Like Button

Tuesday, October 06, 2009

Whatsoever things ...

You're going to read this as if I'm challenging you to come up to my level and obey Scripture. I'm not intending it that way. I am asking a question because I don't know the answer. Or, to put it another way, it's my problem, too.
Finally, brethren, whatsoever things are true, whatsoever things are honest, whatsoever things are just, whatsoever things are pure, whatsoever things are lovely, whatsoever things are of good report; if there be any virtue, and if there be any praise, think on these things (Phil 4:8).
Clear, straightforward, pretty simple. Not a lot of controversial or difficult concepts there. Not a lot of debate about word meanings. It seems to be a basic command from Paul to Christians.

Here's my question. How in the world do we do that? I don't use "in the world" in that question lightly. We live in the world. We are to be "in the world but not of the world". You know, like when Jesus said, "If you were of the world, the world would love its own. Yet because you are not of the world, but I chose you out of the world, therefore the world hates you" (John 15:19). So, we live here, but we aren't to be driven by this place. We are to operate on a higher power, citizens of heaven (Phil 3:20) on temporary assignment in this world. All well and good.

But ... we know that the world is not a good place. We know that "the creation was subjected to futility" (Rom 8:20), that sin is in the world, that there is a worm in everything. We only have to turn on the news or read a newspaper to find that we're not surrounded by truth, honesty, justice, purity, beauty, good news, virtue, praiseworthiness ... you know, the list Paul gives. So, how do we operate in this world in the manner that Bible commands?

I'm thinking of the Christian news agencies that complain about the way that Christians are being treated in this country or others. I'm thinking of the authors who write books about the sorry state of the Church. I'm thinking about bloggers who point out the problems in our society, our politics, our churches, our world. I'm thinking about those who are open about their belief that homosexual behavior is a sin or that there is no such thing as "gay marriage" or ... you get the idea.

I'm wondering how we maintain integrity -- recognizing sin when we see it, understanding foolishness when it presents itself, that kind of thing -- while still dwelling on the types of things that this passage commands us to dwell on. Are we to be Norman Vincent Peales, thinking only of the positives? Are we being called to be "pollyannas", only seeing the bright side? I don't think so. Jesus wasn't particularly "pollyannic" when He faced the moneychangers in the Temple. Paul wasn't particularly cheery when he turned someone over to Satan for the destruction of his flesh. So maybe you can help me understand how we obey this command to "think on these things" while still recognizing sin and error in the world.

Monday, October 05, 2009

Oh, Hell? No.

"Excuse me, do you believe in Hell?" "In what?" "Hell." "Oh, Hell? No."

The concept of Hell has been part and parcel of Christianity since it began. Today the idea is slipping into the Hell of Tossed Ideas. A survey in 2006 held that 76% of Americans believed in Hell. In 2008, that number was down to 59%. While belief in Heaven remains fairly high, the idea that there is some sort of eternal damnation, some torment forever for my sins, is no longer the fear factor it once was. Most people are pretty sure they'll get to Heaven. Hell is not an issue.

When I was younger, I was baffled by the idea of Hell. I got that it was intended to be punishment for sin. I was fine with punishment for sin. However, I wondered, "Shouldn't the punishment fit the crime?" After all, if I defied my mom and dad, I got something like a spanking. If I defied God, I got eternal torment. How was that reasonable? If I commit temporal crimes, why do I get eternal punishment? This was all, of course, because I was operating from the center of Man rather than God. Sin was just "doing bad things" and God was a big Dad. I was a nice fellow. Why would I deserve that kind of response?

God explains the problem in a different light. Starting with God, we see the One and Only Master of the Universe, the King, the Sovereign of All. He doesn't simply make suggestions; His Word is Law. He not only demands, but deserves complete obedience. So we, as creations of His, see those demands and respond with "I will make myself like the Most High" (Isa 14:14). We decide to overthrow the King of the Universe and make ourselves masters of our universe. Looking at this top down, we can see that our refusal to submit to the King of Kings is not simply a violation of rules. It is treason. We are committing Cosmic Treason against the King. Now, in normal, temporal governments, treason is punishable by temporal death. It makes sense, then, that in an eternal government, the punishment for treason would be eternal death.

The second problem in our thinking about Hell is that we have some faulty definitions. Take, for instance, the concepts of "life" and "death". We see them as fairly simple ideas. Life, to us, is the condition that distinguishes organisms from inorganic objects and dead organisms, being manifested by growth through metabolism, reproduction, and the power of adaptation to environment through changes originating internally. Death, then, would be the absence of life, the permanent cessation of all the vital functions of an organism. Not much controversy there. God, however, sees these differently. Jesus said, "This is eternal life, that they know You, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom You have sent" (John 17:3). From God's perspective, then, life is our relationship with God and His Son. The absence of life would be the absence of said relationship. Jesus confirmed this when He told of those who would come to Him falsely claiming Him as Lord. The defining problem, according to Jesus, was "I never knew you" (Matt 7:23).

Another faulty definition we perpetrate is thinking of "Hell" as "a place of fire". The biblical concept of Hell is simply the place of the dead. The Old Testament word is Sheol, and the concept is simply the grave. The New Testament (Greek) word is Hades, the grave. Now, don't misunderstand. I'm not saying that there is no place of eternal torment, of eternal death. I'm saying that our wording here is confused. According to John, at the end of the Millennial Kingdom, "Death and Hell were thrown into the lake of fire" (Rev 20:14). So, if both Death and Hell are terminated in this "lake of fire", what are we talking about when we use the term "Hell" as eternal death and eternal torment? In fact, how do "eternal death" and "eternal torment go together?

So, we have a view of sin that is simply "doing bad things" and God sees it as Cosmic Treason. We see "life" as living and breathing and death as the permanent cessation of such life while God sees it as connection to Him or the lack thereof. We see "Hell" as "a place of eternal fire" and God terminates Hell in the Lake of Fire. Holding up the concept of Hell to these new values, then, we might begin to have a new perspective on Hell. First, Hell is not the final resting place of sinners. The "Lake of Fire" is. But that's a minor issue, a trivial point, a matter of terminology, not reality. The reality is that Cosmic Treason demands justice and the just recompense for that crime is Cosmic Death. Life is not living and breathing, but connection with God, so Cosmic Death would be an eternal separation from God.

"Oh," some might think, "that's not so bad. You're just talking about separation. That's nothing at all like 'fire and brimstone' like we hear about." Again, we're suffering from a faulty concept. Humans are designed by God to be in connection to God. We are built in His image and fashioned to have a relationship with Him. This loss of connection, this separation from God, is not a small issue. Interestingly, the most prolific information we have on the eternal torment that awaits those who are damned comes from the Son of God. People like to think of Jesus as a warm and loving guy, but Jesus spoke more of Hell than He did of Heaven. It is Jesus who gives descriptions like "the unquenchable fire" (Mark 9:43) and "Where their worm does not die" (Mark 9:48). Whatever it is, we know that it is eternal and it is torment.

The final abode of those who die without Christ may not be a place of fire. That image comes from language in Scripture and is popularized by Dante's Inferno. Whether or not it is literally such a place is up for discussion. What we do know is that it is eternal, that it is eternal death, that it is eternal separation from God, that it is eternal torment. Physical torment? Who knows? But I suspect there will be slim satisfaction to the soul that is damned to find out that it isn't fire and brimstone ... just eternal torment.

Sunday, October 04, 2009

Where Your Treasure Is

Yesterday I wrote about our propensity to operate on "I want". Today I'm offering a valuable "I want" from which to operate. Rather, Paul is making the offer.
7 But whatever gain I had, I counted as loss for the sake of Christ. 8 Indeed, I count everything as loss because of the surpassing worth of knowing Christ Jesus my Lord. For His sake I have suffered the loss of all things and count them as rubbish, in order that I may gain Christ 9 and be found in Him, not having a righteousness of my own that comes from the law, but that which comes through faith in Christ, the righteousness from God that depends on faith -- 10 that I may know Him and the power of His resurrection, and may share His sufferings, becoming like Him in His death, 11 that by any means possible I may attain the resurrection from the dead. 12 Not that I have already obtained this or am already perfect, but I press on to make it my own, because Christ Jesus has made me His own. 13 Brothers, I do not consider that I have made it my own. But one thing I do: forgetting what lies behind and straining forward to what lies ahead, 14 I press on toward the goal for the prize of the upward call of God in Christ Jesus (Phil 3:7-14).
Imagine how your life would be if your concept of the ultimate value was "the surpassing worth of knowing Christ Jesus". Imagine how your goals would change if you were aiming to "know Him and the power of His resurrection, and [share] His sufferings". This would be no trivial change.

