Today we celebrate Veterans Day. It's a day we celebrate all Armed Services veterans who have served in the grand task of defending our independence.
The dictionary says that independence is "freedom from the control, influence, support, aid, or the like, of others." Think about that for a moment. Freedom from ... control, influence, support, or aid. You're on your own, folks.
We think of independence as the freedom to do what we want. That's not quite accurate. With a minimum of thought it should be abundantly clear that "independence" is the opposite of "dependence". And when it's put that way, I have to wonder ... is that a good thing? Oh, of course, we Americans are almost pathologically independent. We don't want anyone telling us what to do or asking anything from us. It's almost not freedom that we want, but anarchy -- the right to do anything if we so desire.
But I don't think we're made for independence. As we know from common sense (and John Donne), "No man is an island." Human beings do not thrive in isolation. You've heard the famous (and oft-misquoted) quip about bells, haven't you? That was part of the same quote from John Donne. He said, "Never send to know for whom the bell tolls; It tolls for thee." The reason he said that was because he said, "Any man's death diminishes me, because I am involved in Mankinde." Independence? Maybe not as good of an idea as you might think.
Me? I don't actually want independence. I want absolute dependence. Some argue that "God doesn't want robots." Maybe. But there is nothing I'd like better than to be God's robot. Not going to happen, I know. But I can still recognize the actual fact that "in Him we live and move and have our being" (Acts 17:28). The more time I spend working on "independence", the more irrational it is. Me? I want utter and complete dependence on God.
Like Button
Monday, November 12, 2012
Sunday, November 11, 2012
Holding Fast the Faithful Word
According to Paul, he sent Titus to Crete for a purpose. He sent him there "that you might put what remained into order, and appoint elders" (Titus 1:5). In that first chapter, Paul goes on to spell out the necessary credentials for an elder. One of the tasks of the elder is "that he may be able to give instruction in sound doctrine and also to rebuke those who contradict" (Titus 1:9). (I find that interesting, given the number of church leaders who aren't too concerned about rebuking those in their care. But that's not where I'm going with this.) He gives a reason that the elder will need to do this: "There are many who are insubordinate, empty talkers and deceivers" (Titus 1:10). Paul apparently was of the opinion that the church would be infused with "many" who would be "deceivers" by means of "empty talk" and "insubordination". Imagine that! (Or, should I say, "so true"?)
Paul does not, however, hang that requirement out in the air. He gives a method, a basis, a mode of operation whereby the elder can do this. Do you know what it is?
Okay? So here's the idea. First, an elder, who must not be a young Christian (1 Tim 3:6), has to have been taught the Word. The text, in fact, literally says he must hold fast the faithful word "according to the teaching". One teaching. A common teaching. It is the sound doctrine Paul entrusted to Timothy (1 Tim 4:6) and told him to pass on to faithful men (2 Tim 2:2). An elder must know the Word and have sound doctrine. Second, he needs to cling to the Word and be able to apply it in order to demonstrate sound doctrine. It is the basis for sound doctrine. (Note, by the way, that the sound doctrine that Paul was referencing was present then and being passed on then. That means it isn't something new, isn't something changing, isn't something recently discovered. Sound doctrine is historical, biblical orthodoxy. Don't let anyone convince you otherwise.) Additionally, he must have a firm enough grasp on the Word to be able to recognize error when he sees it and address it.
An elder's job includes both instructing sound doctrine and rebuking those in error. These are both predicated on a firm and continued grasp of the Word. While we may not all be elders, it would be wise, I think, to seek to hold fast to the faithful Word for purposes of sound doctrine and rebuking error. We don't all need to be elders, but we all need the Word, sound doctrine, and response to error.
What are you doing today to improve your grasp of the Word and sound doctrine?
Paul does not, however, hang that requirement out in the air. He gives a method, a basis, a mode of operation whereby the elder can do this. Do you know what it is?
He must hold firm to the trustworthy word as taught (Titus 1:9).In order to qualify as an elder, a man must hold firm to the trustworthy word as taught. It is the means by which ("so that") he will be able to both instruct in sound doctrine and rebuke those who contradict -- those insubordinate, empty-talking deceivers.
Okay? So here's the idea. First, an elder, who must not be a young Christian (1 Tim 3:6), has to have been taught the Word. The text, in fact, literally says he must hold fast the faithful word "according to the teaching". One teaching. A common teaching. It is the sound doctrine Paul entrusted to Timothy (1 Tim 4:6) and told him to pass on to faithful men (2 Tim 2:2). An elder must know the Word and have sound doctrine. Second, he needs to cling to the Word and be able to apply it in order to demonstrate sound doctrine. It is the basis for sound doctrine. (Note, by the way, that the sound doctrine that Paul was referencing was present then and being passed on then. That means it isn't something new, isn't something changing, isn't something recently discovered. Sound doctrine is historical, biblical orthodoxy. Don't let anyone convince you otherwise.) Additionally, he must have a firm enough grasp on the Word to be able to recognize error when he sees it and address it.
An elder's job includes both instructing sound doctrine and rebuking those in error. These are both predicated on a firm and continued grasp of the Word. While we may not all be elders, it would be wise, I think, to seek to hold fast to the faithful Word for purposes of sound doctrine and rebuking error. We don't all need to be elders, but we all need the Word, sound doctrine, and response to error.
What are you doing today to improve your grasp of the Word and sound doctrine?
Saturday, November 10, 2012
"Woe" is Not a Positive Thing
Oh, now, come on!
So, while NYC's Mayor Bloomberg is hard over in favor of murdering babies in the womb, he is compassionate enough to ban sugared drinks from the city's fast food outlets. Bad, you see. Ought not be. And now I come across a CBS report that he has outlawed food donations to homeless shelters. What??!!
"Woe to those who call evil good, and good evil; who substitute darkness for light and light for darkness" (Isa 5:20).
Just ... wow!
(Ironically, on the side of the story when I was looking at it was an ad inviting donations for people affected by Sandy. Sorry. Not gonna happen. The city can't evaluate the quality of the donations. It would be interesting to see if he'd try to be consistent on that. I'm not expecting it.)
