I wrote about a single passage) -- losing your salvation.

I don't plan today to visit all those passages from the two lists and explain how they fit together (and I do believe they fit together). What I want to do is ask a more basic question. To do this, you might want to reread those passages. I'll wait ...

All fresh in your mind now? Good. There is something overall in these two lists that strikes me as quite significant. In the first list we read all about what it is you have to do to avoid losing salvation. You have to bear fruit and stand firm and be ready and be obedient and practice self-discipline and remain faithful and avoid intentional sin ... well, you get the idea ... and you're likely aware of all that anyway. But I note that this first list is about all we are supposed to do or not do. The second list stands in stark difference. The second list doesn't talk about what we must do; it talks about what God will do. He upholds, gives eternal life, does not condemn, keeps, justifies, makes stand, seals, completes, and so much more. The primary difference, then, between these two lists is not whether or not you can lose your salvation, but who you are talking about.

I have a favorite passage that seems to encapsulate these two lists in just two verses.
Therefore, my beloved, as you have always obeyed, so now, not only as in my presence but much more in my absence, work out your own salvation with fear and trembling, for it is God who works in you, both to will and to work for his good pleasure (Phil 2:12-13).
The first part is a command about what we need to do, and it's not trivial. "Work out your own salvation." No, not just that. Do it "with fear and trembling". This is serious ... and frightening. But it's not the end of the thought. How are we to carry out this serious and scary thing? "It is God who is at work in you." What is God doing? He is giving us both the willingness and the ability to do what He wants us to do, to do what pleases Him.

Right there, balanced together, you find a summary of both of those lists. There is work for us to do. There is no doubt. It is serious work and it is frightening. Still, do it. How? Well, in the final analysis, you'll find it was God who did it in you. He didn't have faith in your ability to do what pleases Him. He made sure you would and could do it.

And on the question of losing one's salvation, it really does come down to this, doesn't it? One set of passages are warnings aimed at you. The other set are confidently hung on God and what He does. If salvation can be lost, it is because of your incompetence. If salvation is sure, it is because of Him and His abilities. You can choose to believe either direction. I cannot help but hang my hat on God's sovereignty. I know that I'm incompetent, but I know His marvelous character far exceeds the depths of my failings. That's the place where I find rest.