If you're like me, you don't measure up against Paul's value system. If you're like me, you might likely kick yourself (in some way or another) over that. Indeed, Paul goes on in the passage to say, "Brothers, join in imitating me" (Phil 3:17) (something I'd never have the nerve to say). We ought to have Paul's value system. So I offer this word of encouragement. Paul said, "I do not consider that I have made it my own." Paul hadn't arrived. So it should be no surprise that neither you nor I have arrived. So let's forget the failures of the past and "press on toward the goal for the prize of the upward call of God in Christ Jesus." It's a worthy goal.

Saturday, October 03, 2009

I Want ...

I have "invaders" in my house. My daughter and her three children (ranging in age from six to one) are with us for awhile. Little children are perfect examples of what the sin nature looks like before we put on a veneer of morality. So I get a chance to look at human nature unvarnished.

There is, for these little ones, a singular motivation. It comes in two flavors, but it is only one concept. It is the sole method by which they determine what they will do (or not), what is good (or bad), what is acceptable (or not). It is defined by the phrase I hear most: "I want ..." Sometimes they will use the other side -- "I don't want ..." -- but you can see that this is simply the inverse of the same coin: "I want."

The truth is most of us operate under that same singular motivation. We determine what to do based on what we want. Do we want to eat what's good for us or will we eat cake? Do we want to stick out this tough marriage or will we take the path of least resistance? Will we do what we want to do or will we surrender to what God wants?

We all seem to have it, the "I want" propensity. It seems there is always a little more that is just ... barely ... outside our grasp that, like those children in my house, we think we need to be happy. "If only ..." seems to drive us in our "I wants" because, you see, what we rarely find is "I want ... exactly what I have." Even for Christians we seem to think, "If God would only give us ____, we'd be satisfied." That ____ is almost always something in this world and always something we don't have now but are quite sure, if we did, would make all the difference. A husband, a wife, a child, a job, a car, a house, something we may not have now but ... "I want it!"

A few observations for those of you who are thinking "If only ...". First, your heavenly Father knows what you need (Matt 6:32). Did you think otherwise? Second, we are ambassadors for Christ (2 Cor 5:20), strangers and exiles on the earth (Heb 11:13). Is getting comfortable here really of that much value? Finally, one author once said, "There's a worm in everything." This world is tainted by sin, and "all the comforts of home" aren't found here. Instead, where your treasure is, there your heart will be also. So ... do we want to mimic those little kids who cannot think beyond "I want", or do we want to mimic Christ? You decide.

Friday, October 02, 2009

What Makes Christianity? Summary

Jude was James's brother. He wrote a very short letter "to those who are called". If that's you, then it was written to you. His initial intent is quite clear: "Beloved, although I was very eager to write to you about our common salvation, I found it necessary to write appealing to you to contend for the faith that was once for all delivered to the saints" (Jude 1:3). "The faith that was once for all delivered to the saints" -- that is what Jude asks us to contend for. "Contend for the faith."

For the past several days I have been contending for the faith that was once for all delivered to the saints. I haven't been telling why these points were true. I've simply been outlining why they are necessary. If Christianity is to be a viable, valid religion, these doctrines must be true. Without them, Christianity either becomes just another religion among many or it evaporates entirely. (Note: Due to the repeated claims of exclusivity in the Bible, if Christianity is relegated to "just another religion among many", then it is nullified.) What doctrines did I list as essential? In what I consider a somewhat logical order:

1. The Inerrancy of Scripture
2. The Sinfulness of Man
3. The Atonement
4. The Trinity
5. The Resurrection of Christ

Other people might make their arguments about essentials. They may list more things. A popular one, for instance, is the Virgin Birth. I didn't list that one because, given the first point, the Virgin Birth is a necessary conclusion. (The Bible doesn't equivocate on the Virgin Birth. It's not up for debate whether or not the Bible teaches it. Remove it and you remove Item #1.) There are many things that are clear in the Bible, and they are unavoidable given the first point. And others might argue down a path that include other things (like the Second Coming, etc.). The things I listed I consider inviolable. The others are up to you.

Now, I, again, need to make it clear. When I say "essential to Christianity", I do not mean that in order to become a Christian you need to believe all these things. I am not saying that a person who does not have a clear understanding and agreement with, for instance, the mystery of the Trinity cannot be saved. These are not essential for salvation. They are essential for Christianity. They form the primary substance of Christianity. Without them, you have something that is not Christianity. And, if all believers have the same Holy Spirit dwelling in them (as the inerrant Scripture says we do), then it stands to reason that all believers would come to the same conclusion regarding these doctrines when presented with them. We would, then, all stand in agreement on these key issues, not as a condition of salvation, but as a result of salvation.

There are many things in Scripture that are abundantly clear. It's not up for debate. There are other things that are questions in the minds of many. We can argue about premil/post-mil/amil stuff. There is room for discussion on election or modes of baptism or the like. We can debate whether or not the gifts of the Spirit are still in effect. These are not essentials. There is lots of room for discussion, and in these matters we ought to be charitable to each other. But on the basic structures that make Christianity Christianity, there is no room for disagreement. Without those we ought to simply surrender the faith as null and void. No, on those we ought to be united. They are essential.

Thursday, October 01, 2009

What Makes Christianity? The Resurrection

This is entry #5 in this series on the doctrines that make Christianity what it is. Admitting that Christianity is a religion among many, I asked, "What makes Christianity unique?" All religions claim that they know the way. Most religions claim to be the only way. There are many beliefs in Christianity that make it unusual, but the really distinctive belief in Christianity is encompassed in this phrase: "Saved by grace through faith in Christ." All other religions offer a works-based method of getting to heaven (or their equivalent). Christianity stands alone in a grace-based salvation apart from works.

Thus far, then, I've explained why it is that we must have a reliable source document for Christianity to be a valid religion. Without a God-breathed (and therefore infallible) Bible, Christianity itself is merely a matter of opinion and your opinion is as good as mine. In other words -- no inerrant Bible, no truth. Secondly, the offer of salvation requires a need for salvation. Thus, the second necessary doctrine is the doctrine of sin. Man is sinful at his core meaning that he has no means within himself to fix the problem or pay the debt. Eliminate that doctrine and Christianity is nullified. Given Man's condition, the next necessary doctrine is the Atonement. If God is just, He requires payment for sin. The only means of that payment being made is either eternal separation from God or someone paying it on our behalf. Enter the Atonement. The doctrine requires first that a man live a sinless life so that the payment made is not on his own behalf, and second that he be more than Man in order to have that payment apply to more than a single man. This leads to the inevitable doctrine of the Trinity -- a triune God who is Father, Son, and Spirit. None of these doctrines can be mitigated without destroying Christianity's core.

One of the most unique things about Christianity is the Resurrection. This doctrine stands out as an obvious problem to skeptics and detractors. I mean, if, indeed, someone rose from the dead by His own power, you have a unique situation here. Thus, the concept has been under fire since the beginning. The religious leaders of the day told the guards to lie about it (Matt 28:11-15). In our day cynics and religious leaders alike deny it. There are even some who are called "pastors" in "Christian churches" who deny the Resurrection. Some scholars gathered as a group called "the Jesus Seminar" and bravely denied the Resurrection. Some say that it's a truth, but not a necessary truth. That is, it's not essential to Christianity. So what is my best argument on this essential?

