This charge I entrust to you, Timothy, my child, in accordance with the prophecies previously made about you, that by them you may wage the good warfare, holding faith and a good conscience. By rejecting this, some have made shipwreck of their faith, among whom are Hymenaeus and Alexander, whom I have handed over to Satan that they may learn not to blaspheme (1 Tim 1:18-20).If you've ever been in a discussion regarding the possibility of a Christian losing their salvation (or some variation thereof), this passage has likely come up. This, we are told, is a clear example of two believers who lost their salvation. (Or who surrendered their salvation.) Clear enough. Now what? I would ask that you take a moment to walk through this with me because I'm not so sure it's as clear as some would like it to be.
What do we know? We know that two guys, Hymenaeus and Alexander, did something that "made shipwreck of their faith". Most people leap immediately to "lost their salvation", but I'd hold off on that. What do we know? Okay, so we know they "made shipwreck of their faith". We know that they did it by rejecting one or both of these concepts: 1) hold the faith, and 2) hold a good conscience. And we know Paul's remedy: "I have handed [them] over to Satan that they may learn not to blaspheme." That's what we know. The rest requires evaluation. Did these two guys lose their salvation? I'd ask you to avoid jumping to that conclusion before we look it over.
There are other things that will play into this discussion, other things we know from Scripture. One thing we ought to consider is the phrase, "handed over to Satan". The concept occurs in another place in Paul's writings. In his first epistle to the Corinthians there was a case of serious, unrepented sexual immorality. On this Paul instructs, "When you are assembled in the name of the Lord Jesus and my spirit is present, with the power of our Lord Jesus, you are to deliver this man to Satan for the destruction of the flesh, so that his spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord" (1 Cor 5:4-5). The purpose of this drastic concept, then, was not death and damnation, but "that his spirit may be saved" -- salvation. We have the same process here in 1 Timothy. These two men were being handed over to Satan, not so they would be damned, but so that they would learn.
The other passage that comes to bear here is found in Hebrews 6. Almost all proponents of the concept that salvation can be lost or surrendered will look to this passage as proof. Oddly, almost all proponents of this concept ignore what this passage says.
For it is impossible, in the case of those who have once been enlightened, who have tasted the heavenly gift, and have shared in the Holy Spirit, and have tasted the goodness of the word of God and the powers of the age to come, and then have fallen away, to restore them again to repentance, since they are crucifying once again the Son of God to their own harm and holding him up to contempt (Heb 6:4-6).Given that we are talking about a true believer here, the passage explains what happens when this true believer becomes apostate ("fallen away"). While they like to point to this as proof that a true believer can be apostate, they deny the ramification: "It is impossible ... to restore them again to repentance." There are those who argue "Once saved, always saved." This passage argues "Once lost, always lost."
So, back to Hymenaeus and Alexander. We know that they made shipwreck of their faith. If that means that they lost their salvation, then Paul was acting foolishly on at least two counts. First, if they lost their salvation, they already belonged to Satan. If they already belonged to Satan, by what authority and for what purpose would Paul want to give them to ... the one who already had them? That makes no sense. The other problem is why? What would giving them to the one who already owned them accomplish? They were permanently damned (Heb 6). There was no hope. Teaching them not to blaspheme was fine, I guess, but it served no ultimate purpose since they had no hope. They were the walking damned. Punishing damned people by turning them over to the one who is already their master just doesn't seem reasonable.
Is it possible, then, that this passage does not reference lost salvation? It is possible, I think, to understand "made shipwreck of their faith" to mean something other than "lost salvation". It could mean that they had run aground in terms of their faith. Like Abraham of old who had God's promise to make a nation out of him and then lied (multiple times) about his wife for fear that he would be killed, these two may have lost sight of their faith ("made shipwreck of their faith") and needed correction, not damnation. This is a coherent understanding of the phrase, and given the problems with 1) handing over to Satan and 2) the permanence of lost salvation, I think it is the most coherent understanding of the phrase.