So, while NYC's Mayor Bloomberg is hard over in favor of murdering babies in the womb, he is compassionate enough to ban sugared drinks from the city's fast food outlets. Bad, you see. Ought not be. And now I come across a CBS report that he has outlawed food donations to homeless shelters. What??!!
"Woe to those who call evil good, and good evil; who substitute darkness for light and light for darkness" (Isa 5:20).
Just ... wow!
(Ironically, on the side of the story when I was looking at it was an ad inviting donations for people affected by Sandy. Sorry. Not gonna happen. The city can't evaluate the quality of the donations. It would be interesting to see if he'd try to be consistent on that. I'm not expecting it.)
About Us
With the reelection of a president who brought about more national debt in his first term than any other president in two terms, who is the most adamant supporter of all levels of abortion, who is openly hostile to people with money, who has come out in favor of redefining marriage and pushes rules that edge out the freedom of religion, and so many more difficult views, we have moved to a new philosophical location as a country. America has shifted.
It was interesting (or maybe that's not the right term) to read about the demographics of the vote. For instance, men voted more for Romney than Obama. Married women voted more for Romney than for Obama. Single women, on the other hand, voted more for Obama. People in rural areas were more for Romney. Cities were more for Obama. The larger the city, the larger the percentage. Whites were more likely to vote for Romney while Blacks, Hispanics, and even Asians were much more likely to go for Obama. Older people preferred Romney over Obama. Younger people (18-29) by far favored Obama. Interestingly the 30-to-44-year-old age group shifted in this election to more Obama than Romney. Religion was an obvious factor. If you attended church, you were more likely to vote for Romney. If you were Evangelical, you were more likely to vote for Romney. If you were Protestant, you were more likely to vote for Romney. On the other hand, those without religion, Jewish folk, even Catholics were much more likely to vote for Obama.
Add to that the rest of the vote. Two states legalized marijuana. No, not for medicinal use; for recreational use. Both Colorado and Washington now allow marijuana for personal use. Three more states redefined the concept of marriage to include couples of the same gender. Beyond that, public polls indicate a continual shift on that score. While something like 33 states currently have laws defining marriage as a union between a man and a woman, given the federal appeals court ruling of the unconstitutionality of DOMA -- the Defense of Marriage Act -- and the support at the top for stripping the concept of its meaning, it shouldn't be long for those other states to cave in either by popular vote or by judicial legislation. In Massachusetts the measure to legalize assisted suicide barely failed. Don't expect that to continue to hold up. In Arizona a self-avowed anti-theist (as opposed to merely an agnostic or even atheist), bisexual, socialist openly opposed to stay-at-home moms is on the verge of going to Congress. In Wisconsin the first openly gay has been elected to Congress. In Nashua, NH, the first openly transgender was elected to State government. Times, they are a-changin'.
We're not looking at a presidential campaign. We're looking at a paradigm shift. The demographics tell the story. Christians want to retain former values ("conservative") and the rest do not. Married people want to retain former values and the rest do not. Older people want to retain former values and the rest do not. White people want to retain former values and the rest do not. Who is in the decline, then? Christians, married people, older Americans, and white people. Who wants to change to newer values -- to eliminate marriage as it was, to rule out drug rules, to tax the rich and share the wealth rather than simply earn what you can, to eliminate the rights of the unborn and the rights to freedom of religion? Those who have no Christian values and who have no investment in the traditional, longstanding concept of marriage. Those who have less, feel slighted, or are too young to think it through.
Face it. If you're a Christian, you're now in the minority in America. If your values are informed by the Bible or by the church, you're not going to have the popular view. If you're white, you're not right. If you're married, that definition is losing its meaning. (Don't let them try to tell you that the meaning of marriage doesn't matter. The voting results say otherwise.) If you're older than 45, you're views are not helpful. If you're satisfied with your life, you have no place at the table of ideas. As one man from China said on the Internet, "Warm congratulations to the American people. Under the wise leadership of the Party Central Committee headed by the wise and brilliant Obama, you have crushed the attempted usurping of power by the counter revolutionary group led by Mitt Romney." Welcome to the new America.
It was interesting (or maybe that's not the right term) to read about the demographics of the vote. For instance, men voted more for Romney than Obama. Married women voted more for Romney than for Obama. Single women, on the other hand, voted more for Obama. People in rural areas were more for Romney. Cities were more for Obama. The larger the city, the larger the percentage. Whites were more likely to vote for Romney while Blacks, Hispanics, and even Asians were much more likely to go for Obama. Older people preferred Romney over Obama. Younger people (18-29) by far favored Obama. Interestingly the 30-to-44-year-old age group shifted in this election to more Obama than Romney. Religion was an obvious factor. If you attended church, you were more likely to vote for Romney. If you were Evangelical, you were more likely to vote for Romney. If you were Protestant, you were more likely to vote for Romney. On the other hand, those without religion, Jewish folk, even Catholics were much more likely to vote for Obama.
Add to that the rest of the vote. Two states legalized marijuana. No, not for medicinal use; for recreational use. Both Colorado and Washington now allow marijuana for personal use. Three more states redefined the concept of marriage to include couples of the same gender. Beyond that, public polls indicate a continual shift on that score. While something like 33 states currently have laws defining marriage as a union between a man and a woman, given the federal appeals court ruling of the unconstitutionality of DOMA -- the Defense of Marriage Act -- and the support at the top for stripping the concept of its meaning, it shouldn't be long for those other states to cave in either by popular vote or by judicial legislation. In Massachusetts the measure to legalize assisted suicide barely failed. Don't expect that to continue to hold up. In Arizona a self-avowed anti-theist (as opposed to merely an agnostic or even atheist), bisexual, socialist openly opposed to stay-at-home moms is on the verge of going to Congress. In Wisconsin the first openly gay has been elected to Congress. In Nashua, NH, the first openly transgender was elected to State government. Times, they are a-changin'.