Now, thus far I've used Scripture and reasoning to explain why it is that the doctrines I've been holding that are essential to Christianity. This one -- the Resurrection -- is an easy one because Scripture alone makes the argument. I don't need a logical argument here. Here's what the Bible says.
12 Now if Christ is proclaimed as raised from the dead, how can some of you say that there is no resurrection of the dead? 13 But if there is no resurrection of the dead, then not even Christ has been raised. 14 And if Christ has not been raised, then our preaching is in vain and your faith is in vain. 15 We are even found to be misrepresenting God, because we testified about God that he raised Christ, whom he did not raise if it is true that the dead are not raised. 16 For if the dead are not raised, not even Christ has been raised. 17 And if Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile and you are still in your sins. 18 Then those also who have fallen asleep in Christ have perished. 19 If in Christ we have hope in this life only, we are of all people most to be pitied. 20 But in fact Christ has been raised from the dead, the firstfruits of those who have fallen asleep. 21 For as by a man came death, by a man has come also the resurrection of the dead. 22 For as in Adam all die, so also in Christ shall all be made alive (1 Cor 15:12-22).
Paul addresses the very question we are. How important is the Resurrection of Christ? Some in his day denied it. Paul takes their argument at face value and follows it down the logical path. If there is no resurrection, then Christ didn't rise. If Christ didn't rise, then we're liars, our preaching is vain, our faith is futile, and there is no forgiveness of sins. "We are," Paul concludes, "of all people most to be pitied." On the other hand, if Christ was raised from the dead, then we have hope. Being dead ourselves (in Adam), we have confidence of defeating death (in Christ).

This is an easy argument to make because the Bible makes the argument. You can research the evidence for the Resurrection, and you ought to. You can make the arguments that support the truth of the Resurrection, and you ought to. But one thing that we cannot do is offer this doctrine as "optional". Without this essential doctrine, there is no salvation, Christianity has no meaning, and we're all lost.

Wednesday, September 30, 2009

What Makes Christianity? The Trinity

Here's a recap so far. I am looking at what makes Christianity different than all other religions. The primary difference is the phrase, "saved by grace through faith in Christ". Having established that, I wanted to go through particular doctrines that would be necessary to maintain Christianity as a distinctive religion ... not just another among many. First I covered the inerrancy of Scripture and why it was necessary. Then we went through Man's Sin Condition -- his debt to God and his inability to repay it. From there we naturally went to the Atonement, the price Christ paid on our behalf to cover that debt. In that piece, however, I mentioned some of the conditions that would be required to make that payment valid. One was sinlessness. Another was that Christ would have to be more than a man for His payment to cover more than one man. Clearly this leads to another essential ingredient of Christianity. That is, if He was not more than a man, the payment wouldn't be valid and Christianity would be finished. So, what essential doctrine does this lead to?

Of much controversy is the doctrine of the Trinity. It shows up, in varying forms, on most lists of "essentials", but it is always under attack. Skeptics assure us that it's neither essential nor true. "It's not even in the Bible!" "Proponents" argue that it's true but not essential and then typically go on to describe a belief that is not the doctrine of the Trinity. Now, let me remind you, my goal is not to make arguments about what makes the doctrine true. The primary discussion here is about what makes it essential. Why is the doctrine of the Trinity essential to Christianity? Remember, we are looking at "saved by grace through faith in Christ." So, what part of this defining concept is modified or lost if the Trinity is modified or lost?

The part in question here is the last part: Christ. The premise of Christianity is that Christ alone can save. On what is that salvation based? Salvation is predicated on God being both just and justifier by providing His Son to pay for our sin. That payment could only cover one man's debt if Christ was only a man. Was He more? The Bible says so.

John presents an interesting, unavoidable concept. "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. The same was in the beginning with God" (John 1:1-2). Here we have "the Word". Whatever else we may know about this "Word", we have two solid facts: 1) "The Word was with God", and 2) "The Word was God". Both are true. This "Word" was both God and in the presence of God. In other words, this Word is both deity and in the presence of deity. Now, since all of Christianity has always maintained monotheism -- only one God -- we have an interesting premise here. This Word is both with the one God and is the one God. Another thing we know about this "Word" -- it refers to Jesus Christ (John 1:14-17). Whatever else we have going on here, this gives us a "di-unity", two in one. Given the numbers of Scriptures that give a similar view of the Holy Spirit -- assigning to the Holy Spirit attributes of God -- we're left with a tri-unity, a Trinity. Two things we know about this Trinity. 1) There is only one God, so all are God. 2) They are referenced individually and distinctly, so while they are not separate, they are all distinct. One in essence, three in persons. Despite what you may have heard, it is a unique concept. Other approaches have been things like tritheism which gives three gods (violating the first thing we know) or modalism which says that one God was first Father, then Son, then Spirit, violating the "with God" concept. (If the Son was originally the Father, to whom was Jesus praying when He prayed to the Father, and who did Jesus promise to send if the Spirit was Himself? Makes no sense.)

In the Trinity, then, we have a cohesion with Scripture that doesn't work any other way. (Without the doctrine of the Trinity, for instance, you can make no sense of John 1:1-17.) In the Trinity, we have a specific, unique character of God that is different from any other religion. Finally, in the Trinity, we have a Son who is God. He was God from the beginning, He arrived on earth as God, and He is still God today. This person of the Godhood was the only one qualified to die for our sin. Think about that. While the doctrine of the Trinity maintains that there are three persons (personas) in the Godhood, only one was qualified to pay for our sin. He had to meet very specific criteria. He had to be human because it was a human debt. He had to be God because a human could only cover one debt. No one else -- no other human, not the Father and not the Spirit -- qualified for that role.

Some people debate the Trinity. Even though it appeared to be settled centuries ago, some still arise today and twist it or toss it. They do so at their own peril. Without the Trinity we don't have a qualified Savior. Without a qualified Savior we don't have Atonement. Without Atonement we don't have salvation. Without salvation we have no hope. Or, to put it another way, no Trinity, no Christianity.

(For a expansive listing of Scriptures on the topic of the Trinity, see my blog entry here.)

Tuesday, September 29, 2009

What Makes Christianity? The Atonement

We're looking at the unique nature of Christianity. Christianity differs from all other religions in a lot of ways, but the key area is "saved by grace through faith in Christ." What doctrines are essential to the structure of Christianity and why are they essential? We have now seen that the Bible is mandatory as a source document. I've discussed the condition of Man and why that's important. Now what?

The next plainly obvious doctrine of key importance is the doctrine of the Atonement. Given the condition of Man -- sinful to the core and justly deserving damnation -- what hope is there? If we asked the question solely from the position of God's justice, the answer would be "None." But God (one of my favorite phrases in all of Scripture) is also merciful and gracious. Now, He cannot violate His own nature, and justice is part of His nature, so God had to plan a means of satisfying both His justice and His merciful grace. Enter the Atonement.

According to Colossians 2, "You, who were dead in your trespasses and the uncircumcision of your flesh, God made alive together with Him, having forgiven us all our trespasses, by canceling the certificate of debt that stood against us with its legal demands. This He set aside, nailing it to the cross" (Col 2:13-14). There was, then, a "certificate of debt" -- something we owed -- and that debt was set aside by "nailing it to the cross". Paul wrote that we "are justified by His grace as a gift, through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus, whom God put forward as a propitiation by His blood, to be received by faith. This was to show God's righteousness, because in His divine forbearance He had passed over former sins. It was to show His righteousness at the present time, so that He might be just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus" (Rom 3:24-26). In this passage we see the term "redemption", an oft-repeated concept throughout Scripture in which we are bought back from a slave condition. There is also the lesser known word, "propitiation". This term references the appeasement of an angry God. Christ, "by His blood", bought us back from slavery to sin and removed the just anger we faced from God. This whole concept (called "the Atonement") was designed by God as a demonstration of His righteousness "so that He might be just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus." In sending His Son to pay for our sin on our behalf, God satisfied both His justice and His mercy.

Now, please note. There are a few necessities for this doctrine to be in place. First, the price that was paid was the death that was required for sin. Second, that price could not be paid by someone who owed it, or it would cover only their debt. Christ, then, had to be sinless or He would have owed His own debt. Third, for this payment to cover more than one man, Christ had to be more than a man. Well, you can see that this is going someplace ... later.

Take away the atonement and what do we have? We have no payment. We have the problem of Man's condition without a solution. If God is just, He must carry out the just sentence of death. If God does not receive payment for our debt and simply forgives the debt, we would certainly say He is merciful, but He is not just. A "saved by grace" of this sort violates the nature of God and, thus, produces no salvation at all. It simply produces a lesser god who is warm and merciful but not just. It isn't the God of the Bible. And Christianity collapses on the injustice of mercy.

The Atonement has been debated quite a bit. Most of the debate is not about its reality, but its particulars. In other words, most of those debating it aren't asking, "Was the price paid?" Without a price being paid, we have no hope. The debate is over to whom the price was paid. That would qualify as "non-essential". Remove the Atonement and there is no means by which we can be at one with God. If the certificate of debt is not paid and no propitiation made, God will remain in His necessary wrath against sin. We may disagree about some particulars of the Atonement, but the fact of the Atonement is not negotiable. It is an essential element of Christianity.

More Reading on the Atonement:
The Doctrine of the Atonement
The Atonement
The Atonement of Christ

Monday, September 28, 2009

What Makes Christianity? Man's Condition

So far in the series, "What Makes Christianity?", I have laid out the initial premise. Christianity is a religion (by English definition), but it is a unique religion. The primary belief that makes Christianity stand out from all other religions is in the phrase "saved by grace through faith in Christ." It is that premise from which I'm working. In the first entry, then, I explained how the doctrine of Inerrancy of Scripture is essential to Christianity. It is the basis from which we work. I listed that one first not because it's most important, but because I plan to lean on it for the rest of this discussion. So, what else is essential and why?

Most people like to think that humans are basically good. Oh, sure, you'll get a bad one from time to time, but deep down, people really want to be moral, nice, to get along. Anyone who says otherwise is just a negative thinker, a pessimist, a cynic. Assuming this as a valid description of the Nature of Man, we can pretty much eliminate Christianity as a viable religion. Christianity makes the stunning claim that "All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God" (Rom 3:23). There is none among us who is exempt (Rom 3:10-12). Despite the notion that all people are basically good, the Bible claims that all people are, at their core, basically sinful. The problem here is that God, Himself perfect, requires perfection as a prerequisite to having a relationship with Him. Now, if all have sinned, Christianity would say that all are in trouble. The just result of this sin condition, according the Christianity, is ... death (Rom 6:23). (Perhaps "in trouble" is a large understatement.) So humans at their core stand in opposition to God. From God's perspective -- referencing only His justice -- He is obliged to execute all humans. And since their crime is against the Supreme God, their execution must be supreme -- eternal death. No exceptions. No hope.

That is the basic Christian doctrine about the condition of Man. We are sinners, every one of us. We have earned damnation and have no means in ourselves of earning anything better than damnation.

So what if we mitigate that? What if we say, "Oh, that's too extreme"? What if we move Man's condition from "rotten to the core" to something ... not quite so bad? How is it essential? Well, first off, having established that the Bible is true, we would be violating that first point. But moving from there, if it is not true that all humans are sinful -- that "all have sinned" -- we find ourselves in contradiction to our basic premise: "saved by grace through faith in Christ." It has been argued from Pelagius through Charles Finney all the way up to today that "this whole 'Mankind is basically sinful' thing is not right. It is possible for humans to be good enough (by various means, depending on the arguer) to get to heaven. This whole 'saved by Christ' thing isn't necessary. Oh, maybe it's good, but it's not necessary." And we've just managed to turn Christianity into ... every other religion. Be "good enough" and you will be fine. You don't really need to be "saved". You simply need to be "good enough". Now, we can debate what "good enough" means, but unless it is "perfection", this approach eliminates Christianity at its core.

In order for people to need salvation, they have to be in peril. The Bible argues that all have sinned, that Man is basically sinful and stands in peril of eternal damnation. It is the first point, in fact, of the Gospel, the Good News. The Gospel tells us that "You're in danger of Hell" followed by the solution to that problem. Eliminate that problem and you eliminate the Gospel and Christianity. So the basic doctrine of Man's Sin Condition is an essential doctrine, not open to negotiation. It is an essential doctrine of Christianity.

Sunday, September 27, 2009

In everything give thanks ...

Rejoice always, pray without ceasing, give thanks in all circumstances; for this is the will of God in Christ Jesus for you (1 Thess 5:16-18).
When a promotion that you never expected comes through, complete with a raise ...

When your husband surprises you with a gift for no reason and whisks you off to dinner, just the two of you ...

When you pay all your bills and find out that there is still money in the account ...

When you spend some remarkably close time with the Lord ...

When you pray for something you desperately want and God says, "No" ...

When you apply for that new job ... and find out it's already filled ...

When your neighbors yapping dog wakes you up in the middle of the night ... for the fourth night in a row ...

When your wife forgets to wash the clothes you intended to wear to work this morning ...

When your boss tells you, "I'm sorry, but we're going to have to let you go" ...

When the doctor looks at your test results, shaking his head ...

When there is a policeman at the door and you don't know where your son is ...

When the bank statement says your account is empty and the landlord says your rent is due ...

When your parents demonstrate, once again, that they really don't understand you ...

When your store is robbed ... again ...

When the person you love and hope to marry tells you, "Let's see other people" ...

When your daughter shows up on your doorstep with three little kids and no husband ...

When the man you didn't vote for gets elected president and starts making changes you are opposed to ...
Rejoice always, pray without ceasing, give thanks in all circumstances; for this is the will of God in Christ Jesus for you (1 Thess 5:16-18).

Saturday, September 26, 2009

What Makes Christianity? - the series

Christianity is a religion. (To those of you who would disagree, I can't do anything about the English language. If "religion" is defined as "a belief in and reverence for a supernatural power or powers regarded as creator and governor of the universe, and the personal or institutionalized system grounded in such belief and worship", then Christianity qualifies.) We live in a world of many religions. What makes Christianity different? We believe that Christianity is the truth and the rest are not. What is different about Christianity?

The singular most obvious difference between our Faith and the rest of the world's religions is summed up in one phrase: "Saved by grace through faith in Christ." Christianity assumes that Man is sinful (where other religions disagree) and in need of salvation (where other religions disagree). Christianity holds that this salvation can only be given by unmerited favor (where all other religions hold that it is earned by being "good enough"). Christianity holds that the sole "qualifier" for this salvation is a singular reliance (faith) on a singular person (Christ) (where other religions have a variety of qualifiers). Christianity is the one religion that replaces the focus of "us" with "Him", a change of perspective from "How am I doing?" to "Every knee shall bow", a radical shift from anthropocentricism to theism.

Now, the world around us, filled with a whole host of other religions, has a tough time seeing these fundamental differences. Where Christianity claims that Christ is the only way, the world around us is quite content with "There are many ways to God" (or even "There is no God"). Part of the reason for this is that we've allowed it. Well-meaning folks have made it their purpose in life to soften the edges, to make Christianity more palatable to the masses, to avoid being a problem to non-Christians. In so doing, the central doctrines that make Christianity Christianity have been blurred or discarded ... and we end up with not-Christianity.

These central doctrines are what would be called "essentials". I wrote a post a short time ago about the essentials of Christianity. It wasn't popular, I know, and, to my discredit, neither was it supported. So I wanted to look briefly at what makes these things essential. Why are these things so important that they cannot be negotiated? I will address them from this premise: Christianity is unique because of the phrase "saved by grace through faith in Christ".