We're not looking at a presidential campaign. We're looking at a paradigm shift. The demographics tell the story. Christians want to retain former values ("conservative") and the rest do not. Married people want to retain former values and the rest do not. Older people want to retain former values and the rest do not. White people want to retain former values and the rest do not. Who is in the decline, then? Christians, married people, older Americans, and white people. Who wants to change to newer values -- to eliminate marriage as it was, to rule out drug rules, to tax the rich and share the wealth rather than simply earn what you can, to eliminate the rights of the unborn and the rights to freedom of religion? Those who have no Christian values and who have no investment in the traditional, longstanding concept of marriage. Those who have less, feel slighted, or are too young to think it through.
Face it. If you're a Christian, you're now in the minority in America. If your values are informed by the Bible or by the church, you're not going to have the popular view. If you're white, you're not right. If you're married, that definition is losing its meaning. (Don't let them try to tell you that the meaning of marriage doesn't matter. The voting results say otherwise.) If you're older than 45, you're views are not helpful. If you're satisfied with your life, you have no place at the table of ideas. As one man from China said on the Internet, "Warm congratulations to the American people. Under the wise leadership of the Party Central Committee headed by the wise and brilliant Obama, you have crushed the attempted usurping of power by the counter revolutionary group led by Mitt Romney." Welcome to the new America.
Friday, November 09, 2012
Three Wills of God
I thought I'd written on this before, but I can't find it. If it's there, it's just embarrassing because ... it's my own blog! Well, since I can't find it and since it continues to be an issue for a lot of people, I thought I'd write it ... again?
The question is regarding the will of God. Years ago when my youngest son was in high school, he asked me, "Dad, how can I know the will of God?" "That's easy, son," I answered. "Everything that has happened up to this moment in time has been God's will." Well, of course (as my kids came to know about their dad), it was not the answer he expected or wanted. "No, I mean in the future!" "Oh, that. Yeah ... that's much harder."
Seriously, what do we know about the will of God? Now, remember, we need to operate from the revealed rather than from what we want or think or premise. Let's not impose on God that which He hasn't given about Himself. So, working from what we know from Scripture, what can we tell about the will of God?
Well, there are different senses of the use of the word "will". We can say quite definitely, for instance, that it is God's will for us to be perfect. Perfect obedience. Sinless. Why? Well, He laid down commands and instructions. He clearly wills that we follow them. One of those comes from the lips of Jesus Himself: "You are to be perfect as your Father in heaven is perfect" (Matt 5:48). Clear enough. Got it. But ... we aren't. And if anything is clearer in Scripture than the fact that God wills us to be perfect is that we are not. Thus, we can clearly see that God's will is not accomplished in this sense.
Another use of the word "will" would include "desires". The Bible talks on multiple occasions about God's "will" in the sense of "desires". We know, for instance, that "God is not willing that any should perish" (2 Peter 3:9), and while we could discuss who "any" referred to, it is clearly His "will" in some sense. A parallel would be God "will have all men to be saved, and to come unto the knowledge of the truth" (1 Tim 2:4). That's pretty clear. God desires "all men to be saved." That's ... His will. And while there may be some outlying disagreement, I think the Bible is abundantly clear that not all will be saved. Indeed, narrow are the gates that lead to life. Conversely, "the gate is wide and the way is easy that leads to destruction, and those who enter by it are many" (Matt 7:13-14). Again, here is a sense in which God's "will" is stated clearly and, yet, certainly does not come to pass.
So we have at least two senses of the use of the word "will" in which God's will is not accomplished. And that gives us a bit of a dilemma. Job was confident that "I know that you can do all things, and that no purpose of yours can be thwarted" (Job 42:2). He knew that God "is unchangeable, and who can turn Him back? What He desires, that He does" (Job 23:13). Solomon contrasted Man and God by saying, "Many are the plans in the mind of a man, but it is the purpose of the LORD that will stand" (Prov 19:21). Paul assured us that God works all things after the counsel of His will (Eph 1:11). He referred to God as "the only Sovereign" (1 Tim 6:15). Heaven itself declares Him the "Sovereign Lord, holy and true" (Rev 6:10). So, which is it? Does He will perfection and desire the salvation of all and His will is blocked, or does He actually accomplish His will? Well, to make sense of it, the answer would be "Yes". That third use of the concept of "His will" would be a third sense. That third sense would be what actually happens. Nothing good happens without God willing it. Nothing bad happens without God willing it. All that happens occurs because of this Sovereign sense of God's will.
There are, then, three perspectives from which to view God's will. Theologians offer handy names for these three. There is His "preceptive will" -- that which He commands. There is His "will of disposition", that which He desires. These two are violable. The third is God's Sovereign or "decretive" will. That one happens ... always. Nothing happens outside that one. There isn't one maverick molecule. Some refer to His "permissive will", His "preceptive will", and His "decretive will" (like here). Others refer to His "intentional will", God's ideal plan, His "permissive will", that which He will allow and use, and His "ultimate will", that which occurs, good or bad, that He ultimately uses to accomplish His good purposes (like here). Lots of names. Same concepts.
Quite clearly, the names are our own inventions, but the concepts are not. They are straight from Scripture. Without these quite biblical concepts about God's will, you cannot arrive at a reasonable perception of God's Will in any rational or complete sense. On the other hand, understanding that God intends some things, permits others, and ultimately accomplishes His own plan will, when properly considered, produce a great deal of comfort, especially when faced with trials and troubles. It is ultimately true then that God does work all things together for good. And that's a good thing.
The question is regarding the will of God. Years ago when my youngest son was in high school, he asked me, "Dad, how can I know the will of God?" "That's easy, son," I answered. "Everything that has happened up to this moment in time has been God's will." Well, of course (as my kids came to know about their dad), it was not the answer he expected or wanted. "No, I mean in the future!" "Oh, that. Yeah ... that's much harder."
Seriously, what do we know about the will of God? Now, remember, we need to operate from the revealed rather than from what we want or think or premise. Let's not impose on God that which He hasn't given about Himself. So, working from what we know from Scripture, what can we tell about the will of God?
Well, there are different senses of the use of the word "will". We can say quite definitely, for instance, that it is God's will for us to be perfect. Perfect obedience. Sinless. Why? Well, He laid down commands and instructions. He clearly wills that we follow them. One of those comes from the lips of Jesus Himself: "You are to be perfect as your Father in heaven is perfect" (Matt 5:48). Clear enough. Got it. But ... we aren't. And if anything is clearer in Scripture than the fact that God wills us to be perfect is that we are not. Thus, we can clearly see that God's will is not accomplished in this sense.
Another use of the word "will" would include "desires". The Bible talks on multiple occasions about God's "will" in the sense of "desires". We know, for instance, that "God is not willing that any should perish" (2 Peter 3:9), and while we could discuss who "any" referred to, it is clearly His "will" in some sense. A parallel would be God "will have all men to be saved, and to come unto the knowledge of the truth" (1 Tim 2:4). That's pretty clear. God desires "all men to be saved." That's ... His will. And while there may be some outlying disagreement, I think the Bible is abundantly clear that not all will be saved. Indeed, narrow are the gates that lead to life. Conversely, "the gate is wide and the way is easy that leads to destruction, and those who enter by it are many" (Matt 7:13-14). Again, here is a sense in which God's "will" is stated clearly and, yet, certainly does not come to pass.
So we have at least two senses of the use of the word "will" in which God's will is not accomplished. And that gives us a bit of a dilemma. Job was confident that "I know that you can do all things, and that no purpose of yours can be thwarted" (Job 42:2). He knew that God "is unchangeable, and who can turn Him back? What He desires, that He does" (Job 23:13). Solomon contrasted Man and God by saying, "Many are the plans in the mind of a man, but it is the purpose of the LORD that will stand" (Prov 19:21). Paul assured us that God works all things after the counsel of His will (Eph 1:11). He referred to God as "the only Sovereign" (1 Tim 6:15). Heaven itself declares Him the "Sovereign Lord, holy and true" (Rev 6:10). So, which is it? Does He will perfection and desire the salvation of all and His will is blocked, or does He actually accomplish His will? Well, to make sense of it, the answer would be "Yes". That third use of the concept of "His will" would be a third sense. That third sense would be what actually happens. Nothing good happens without God willing it. Nothing bad happens without God willing it. All that happens occurs because of this Sovereign sense of God's will.
There are, then, three perspectives from which to view God's will. Theologians offer handy names for these three. There is His "preceptive will" -- that which He commands. There is His "will of disposition", that which He desires. These two are violable. The third is God's Sovereign or "decretive" will. That one happens ... always. Nothing happens outside that one. There isn't one maverick molecule. Some refer to His "permissive will", His "preceptive will", and His "decretive will" (like here). Others refer to His "intentional will", God's ideal plan, His "permissive will", that which He will allow and use, and His "ultimate will", that which occurs, good or bad, that He ultimately uses to accomplish His good purposes (like here). Lots of names. Same concepts.
Quite clearly, the names are our own inventions, but the concepts are not. They are straight from Scripture. Without these quite biblical concepts about God's will, you cannot arrive at a reasonable perception of God's Will in any rational or complete sense. On the other hand, understanding that God intends some things, permits others, and ultimately accomplishes His own plan will, when properly considered, produce a great deal of comfort, especially when faced with trials and troubles. It is ultimately true then that God does work all things together for good. And that's a good thing.
Thursday, November 08, 2012
Something to Think About
I think it's pretty clear that I do not think that electing Obama for a second term (or, in fact, a first term) was a good idea. If I left that in doubt, let me clear it up. Not a good thing. The president's agenda thus far has included advancing the cause of abortion, diminishing marriage, increasing sexual sin, theft through unwarranted taxation, and so on. These are not classified as "good". Indeed, I think it is clear that they would be classified as "evil" in my book.
However, you must remember: I stood and still stand on the Sovereignty of God. I believe, in fact, that nothing happens without God's express permission -- His will. I do believe that God ordains evil, allowing it in order to accomplish His purposes which, by definition, would be good. Evil remains evil, but God is able to use it ("intend it") for good. Indeed, I am convinced (because my Bible is abundantly clear on this point) that "there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God" (Rom 13:1). Taking the worst possible evil government that comes to mind, then, I would conclude that Stalin or Mao or Hitler were all "instituted by God". Just because Obama's agenda is less egregious than theirs doesn't diminish the fact that God put Him there.
One objection might be, then, "Why are you cast down?" You know, if it's all God's will, why be upset about it? Well, rationally, it is perfectly reasonable to understand and concur that God's will is at work and will be for good while still recognizing that it will be painful and difficult and ... upsetting. If you disagree, I'll stand in line behind Jeremiah and Jesus for you to correct. Jeremiah wrote Lamentations knowing that the judgment on Israel was God's work. It still hurt. Jesus prayed in the garden, "If it be possible, let this cup pass from Me," while still relying on God's will. It's human to hurt. It's not a bad thing.
I know, then, that God is Sovereign and has even instituted another round of leadership for a president that is proving himself to be an agent of evil. I know that it is, in the final analysis, good. I don't know what that final good is. But consider this. Generally speaking, when the authority that God institutes is an evil authority, He does it for purposes of judgment. It's not "blessing" or "joy", but judgment. It may be a temporary judgment or the demise of a nation, but it is judgment. So, what is the proper response when God brings judgment to a people?
Is it "Let's get out the vote next time!"? No, not really. Is it "Let's rally our cause and take back Washington!"? Can't find that in Scripture either. There is a singular proper response to God's judgment. That is repentance.