The first question is "Why do you think that this phrase is what makes Christianity unique? On what do you base this phrase?" Most of us should recognize that the phrase is almost a direct quote from Ephesians. "By grace you have been saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God: Not of works, lest any man should boast" (Eph 2:8-9). "Ah," the skeptic would say, "so you're basing it on that book." Yes. Christianity is not unique in deriving its doctrines from a book. Most religions have a book. We're not unique in referring to them as "sacred Scriptures". Christianity appears to be unique in that our Scripture alone seems to be under attack. Question the content of the Quran and you're simply being petty. Ask about the sacred Hindu writings and you're being stubborn. Raise your hand about the Book of Mormon and you're being prejudice. You can't question these Scriptures. They're sacred to their believers. The Bible, on the other hand, is both questionable and unreliable. It is at the very least open to wide (and apparently valid) interpretation. It is certainly not a unique book in any way. It is, just like all the other Scriptures of all the other religions, right in some places, misunderstood in many, and wrong in others.

If that's where we stand, Christianity ceases to be Christianity. Our certainty, for instance, that Christianity's uniqueness lies in a phrase found in a letter written by Paul to the church at Ephesus is mere opinion -- certainly not certainty. I mean, really, did Paul even write that? And why is it right? Or what makes you think you understand it correctly? "No, no," the argument goes, "this whole 'sacred Scripture' thing is just an outlandish belief common to most religions and perpetrated only by those evil, right-wing 'fundamentalists' (meant in the most pejorative sense possible)." In other words, strip off the Bible, and Christianity has nowhere to stand. It is just, as the world suspected, another religion among many religions. There is nothing particularly unique about this one. You Christians are making a mountain out of a mole hill.

The ground on which Christianity stands is, on the face of it, a singular book. That book claims to be "God-breathed", a term that goes beyond anything we know today. It isn't merely "inspired writings". It is breathed out by God to individual writers who, through their own words and personalities, expressd what God intended to have expressed. Quibble about details if you wish. Evidence, logic, experience, and history all provide us with a Bible that is reliable. If it is God-breathed, it is, as God is, without error. These are not negotiable because without them we do not have a reliable source document for Christianity and Christianity goes undefined, a vague idea based on individual preference and feeling. Remove a solid ground upon which to base Christianity and the discussion about the uniqueness of Christianity is over. It's just another religion like any other religion and you mad, right-wing wackos are the ones making it the "only way" by your crazy view on your "sacred Scriptures". Without this "crazy view", Christianity falls. Thus, this view is essential to Christianity.

I haven't offered here any arguments for the inerrancy of Scripture. I haven't given reasons why you should see it as such. I've simply tried to explain why such a view would be essential to Christianity in general. I've listed below resources for you to examine that offer arguments on the subject. Do your own homework. I'm not making the argument that it's true, here. I'm making the argument that it is essential. You can look at some of these arguments and see if it's true. If you have other favorite sources, feel free to list them in the comments section.

Sources on Biblical Inerrancy:
Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy
Is the Bible Inerrant?
Inerrancy and Infallibility of the Bible
Response to the Arguments Against
Defending Biblical Inerrancy
From GotQuestions.org
Is the Bible Authoritative? (Greg Koukl - str.org)
My own defense

Friday, September 25, 2009

Art and Life

In comments on one of my recent posts, my son and I joked back and forth about the "flux capacitor". He used it as an illustration of a point. I kidded him, "You know they're not real, right?" He kidded back, "Yes they are! I saw it on TV." All in good fun. But it got me to thinking. How much of my reality is determined by TV (or the media)?

Back in December I wrote a post about the problem of the news media. The news, by its very nature, reports the unusual. (We don't need to be told about the usual.) The unusual is then held up as the prevailing conditions and we begin to make our choices based on ... the unusual. The other day I told my wife, "Don't put the mail to go out in our mailbox. I'll drop it in the mailbox on the corner." She said, "They're breaking into mailboxes." She was concerned about a news item she had heard about some break-ins to those mailboxes on corners. Three of them had been robbed. So I was supposed to be worried that the letters I was sending (not checks, money, personal info, etc.) were in danger because three mailboxes had been vandalized in the past six months. I am not suggesting that my wife was out of bounds. I'm suggesting that, due to our current culture, she reacted perfectly normally. The reports of the unusual determined, in this case, her reality.

We often think that art imitates life, but, as Oscar Wilde said, "Life imitates art far more than art imitates life." I gave an example of the news media creating reality. What about the rest? Let's try some examples. If you've seen Enemy of the State, you likely now think that the U.S. government has secret organizations capable of reading license plates from outer space. For some reason, they are not capable of seeing faces from outer space because apparently faces are at the wrong angle, but license plates are not. (Go figure.) If you've watched any crime shows at all, you're pretty clear that DNA testing takes little more than an hour and crime solving is likely done in a day ... two at most. Certainly the majority of crimes these days are solvable because of modern forensics. Well, at least murders. I would guess, just from the stuff I've seen on commercials, that most people are pretty sure that sex early in any relationship is normal, that kids are much wiser than parents, that the American population is much more entertained by crude and rude humor than clean humor.

And on it goes. Since we tend to absorb rather than evaluate stuff fed to us via video screens, we allow our realities to be shaped rather than mirrored by the media. We assume the values of what we watch rather than questioning them. We assume things of those around us based on what we watch rather than asking those around us. We derive our worldviews and perceptions not from life, but from art. And then, when someone questions it, we are puzzled, confused, even irate.

The whole multimedia phenomenon in the last half of the 20th century has been an interesting experiment. It provides possibilities that were previously outlandish. It offers mass communication, nearly instant news, and vast resources of information and interaction. It is, however, still limited. It is influenced by Man's sin nature, corrupted by evil intentions, twisted by personal views handed off as "good" (or, even better, "neutral") to the masses. There can be valuable uses and useful information, but I begin to wonder if the dangers (which are far more than what I'm referencing here) outweigh the value? It would be impossible, likely, to actually evaluate those dangers and the benefits and do a comparison, but I'm thinking that we've created a system that already has and will continue to do increasingly grievous harm.

Thursday, September 24, 2009

It is a Gift of God

I left you yesterday with the necessity of writing this entry today when I said, "The faith that the Bible references is not something we drum up. It is something given by God. No, it isn't given to everyone. It is given as He chooses." "Oh? Really?" you might say. "Let's see you argue that idea with any real substance." Okay, let's do.

First, the perception begins with the certainty that faith is something we muster up. It's something that we bring to the table. It's something that we provide and God recognizes and then justifies. That's a nice concept. Is there any reason to think it's not true? Is there any reason to think that faith is given rather than developed?

The first and easiest spot to look is Rom 12:3 where Paul says, "God has allotted to each a measure of faith." Conclude what you will about how, when, who, or any other question, whatever else Paul is saying here he is definitely saying that God allots faith. Faith is a gift. Now, most people, seeing this, would likely conclude, "Oh, well, okay. Then faith is given to all people and we decide what to do with it." The first problem with this is that Paul isn't writing to "all people". He's writing to the saints in Rome (Rom 1:7). Then there is a logical problem. We know that justification is by faith. So consider the logical syllogism:

1) We are justified by faith.
2) All humans have faith.
3) Therefore, all humans are justified.

That is a perfectly logical syllogism, but we know it's not true. Still, we need to be more sure of this. Certainly the Bible isn't silent on the subject, is it? No, indeed. The Bible has much to say. We know, for instance, that Jesus is "the author and finisher of our faith" (Heb 12:2). He is the one who begins and completes our faith. In Acts 13:48 we read "... as many as were appointed to eternal life believed." The obvious implication is that those who were not appointed did not believe (did not have faith). 2 Tim 2:25 says that God grants (or doesn't grant) repentance to people. Paul also says, "It has been granted to you that for the sake of Christ you should not only believe in Him but also suffer for His sake" (Phil 1:29). We all get that. We are being given the privilege of suffering for Christ. Don't miss, however, the first mention. We are granted "not only to believe", but to suffer. Believing is a gift, a grant. Of course, there's always the ever-popular Eph 2:8-9. Most who make the claim I'm making go here first. I'm going here last because it's only a piece of the puzzle. Paul says, "For by grace you have been saved through faith, not of yourselves; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast." In normal Greek and English usage, a prepositional phrase references the thing before it. The "not of yourselves", then, would suggest that "faith" is in mind. Faith is not of yourself -- it is a gift of God. Some are inclined to argue. "No, no, the real reference is to salvation." So, faith is not a gift, but salvation is. The argument leaves me flat because there is a missing component in the sentence that is skipped. Three pieces make up the first phrase: Grace, salvation, and faith. Something there is "not of yourselves". They argue it's salvation. So we conclude that faith ... and grace are something we produce. Wait ... no ... that's not right. It seems to me that the "not of yourselves" is referencing the entire previous statement: "By grace you have been saved through faith." So grace, salvation, and faith are "not of yourselves". This is buttressed with the next statement: "Not a result of works, so that no one may boast." No matter how you cut it, if I provide the faith and the faith is the key ingredient, I have something to boast about. But, if God provides the faith, we have nothing left to boast about.