Repentance is not "feel bad". It is a change of heart. It is a change of direction. It is an awareness of genuine sin in our lives that cries out to be addresses, repudiated, and removed. What sin? Well, that's your concern. I can see potentials. We didn't care enough about our neighbors to be lights in the darkness. We didn't shine the Gospel in our corner of the world. We have been too much "friends with the world". Our good works have not reflected glory on our Father. Just some starters to consider. But we all have them and the proper response is not to rally the troops. It is to get ourselves right with God and to urge all around us to do the same. The Lord told Solomon, "If My people who are called by My name humble themselves, and pray and seek My face and turn from their wicked ways, then I will hear from heaven and will forgive their sin and heal their land" (2 Chron 7:14). This was a promise made to Solomon, to Israel. I'm not suggesting we have the same promise. It should be obvious, however, that if we, as adopted children of God, humble ourselves, pray, seek His face, and turn from sin, it could only be a good thing. On the other hand, if we see the current government (instituted by God) as a reason for pride, a reason to rally, a point of contention, and a possible cause for questioning God's wisdom, surely it's clear that this would not be a good thing.
Repentance for judgment or rally for rights. You choose. Something to think about.
However, you must remember: I stood and still stand on the Sovereignty of God. I believe, in fact, that nothing happens without God's express permission -- His will. I do believe that God ordains evil, allowing it in order to accomplish His purposes which, by definition, would be good. Evil remains evil, but God is able to use it ("intend it") for good. Indeed, I am convinced (because my Bible is abundantly clear on this point) that "there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God" (Rom 13:1). Taking the worst possible evil government that comes to mind, then, I would conclude that Stalin or Mao or Hitler were all "instituted by God". Just because Obama's agenda is less egregious than theirs doesn't diminish the fact that God put Him there.
One objection might be, then, "Why are you cast down?" You know, if it's all God's will, why be upset about it? Well, rationally, it is perfectly reasonable to understand and concur that God's will is at work and will be for good while still recognizing that it will be painful and difficult and ... upsetting. If you disagree, I'll stand in line behind Jeremiah and Jesus for you to correct. Jeremiah wrote Lamentations knowing that the judgment on Israel was God's work. It still hurt. Jesus prayed in the garden, "If it be possible, let this cup pass from Me," while still relying on God's will. It's human to hurt. It's not a bad thing.
I know, then, that God is Sovereign and has even instituted another round of leadership for a president that is proving himself to be an agent of evil. I know that it is, in the final analysis, good. I don't know what that final good is. But consider this. Generally speaking, when the authority that God institutes is an evil authority, He does it for purposes of judgment. It's not "blessing" or "joy", but judgment. It may be a temporary judgment or the demise of a nation, but it is judgment. So, what is the proper response when God brings judgment to a people?
Is it "Let's get out the vote next time!"? No, not really. Is it "Let's rally our cause and take back Washington!"? Can't find that in Scripture either. There is a singular proper response to God's judgment. That is repentance.
Repentance is not "feel bad". It is a change of heart. It is a change of direction. It is an awareness of genuine sin in our lives that cries out to be addresses, repudiated, and removed. What sin? Well, that's your concern. I can see potentials. We didn't care enough about our neighbors to be lights in the darkness. We didn't shine the Gospel in our corner of the world. We have been too much "friends with the world". Our good works have not reflected glory on our Father. Just some starters to consider. But we all have them and the proper response is not to rally the troops. It is to get ourselves right with God and to urge all around us to do the same. The Lord told Solomon, "If My people who are called by My name humble themselves, and pray and seek My face and turn from their wicked ways, then I will hear from heaven and will forgive their sin and heal their land" (2 Chron 7:14). This was a promise made to Solomon, to Israel. I'm not suggesting we have the same promise. It should be obvious, however, that if we, as adopted children of God, humble ourselves, pray, seek His face, and turn from sin, it could only be a good thing. On the other hand, if we see the current government (instituted by God) as a reason for pride, a reason to rally, a point of contention, and a possible cause for questioning God's wisdom, surely it's clear that this would not be a good thing.
Repentance for judgment or rally for rights. You choose. Something to think about.
Wednesday, November 07, 2012
Election Response
The elections are over (for which I am deeply grateful). Your candidates ______(won/lost). (Fill in the blank.) You are ________ (glad/depressed). We are looking at ________ (salvation/disaster). And no matter who won and who you wanted to win, the answers will vary.
You may have thought your vote helped determine who was in power. You may have felt vindicated on that notion or suffered a loss. But remember,
To all the Christians in America, then, I'd like to recommend a course of action. Regardless of whether the outcome was what you hoped or not, I would suggest this:
You may have thought your vote helped determine who was in power. You may have felt vindicated on that notion or suffered a loss. But remember,
There is no authority except from God, and those which exist are established by God (Rom 13:1).For those of you who were appalled by the outcome, remember. God is Sovereign and Jesus saves. The government is not and does not. For those of you who were delighted by the outcome, remember, "It is better to take refuge in the LORD than to trust in princes" (Psa 118:9). Delighted or worried, always keep in mind that "The king's heart is like channels of water in the hand of the LORD; He turns it wherever He wishes" (Prov 21:1).
To all the Christians in America, then, I'd like to recommend a course of action. Regardless of whether the outcome was what you hoped or not, I would suggest this:
I urge that entreaties and prayers, petitions and thanksgivings, be made on behalf of all men, for kings and all who are in authority, so that we may lead a tranquil and quiet life in all godliness and dignity (1 Tim 2:1-2).
America's Choice
Romney Concedes is splashed all over the place as President Obama wins a second term. Beyond Romney's loss, America loses. It loses in its fight for the lives of babies. It loses in its fight for the freedom of religion. It loses its weakening grasp on a workable or even logical economy. Marriage is on the way out by way of defining it into meaninglessness. It loses in this and more not because President Obama won, but because they voted him in.
The headline reads, "Minnesota voters reject marriage amendment." While 30 other states have just such an amendment, Minnesotan voters "opened the way for backers to push for legal same-sex marriages in Minnesota." Like someone told me in disgust after California's Prop 8 passed, "How would you feel if someone told you you couldn't marry who you wanted to?" The logic falls apart, of course, indicative of the whole problem. "How would you feel" is not the question to be asking, and "do what you feel" is not a good moral mandate.
There is a lot of what the president says and stands for with which I disagree to varying degrees. One thing I agree with him on wholeheartedly. America is not a Christian nation. "When the righteous are in authority, the people rejoice: but when the wicked rule, the people mourn" (Prov 29:2). And we Christians should remember that Americans have voted for the unrighteous leadership and positions. They weren't forced on us. We should rightly realize that we are not being the light in our world that we ought to be. And while the final judgment of humans is at last day, judgment of nations is temporal -- done in real time. There is no reason to expect continued mercy from God on a nation that has turned her back on Him.
The headline reads, "Minnesota voters reject marriage amendment." While 30 other states have just such an amendment, Minnesotan voters "opened the way for backers to push for legal same-sex marriages in Minnesota." Like someone told me in disgust after California's Prop 8 passed, "How would you feel if someone told you you couldn't marry who you wanted to?" The logic falls apart, of course, indicative of the whole problem. "How would you feel" is not the question to be asking, and "do what you feel" is not a good moral mandate.
There is a lot of what the president says and stands for with which I disagree to varying degrees. One thing I agree with him on wholeheartedly. America is not a Christian nation. "When the righteous are in authority, the people rejoice: but when the wicked rule, the people mourn" (Prov 29:2). And we Christians should remember that Americans have voted for the unrighteous leadership and positions. They weren't forced on us. We should rightly realize that we are not being the light in our world that we ought to be. And while the final judgment of humans is at last day, judgment of nations is temporal -- done in real time. There is no reason to expect continued mercy from God on a nation that has turned her back on Him.
Tuesday, November 06, 2012
Today We Choose A New Mirror
By thebumblinggenius
There are perhaps a thousand ways for us as Christians to fulfill our destiny in Christ by being a salt and a light in this deteriorating and dark world. One of those ways, and by far one of the easiest ways, is to vote. Today is a day set aside for just such an exercise.
People from almost every walk of life and worldview, with every kind of hope and dream will participate today in influencing the leadership and direction of our nation. Consequently our government will be, for us, a reflection of who we collectively are. As the changes that will be revealed about our society by this election emerge over time, I am confident of this one thing: Very few Americans are going to be enamored with what they see. This will be the case regardless of who wins any of today’s races.
I am confident for good reason. Man is fallen. A walk through history is but a walk through a gallery of portraits, one after the other, that portray Man’s failed attempts at repairing himself by replacing the mirror that is his government, as if replacing the mirror would somehow replace the reality it reflects.
For the believer, today ought to be a sober day as we contemplate this reality. For us, what will be reflected is the extent to which we have been a salt and light. We know that tomorrow, just as yesterday, the flow of blood from the millions of slaughtered human beings that now cries out to God for justice will continue unabated. We know that the sin of homosexuality will still be institutionalized in many states with even more states to follow. And we know that the family, godly marriage, and child-rearing will continue to be attacked, discarded, and disregarded.
Yet, for the true believer there is hope that lies beyond the folly of replacing mirrors. As the fallout from the election precipitates among society and the noise over who does or does not get what from who increases and as man rationalizes about what sin he can arbitrarily deem to no longer be sin and so forth, God’s kingdom will be advancing. To the extent that Man continues to reject the reality of his condition, his efforts at improving it will be futile in all but increasing suffering. Yet his efforts in the end will still bring about the advancement of the kingdom of God. This is our hope. God’s kingdom will come, on earth as it is in heaven. To fight it is to advance it. To join in its advancement is to advance it. Either way it is coming. And every tiny fraction of a voice that is each of our votes, whether they be for or against God, will serve only to accomplish His good pleasure.
There are perhaps a thousand ways for us as Christians to fulfill our destiny in Christ by being a salt and a light in this deteriorating and dark world. One of those ways, and by far one of the easiest ways, is to vote. Today is a day set aside for just such an exercise.
People from almost every walk of life and worldview, with every kind of hope and dream will participate today in influencing the leadership and direction of our nation. Consequently our government will be, for us, a reflection of who we collectively are. As the changes that will be revealed about our society by this election emerge over time, I am confident of this one thing: Very few Americans are going to be enamored with what they see. This will be the case regardless of who wins any of today’s races.
I am confident for good reason. Man is fallen. A walk through history is but a walk through a gallery of portraits, one after the other, that portray Man’s failed attempts at repairing himself by replacing the mirror that is his government, as if replacing the mirror would somehow replace the reality it reflects.
For the believer, today ought to be a sober day as we contemplate this reality. For us, what will be reflected is the extent to which we have been a salt and light. We know that tomorrow, just as yesterday, the flow of blood from the millions of slaughtered human beings that now cries out to God for justice will continue unabated. We know that the sin of homosexuality will still be institutionalized in many states with even more states to follow. And we know that the family, godly marriage, and child-rearing will continue to be attacked, discarded, and disregarded.
Yet, for the true believer there is hope that lies beyond the folly of replacing mirrors. As the fallout from the election precipitates among society and the noise over who does or does not get what from who increases and as man rationalizes about what sin he can arbitrarily deem to no longer be sin and so forth, God’s kingdom will be advancing. To the extent that Man continues to reject the reality of his condition, his efforts at improving it will be futile in all but increasing suffering. Yet his efforts in the end will still bring about the advancement of the kingdom of God. This is our hope. God’s kingdom will come, on earth as it is in heaven. To fight it is to advance it. To join in its advancement is to advance it. Either way it is coming. And every tiny fraction of a voice that is each of our votes, whether they be for or against God, will serve only to accomplish His good pleasure.
Labels:
By Dan
Monday, November 05, 2012
A Story Within A Story, Within A Story, Within...
By thebumblinggenius
The climax of a heart-wrenching story occurs when a distraught and broken-hearted Joseph reveals his true identity to his brothers. Everything is made right. Then an explanation for Joseph's suffering and his brothers' evil is given in Genesis 50:20: "As for you, you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good in order to bring about this present result."
But Joseph's story of being betrayed, enslaved, imprisoned, then raised to a position of authority is a story within a much larger story. There was going to be a famine in Canaan you see. And knowing that this famine was coming God used these event to establish his man in Egypt to save Jacob from starvation.