One other relevant passage came up in my examination of the question. In 2 Thessalonians, Paul asks the Thessalonians to pray for him and his team:
Finally, brothers, pray for us, that the word of the Lord may speed ahead and be honored, as happened among you, and that we may be delivered from wicked and evil men. For not all have faith. But the Lord is faithful. He will establish you and guard you against the evil one (2 Thess 3:1-3).
We saw in Rom 12 that God allotted to each a measure of faith. Now we see the reverse: "Not all have faith." Paul goes on to say that "the Lord is faithful" and that "He will establish you and guard you".

We are really reticent to think that we have nothing at all to do with our own salvation. Most people think "If you're good enough you'll get to heaven." "Good enough" doesn't work. We Christians realize that we're not good enough and we need a Savior. But we're still unwilling to give up our own contribution. Surely we contribute something. "I know! We contribute faith! Yeah! We exercise our own free will and we muster up the faith that is required and that's our small but extremely significant part in our own salvation. That's right!" Both logic and the Word seem to disagree. While we are certainly required to exercise the faith given to us, it would appear that even that faith that we are to exercise is a gift from God, not something that we produce. Or, in the words of the author of the hymn, Rock of Ages, "Nothing in my hand I bring; Only to Thy cross I cling."

Wednesday, September 23, 2009

What Must I Do to be Saved?

Given yesterday's post ("This is not what it takes to be a Christian, but Christians do these things"), this would be the next obvious question, wouldn't it? It was the famous question from the Philippian jailer. It was simple, straightforward, to the point. Actually, you don't hear it too often, and that's too bad. And Paul gave an equally simple, straightforward, to-the-point answer. "Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ and you shall be saved." Ah, yes, that's it. We're done. Let's bow in prayer, pass the offering plates, and go home.

Is it that simple? Is there more to it? Let's look. Without straying beyond the confines of the textual question/answer, is there more to this simple conversation that we need to see? Yes. First, the question presupposes prior information. It presupposes that the questioner knows he/she is lacking something, is in danger, needs rescue. ("Saved" has become so overused that people miss the point.) To ask the question first requires that the questioner recognizes personal peril (I'm in real trouble here) and personal need (I don't know how to get out of the trouble I'm in.) Therefore, the question itself addresses a prerequisite condition -- the recognition of guilt and separation from God. In other words, the question won't get asked if the person doesn't see the problem or the need. Second (and this seems painfully obvious but isn't), the question presupposes an answer. It presupposes that there is a solution to the personal peril and the lack of ability to avoid that peril. It assumes that God has put into place a means of ... salvation. So we have basic premises that underlie the question to begin with.

Moving on, then, assuming that the questioner knows of their spiritual peril and lack of ability to fix it and that God has supplied an answer (the one they're seeking), what is the answer to the question? "Believe." What could be simpler? Just ... believe. Mentally acquiesce. Accept as true in your mind. Believe. Unfortunately, today's English "believe" is not quite the equivalent of the Greek word that is behind Paul's answer. That Greek word is pisteuo. It is more accurately "have faith". "Faith" is not merely mental acquiescence. It is a confidence in, a reliance upon, placing one's weight on the thing believed. It isn't like believing in George Washington. This kind of belief is only genuine when you place your weight on it, when your reliance is there and only there. Faith in Christ is also an obligation of loyalty and fidelity to Christ. Faith is not simple mental belief; it is something that produces a response. Now, step back a moment. Remember, the prerequisite for the question is "I am in peril with God, have no means to fix it, and believe that He has." This faith, then, says, "There is no other means by which I can solve this problem. I am relying solely on this solution."

Now, having cleared up what "believe" means, we come to the object of that faith -- the Lord Jesus Christ. We can debate (as others have) whether that requires that the believer recognize that Jesus is Lord (see "Lordship salvation"), that He is Messiah, that He is God Incarnate (another implication of "Lord"). I think there are some parts of this that are genuine and some too far off. To be saved, though, isn't simply, "Yeah, yeah, I believe there was a Jesus." There is more than His existence. As a minimum, He must be the Jesus who is Lord, who was Messiah ... that Jesus. As Lord He demands obedience and as Messiah He came to save His people. A "Jesus" who is neither Lord nor Messiah is not the same Jesus that Paul is referencing. A deep, extensive knowledge and agreement with Messianic theology, Trinitarian theology, and the far-reaching implications of Christ as Lord is not in mind here, but neither is "whatever Jesus you have in mind" an acceptable possibility. It must be the same Lord Jesus Christ that Paul knew, the same one that walked with the Apostles, the one with the mission and authority to save and to rule. It cannot be the "analogy Jesus" who never actually lived but is a fine story about how to live (as some hold) or the "'brother of Lucifer' Jesus" who is one of many gods (as others argue) or some other variation. There is one and only one -- the Lord Jesus Christ.

There is a problem with all of this that is rarely addressed. I bemoaned the fact that the question isn't often asked. Scholars question whether the jailer actually meant what we see there. Was he saying, "How do I avoid eternal damnation at the hands of God?" or was he saying, "How do I avoid getting fired (or killed) by my employers?" Was it a genuine spiritual question, or did Paul simply provide the man with the better answer? We do not and cannot know. The real problem is this: Since humans are naturally dead in sin (Eph 2:1), hostile to God (Rom 8:7-8), and incapable of understanding (1 Cor 2:14), what would make them ask the question or be capable of understanding the answer? On the one hand, the question and answer are simple. On the other, a genuine question and a genuine understanding of the answer are not. At the mental level, it's all an easy thing. We understand all the words. We get all the components. That's fine, thanks. But at the spiritual level, both genuine understanding and genuine faith are impossible. You see, the faith that the Bible references is not something we drum up. It is something given by God. No, it isn't given to everyone. It is given as He chooses. (I'm leaving off the arguments and references here because I'm setting myself up for another blog entry, see?) So, while Natural Man can nod and say, "I understand all those words and I believe what it says", it is entirely possible (nay, an actual given) that such a person will think he or she is among the saved when he or she is not. How will I provide correction? I can't. That is God's job. He has to do an awakening (we call it "regeneration" or, in the King James vernacular, "quickening"). He has to provide the necessary faith. So while the concepts are easy to explain and clear enough, it isn't, in the final analysis, in our hands, but in God's hands. Careful analysis of word and context, clearly written explanations, and concise process steps don't produce either the faith or the understanding for this whole thing. That would be God's job.

Tuesday, September 22, 2009

Fruit and Nonsense

Those who have faithfully followed my blog along with the comments will remember [a guy who will remain nameless but made a lot of comments that you can read at your leisure]. [This guy] (quite understandably) took offense when he asked me a direct question -- "Do you think I'm not a Christian?" -- and I gave him a direct answer -- "No, I don't think you're a Christian." We aren't supposed to do that, are we? I mean, it's wrong to question other people's faith, isn't it? [The guy] was right to be offended, wasn't he? I mean, after all, he claimed to be saved by grace through faith in Christ. Who am I to question that? What kind of Pharisee am I ... making up other things regarding salvation that are not in the Bible? Didn't Paul answer the jailer's "What must I do to be saved?" with "Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ and you will be saved"? How dare anyone ask anything else?