But if you see the world as I do, this story raises questions. Why would God put Joseph through such suffering? Could He not have simply made it rain in Canaan, and thereby prevented the famine? This is just the way my mind works. And this divergence in thinking styles become more obvious in my relationships with others. Someone says to me something like, "Isn't God good? He knew that I was going to lock my keys in the car so he caused my husband to get off work early so that he would be available to rescue me."
"Well, I suppose." I respond, "But wouldn't it have been simpler if He had simply reminded you to take your keys?"
You see, I have a story. And you have a story also. But there is a larger story within which our stories are taking place. And chances are that those stories are occurring within even larger stories that span a time far beyond our own years on this earth or understanding. So what is that story? In an attempt to grapple with that question, let’s go back to Joseph's story.
Because of Joseph's suffering his family was saved from starvation. They all moved into Egypt and set up shop there ... and lived happily ever after. Well ... maybe not. We get a clue that there is more going on as Joseph's life draws to a close. On his deathbed, he tells his family to take his bones with them when they leave. Joseph knew that his story was but a piece in a much larger story that was still being written.
This larger story begins to unfold as we read these ominous words in chapter 1 of Exodus. Verse 8: "Now a new king arose over Egypt, who did not know Joseph." So did God fail again? Couldn't God have caused the people to remember? Well as it turns out God was about to expand the horizons of this story. The modern Pharaoh was about to oppress the Isaralites. In our modern vernacular one might say that the Pharaoh was Herbrewphobic. The children of Israel then cried out to God and He began to orchestrate a rescue.
So Moses comes onto the scene and leads the people out of the land that had earlier been a refuge. Through miraculous events the "Children of Israel" delivered. God came to the rescue again. But is this just another story that tacks onto the previous one? Or is it still a story within a story, and if so, what is that story?
The key I think can be found as God repeatedly reminds His people from their great exodus on to remember "the God that brought you up out of Egypt." So why would God remind them over and over that he was their deliverer; that he He was the God that brought them up out of Egypt? The answer is simple really, so simple that it perhaps is easy to miss. It is because God demands glory. We are weak. We are pawns in a larger story. We deserve no glory, no recognition, no credit or merit. This is His story and He will be ultimately glorified. The moment that we think that any of our story is about us, we are sure to miss the object of our story: His glory.
So, what does this have to do with me? Well it seems obvious that we are apparently made to need purpose in life, among other things. We can endure incredible suffering if we understand that it is for a purpose. How many times, for example, do we hear someone, after enduring something unpleasant, console themselves with "Everything happens for a reason"? If I consider myself the center of that reason then I've missed it; but if that reason is His glory, then I've come to a better understanding of the reality within which I live out my story.
The climax of a heart-wrenching story occurs when a distraught and broken-hearted Joseph reveals his true identity to his brothers. Everything is made right. Then an explanation for Joseph's suffering and his brothers' evil is given in Genesis 50:20: "As for you, you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good in order to bring about this present result."
But Joseph's story of being betrayed, enslaved, imprisoned, then raised to a position of authority is a story within a much larger story. There was going to be a famine in Canaan you see. And knowing that this famine was coming God used these event to establish his man in Egypt to save Jacob from starvation.
But if you see the world as I do, this story raises questions. Why would God put Joseph through such suffering? Could He not have simply made it rain in Canaan, and thereby prevented the famine? This is just the way my mind works. And this divergence in thinking styles become more obvious in my relationships with others. Someone says to me something like, "Isn't God good? He knew that I was going to lock my keys in the car so he caused my husband to get off work early so that he would be available to rescue me."
"Well, I suppose." I respond, "But wouldn't it have been simpler if He had simply reminded you to take your keys?"
You see, I have a story. And you have a story also. But there is a larger story within which our stories are taking place. And chances are that those stories are occurring within even larger stories that span a time far beyond our own years on this earth or understanding. So what is that story? In an attempt to grapple with that question, let’s go back to Joseph's story.
Because of Joseph's suffering his family was saved from starvation. They all moved into Egypt and set up shop there ... and lived happily ever after. Well ... maybe not. We get a clue that there is more going on as Joseph's life draws to a close. On his deathbed, he tells his family to take his bones with them when they leave. Joseph knew that his story was but a piece in a much larger story that was still being written.
This larger story begins to unfold as we read these ominous words in chapter 1 of Exodus. Verse 8: "Now a new king arose over Egypt, who did not know Joseph." So did God fail again? Couldn't God have caused the people to remember? Well as it turns out God was about to expand the horizons of this story. The modern Pharaoh was about to oppress the Isaralites. In our modern vernacular one might say that the Pharaoh was Herbrewphobic. The children of Israel then cried out to God and He began to orchestrate a rescue.
So Moses comes onto the scene and leads the people out of the land that had earlier been a refuge. Through miraculous events the "Children of Israel" delivered. God came to the rescue again. But is this just another story that tacks onto the previous one? Or is it still a story within a story, and if so, what is that story?
The key I think can be found as God repeatedly reminds His people from their great exodus on to remember "the God that brought you up out of Egypt." So why would God remind them over and over that he was their deliverer; that he He was the God that brought them up out of Egypt? The answer is simple really, so simple that it perhaps is easy to miss. It is because God demands glory. We are weak. We are pawns in a larger story. We deserve no glory, no recognition, no credit or merit. This is His story and He will be ultimately glorified. The moment that we think that any of our story is about us, we are sure to miss the object of our story: His glory.
So, what does this have to do with me? Well it seems obvious that we are apparently made to need purpose in life, among other things. We can endure incredible suffering if we understand that it is for a purpose. How many times, for example, do we hear someone, after enduring something unpleasant, console themselves with "Everything happens for a reason"? If I consider myself the center of that reason then I've missed it; but if that reason is His glory, then I've come to a better understanding of the reality within which I live out my story.
Labels:
By Dan
Sunday, November 04, 2012
A Firm Foundation
I was raised in the church. All us kids knew the song (complete with hand motions). "The foolish man built his house upon the sand ... and the rain came tumblin' down." What happened? Well, of course, "the foolish man's house went splat!" And there was the counterpoint: "The wise man built his house upon the rock ... and the rain came tumblin' down." His house "stood firm". And it doesn't take a children's song to know that the concept comes from Jesus.