I have to admit that it sounds convincing. It sounds like anyone who questions someone who claims "I am saved by grace through faith in Christ" is questioning Christianity itself. Hey, the phrase is even biblical, isn't it? So I take a half step back and ask myself "Is [the guy] (and all those others who openly or silently complained) right?"

Then I run across some very odd (or, rather, perhaps not so odd) stuff in my Bible. Jesus warned, for instance, of wolves among the sheep. He said, "You will recognize them by their fruits" (Matt 7:16). So ... now we're to become fruit inspectors? What fruit? Jesus goes on in that very context to say, "Not everyone who says to Me, 'Lord, Lord,' will enter the kingdom of heaven, but the one who does the will of My Father who is in heaven" (Matt 7:21). Apparently, then, there are going to be those who come to the Day of Judgment completely convinced that they view Jesus as Lord ("faith in Christ") but are completely misguided. The problem, according to Jesus, occurred long ago: "I declare to them, 'I never knew you ...'" (Matt 7:23). The relationship never started.

Well, it's all well and good for Christ (the perfect Judge) to inspect fruit and to determine who is or isn't saved, but what about us? Shouldn't we keep our noses out of it? I would say that, to some extent, yes, we need to avoid too much action here. In the parable of the tares among the wheat (Matt 13:24-30), the master tells his servants not to tear out the tares in the wheat because it would damage the wheat. Of this Jesus said, "The Son of Man will send His angels, and they will gather out of His kingdom all causes of sin and all law-breakers ..." (Matt 13:41). Removing the tares from the wheat is His job, not ours.

On the other hand, does that mean, then, that we are to be silent? If we are, the Bible is full of sinful writing. Paul wrote things like:
When you are assembled in the name of the Lord Jesus and my spirit is present, with the power of our Lord Jesus, you are to deliver this man to Satan for the destruction of the flesh, so that his spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord (1 Cor 5:4-5).

Purge the evil person from among you (1 Cor 5:13).

Or do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: neither the sexually immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor men who practice homosexuality, nor thieves, nor the greedy, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God (1 Cor 6:9-10).

For you may be sure of this, that everyone who is sexually immoral or impure, or who is covetous (that is, an idolater), has no inheritance in the kingdom of Christ and God (Eph 5:5).
It would appear that Paul is laying down these instructions to act as markers to tell if someone is in or out of the kingdom. In fact, the basic purpose of the John's first epistle is just that. It is largely a series of "test questions" for his readers to determine if they have a relationship with God or not. Indeed, the Bible is full of differentiators -- ways to determine "Christian" or "not Christian".

Now, the first problem here occurs when we think, "These things determine if a person is saved." No, genuine "faith in Christ" determines if a person is saved. These things are not the things that determine if a person is saved. They are things that indicate it. They are, to use the biblical term, fruit. An fig tree is a fig tree because it is a fig tree, not because it bears figs. But a genuine fig tree will bear figs. And it was Jesus who said "You will recognize them by their fruits." So, what "fruits" are there? We're not left to guess. We know, for instance, that there is "the fruit of the Spirit" (Gal 5:22-23). John has a whole listing of stuff in 1 John. But Paul makes an interesting summary: "The fruit of the Spirit is in all goodness, and righteousness, and truth" (Eph 5:9). Isn't it interesting that the fruit includes virtue (goodness), holiness (righteousness), and truth? Now, Paul is not saying, "In order to be saved, you must be virtuous, holy, and right." What Paul is saying is that those who have the Spirit begin to produce -- bear the fruit of -- virtue, holiness, and truth.

My concern way back then when I was upsetting readers with my concerns about their spiritual well-being was this. It wasn't "Have you come to faith in Christ?". Genuine faith in Christ makes a Christian. It was "When confronted with truth, do you recognize it or reject it?" Recognizing truth doesn't make you a Christian, but Christians (those with the Spirit of God in them) have certain characteristics and those who lack them ought to be concerned about whether or not what they thought was "faith in Christ" was genuinely faith in Christ. I'm not saying, "You need to do these things or believe these things to be saved." I'm saying, "True believers -- those who are saved -- do these things and believe these things." I'm not saying, "You have to bear figs to be a fig tree." I'm saying, "Fig trees bear fruit." Now, the folks of this world [like the guy I referenced at the start] would prefer that I shut up about this stuff. You know, let 'em go and let God sort 'em out. (No, they'd say, "Don't impose your views on others" which, by the way, is imposing a view on me.) I suppose that's an approach, but it sure seems like a cruel one to me. If I have information that people might need and withhold it, especially when it affects their eternal destination, is it kind of me to keep silent or to say something? I can't seem to conclude that the kindest thing for me to do is shut up about it. You decide.

Update: Edited to put the actual name of someone in brackets to remove his real name because he was offended that I referred to him.

Monday, September 21, 2009

Crucial Conversations

I'm currently in the midst of an interesting book. The title is Crucial Conversations: Tools for Talking When Stakes are High, by Kerry Patterson, Joseph Grenny, Ron McMillan, Al Switzler, and Stephen R. Covey. These guys set out to discover what it is that sets successful businesses apart from less successful businesses. In their study, though, they found out that the primary difference between the two was people. So they studied further what sets successful people apart from less successful people. As they studied this concept, what they found was that successful people had an approach to communication that differed from everyone else. Thus, the book is about crucial conversations rather than successful people or businesses.

What I have found fascinating thus far is that these men did not set out as Christians to produce something Christian, but what they have produced sounds decidedly Christian. The secret, they suggest, to successful interactions with people is to "start with heart". Now, of course, there is a lot more to it and I'm still working my way through the book, but at the core, they say, the best way to have proper dialog with people in the most productive way possible is to care about the people with whom you are having the dialog. The book even points out, "This is not a technique." You can't fake it. You have to genuinely care about the people with whom you are interacting if you want to have the best possible outcome. Funny thing. The command of Scripture is "love your neighbor." Kind of like "You have to genuinely care about the people with whom you are interacting." This, they say, is the absolute core and fundamental key to success in conversations at work, at home, wherever you care to go.

I am convinced that truth is truth. Or, as the saints before me put it, all truth is God's truth. Science equivocates. Philosophy meanders. Psychology wanders about. But in the end, I suspect, the truth will be that God was right from the beginning. People work better when they care about each other. Life is better lived with concern for our fellow man. Things are a lot smoother when we aren't self-centered. And I could go on, but it would start to get a bit pointed ...

Sunday, September 20, 2009

Great is Your Faithfulness

Consider the work of God, for who is able to straighten what He has bent? In the day of prosperity be happy, but in the day of adversity consider -- God has made the one as well as the other so that man may not discover anything that will be after him (Eccl. 7:13-14).
I recently used this reference in a post about the sovereignty of God when things are unpleasant. It says that God makes both days of prosperity and days of adversity. In the first we are to be happy. In the second we are to take it from the hand of God. All well and good.

I wanted to look at the last phrase. It gives, from Solomon's perspective, the reason why God gives both prosperity and adversity: "So that man may not discover anything that will be after him." What an interesting reason! Now, I'm quite sure there are a host of other reasons. I don't suppose that Solomon intended "This is the only reason God does this." But it is a reason. The reason is so you won't know tomorrow what God intends to do.

Lots of people like to guess when bad things happen. Job's friends in the book of Job were very happy to offer advice as to why bad things happened to Job, for instance, and they represent a fairly common approach. "Bad things happen to bad people; good things happen to good people." And it's just not true. People like to guess "It's a judgment from God." And it may or may not be true. It's one of the popular methods of determining success, too. "If things don't work out, it must mean that you're not doing what God wanted." Again, perhaps true and perhaps not. Specifically what Solomon claims here is that you cannot know. God does what He does -- pleasant or unpleasant -- for His own good reasons and we're not wise to try to guess at what that is without specific instructions to do so.

So, what's the alternative? If we can't guess, "This is why God did what He did when that unpleasant thing happened", how are we to respond? We are to respond as Jeremiah did: "This I recall to my mind, Therefore I have hope. The LORD'S lovingkindnesses indeed never cease, for His compassions never fail. They are new every morning; Great is Your faithfulness. 'The LORD is my portion,' says my soul, 'Therefore I have hope in Him'" (Lam 3:21-24). Hope in the Lord and His character, not in better circumstances. It's a much more stable place to be because we "may not discover anything that will be after".

Saturday, September 19, 2009

Blog!

Look, it's Saturday and not a lot of people are reading this, so I'll do a "Saturday-lite" post. Everyone okay with that?

I have friends out there who read my blog (or, perhaps, who don't) and who don't blog themselves. Some of them blog a little, but not much. Most of the people I know don't blog at all. So, this one is for all you who read my blog and either blog a little or not at all.

It is my strong recommendation that you blog. Okay, maybe not blog. But write. Why?

Well, writing gives you the chance to put down your ideas in a "solid" form. When you write, you are required to pull ideas out of your head, examine those ideas, put them in an explainable order, and then evaluate the explanation. Blogging (or something similar) has the added advantage of allowing others to evaluate the explanation of your ideas and say, "No, that doesn't make sense" or "Yes, you're right on that point."

I am of the opinion that people don't think so much these days. We are pretty happy with the feed we get from the television and the radio and the Internet and we don't really need to evaluate much at all because, happily, someone else is doing it for us. So we pick up the ideas that "feel" best to us and stand our ground on them ... without ever making them our own or even fully understanding them. We are in too many cases, I'm afraid to say, mentally lazy. And then we assume others did their thinking right and absorb their errors without analysis. Sometimes it really makes us look stupid. Most of the time, though, no one else is really evaluating these things, so no one notices that we might look stupid. Besides, the emotional debate is far more popular than the reasoned one.

"Oh," you say, "I can't write. I have no writing skills. I'm not good with words." Two points here. First, the quality of the writing isn't the point. Conversely, writing down your thoughts gives you the chance to improve the quality of your writing (among other benefits). No one writes well who has never written. If "I can't write" was the decision point for anyone who wrote, then no one would start writing. And the second point is like unto the first. I'm not suggesting that you aim to be the next bestseller author. I'm not suggesting you try to be some riveting writer with clever turns of phrases and spellbinding thoughts ... you know, like me. (Kidding ... just kidding.) I'm suggesting that you write for your own benefit.

So ... if you want to stand out, if you want to be a reasonable person, if you want to ... how about this? ... renew your mind, I would recommend you blog. Blogging is free so you don't have a cost problem. It forces you to think to some degree (the more the better). It requires that you explain yourself. It offers your ideas to others who may benefit from them and can also help you critique them. The added benefit of blogging is that you will very possibly have to interact with people who disagree with your ideas. If you use the opportunity properly, it might help you learn to interact with civility and argue with charity. But, hey, that's up to you, isn't it? (Trust me ... I've seen enough bloggers who don't see any requirement to offer civility or charity.) As a benefit to you, then, I say, "Blog!"

Friday, September 18, 2009

Pet Peeves

Through the years I've discovered that there are little things that bother me that, frankly, shouldn't. But they do. I'm not talking about the things people do or say that are seriously wrong. I'm talking about little things ... or at least little things to me. You know, little things like rotten grammar or poor spelling when it shouldn't be so hard. Usually I overlook it, but when it comes from people that appear to be just too lazy to bother, it bothers me. But there are worse things to me.

I really dislike it when people say things "I really hate it when ..." without actually meaning hate. I prefer it when people reserve the right words for these things. But we throw around words like "love" and "hate" and "good" and "evil" without really considering them. Is the thing of which you speak really that good/bad/right/wrong/wonderful/horrible? Or not?

It irks me when Christians defend their positions from the Bible. No, no, that's not right. Not at all. But two Christians will be discussing differing opinions on a topic, both deriving their view from Scripture, and one will say, "Well, Luther said ..." and the other will trump them with, "Well, I get my idea from the Bible." The suggestion is, "You don't." The implication is, "My view is the only right view because (apparently) I can't be wrong in my interpretation ... and since you are using other sources, I'll assume you're not using the Bible." When Christians discuss differing views of Scripture, can't we just admit that we're both talking about Scripture and drop this failed trump as if the other isn't using the Bible? A hint to Calvinists and Arminians, Presbyterians and Baptists, pre-millenialists and amillenialists, paedobaptists and credobaptists: both sides will be using Scripture. Show a little charity, okay?

A close relative is "The Lord showed me the meaning of that passage ...". I see. You have a special connection with God that I don't. And usually "the Lord" shows these people meanings of passages that no one has ever seen before. Really? You have that special a connection? Don't go there.

Of course, it really bugs me when people cannot discuss ideas with charity. At some point, it seems, it becomes personal. This one may comment negatively on a pet concern of that one and suddenly we're no longer discussing those ideas; we're discussing me. "Are you calling me stupid?" Or something like it. Even if it doesn't get said. There are triggers for all of us, it seems. Just mention the word "socialism" and I'll get angry responses from all directions (not necessarily aimed at me ... just angry). Just drop a word like "abortion" or suggest "homosexual behavior is sin" and people will be coming out of the woodwork not to argue the point, but to fight ... and from both directions. Can't we discuss ideas without getting personal? "I think that some of President Obama's plans are wrong" could very likely get a response of "racist!". Really?

But, then, maybe I'm just too sensitive. I tend to view most things with a bit of humor. Maybe I should practice more of that.

Thursday, September 17, 2009

Why Be Moral?

There are plenty of times that I've been told, "Keep your Christian morality to yourself." I've even heard it from "Christians". (The quotes there are my way of being generous. They may or may not be Christian ... I'm just not calling it into question right now.) Somehow there is an underlying conviction that morality is negative. It is a thrill-kill, a sad thing. It is a limitation, a mean streak, an overbearing belief. And it is, of course, individualistic. There is "your morality" and "my morality" and these are both equal in value and validity. So keep "your morality" out of my face.

I would guess that this belief is rather prevalent. Sometimes we see studies aimed at showing that God's version of the best family (mother, father, children) is wrong or that sexual purity is pointless. But most of the time we're just told, "Believe what you want; just don't force it on me." The term "force", explicit or implicit, suggests something "wrong". So encouraging moral behavior ... is wrong.

So I have to ask, why be moral? Why would I bother saying out loud that homosexual behavior is wrong? That's just my belief, right? I'm just being intolerant, right? Why would I hold in public that abortion is murder and murder is wrong? Why can't I let those others who believe that "it's a woman's choice" do what they believe is right? Why would I be so judgmental? And the Christians who say it are urging me away from these things because "it will push people away from the Gospel" or some such. So ... why be moral?

I believe that there is more to "moral" than rules. It's not simply "right or wrong". It's not simply "be good or not". It is much, much more. I am convinced that being moral is best. Now, let me say here clearly and quickly that being moral doesn't give you heaven. But what it does do is to make the "machinery" work best. What do I mean?

I believe that the man who is faithful to his wife is much happier than the man who is not. There may be some temporary pleasure, some immediate gratification, but in the end, recognized or not, the faithful husband is happier than the cheat. I believe that a person of integrity is better off than a liar, a cheat, a thief. I believe that those who give are more blessed than those who receive, that those who love are more fulfilled than those who demand love, that those who seek the welfare of others are more satisfied than those who seek their own personal pleasure. In other words, while being moral may not get you to heaven (because the demand of heaven is perfect morality), it will certainly make your life much better.

So I ask myself, "Why are they telling me to keep it to myself? Why is it judgmental or intolerant to want what's best for others? How is it more caring to keep the truth from others?" I imagine a fellow picking up a bottle of poison. Maybe it's a slow poison, taking years, prossibly, to end his life. But it is poison. He tells me, "Mmmm, I just love this stuff." And the people around me, seeing I'm about to say something, shoosh me. "Don't say anything," someone near me whispers. "Keep your opinion to yourself. He likes it. There's no need for you to foist your views on him. If you do, he may not even listen to you anymore. Don't be so judgmental and intolerant." Seriously, people, would I be more kind, loving, caring if I kept my mouth shut while this fellow poisoned himself? I don't think so.