It is no surprise, then, that Satan started his assault on God and His creation with "Did God say ...?" Question authority? Maybe. But it doesn't really take a bomb here or fire. Erode the foundation. If the one positive thing we can know is that which God tells us is so and you can erode the one positive thing we know, we're living in a house of cards, the foolish man's house, ready to collapse at the slightest breeze or the first rain.
Satan's attack hasn't changed. It is still "Did God say ...?" In the garden he relied on Eve's memory (and how well she listened to Adam). Today it isn't a matter of memory. We have God's Word in writing. To "Did God say ...?" we merely have to reply, "Hang on a minute ... I'll look it up." Of course, it's not that simple, is it? "Did God say that its a sin to run a red light?" No, of course not. You have to read what He did say and interpolate. "Every person is to be in subjection to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God, and those which exist are established by God. Therefore whoever resists authority has opposed the ordinance of God; and they who have opposed will receive condemnation upon themselves" (Rom 13:1-2). Do the math. Authority says, "Red light: Stop!" We would be required to stop. Not merely because they said it, but because "whoever resists authority has opposed the ordinance of God". And opposing the ordinance of God is ... you got it ... sin. Still, the answers are there.
Satan still hasn't changed. From one side you'll hear, "That ol' stuff? It's man-made. It's poppycock! Don't listen!" ("No, God didn't say.") Another side will tell you, "Well, sure, maybe He did, but who can really know what it all means? Or what any of it means? It's legend, myth, exaggeration, culturally informed gobbledy gook. Maybe God did say, but we can't say what." ("Maybe, but who knows?") Or you'll hear, "Sure, it's God's Word, but it's wrong to be certain that you understand it. Do your best. Make sure it aligns with what you know to be true rather than simply what it says. That would be nonsensical. Don't go by hunches!" ("Yes, but don't be too sure.")
How do those kinds of disasters occur? Eroding the foundation. Eroding the foundation of God's Word is Satan's favorite tactic. Jesus, on the other hand, assured us that building our house on His Word by hearing and acting on it produces a solid foundation. Don't let the eroding forces, launched originally by Satan and perpetuated by His "children", allow that firm foundation to erode your footing.
Get on that firm footing. Build your house on the foundation. Fight the erosion. Stand on the solid rock. Recheck your footing every chance you get against that foundation. Daily is good. More is even better. Memorize it. And don't be afraid of it. "Did God say ...?" We know where that lie comes from.
Everyone who hears these words of Mine and acts on them, may be compared to a wise man who built his house on the rock. And the rain fell, and the floods came, and the winds blew and slammed against that house; and yet it did not fall, for it had been founded on the rock. Everyone who hears these words of Mine and does not act on them, will be like a foolish man who built his house on the sand. The rain fell, and the floods came, and the winds blew and slammed against that house; and it fell--and great was its fall" (Matt 7:24-27).Perhaps you've seen the image from Sandy's devastation with the roller coaster in the ocean? Stunning. Sandy isn't alone. Other similar pictures show something quite stunning. Apparently if you take some water and run it under your foundation, you lose everything. It doesn't take a bomb or fire. All you have to do is erode the foundation and the building collapses. Simple. Easy. Devastating.
It is no surprise, then, that Satan started his assault on God and His creation with "Did God say ...?" Question authority? Maybe. But it doesn't really take a bomb here or fire. Erode the foundation. If the one positive thing we can know is that which God tells us is so and you can erode the one positive thing we know, we're living in a house of cards, the foolish man's house, ready to collapse at the slightest breeze or the first rain.
Satan's attack hasn't changed. It is still "Did God say ...?" In the garden he relied on Eve's memory (and how well she listened to Adam). Today it isn't a matter of memory. We have God's Word in writing. To "Did God say ...?" we merely have to reply, "Hang on a minute ... I'll look it up." Of course, it's not that simple, is it? "Did God say that its a sin to run a red light?" No, of course not. You have to read what He did say and interpolate. "Every person is to be in subjection to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God, and those which exist are established by God. Therefore whoever resists authority has opposed the ordinance of God; and they who have opposed will receive condemnation upon themselves" (Rom 13:1-2). Do the math. Authority says, "Red light: Stop!" We would be required to stop. Not merely because they said it, but because "whoever resists authority has opposed the ordinance of God". And opposing the ordinance of God is ... you got it ... sin. Still, the answers are there.
Satan still hasn't changed. From one side you'll hear, "That ol' stuff? It's man-made. It's poppycock! Don't listen!" ("No, God didn't say.") Another side will tell you, "Well, sure, maybe He did, but who can really know what it all means? Or what any of it means? It's legend, myth, exaggeration, culturally informed gobbledy gook. Maybe God did say, but we can't say what." ("Maybe, but who knows?") Or you'll hear, "Sure, it's God's Word, but it's wrong to be certain that you understand it. Do your best. Make sure it aligns with what you know to be true rather than simply what it says. That would be nonsensical. Don't go by hunches!" ("Yes, but don't be too sure.")
How do those kinds of disasters occur? Eroding the foundation. Eroding the foundation of God's Word is Satan's favorite tactic. Jesus, on the other hand, assured us that building our house on His Word by hearing and acting on it produces a solid foundation. Don't let the eroding forces, launched originally by Satan and perpetuated by His "children", allow that firm foundation to erode your footing.
Get on that firm footing. Build your house on the foundation. Fight the erosion. Stand on the solid rock. Recheck your footing every chance you get against that foundation. Daily is good. More is even better. Memorize it. And don't be afraid of it. "Did God say ...?" We know where that lie comes from.
Saturday, November 03, 2012
Liberals
I have on multiple occasions bemoaned the decline (demise?) of the English language. We've been losing terms and, with them, concepts. The language has been evolving because, well, it is a living language, but it hasn't necessarily been improving. It has been dropping important ideas, obscuring important realities and further deterring communication. I ran across another prime example. It's appropriate at the moment. And the good news is it's not about "marriage", homosexual sin, or even Reformed theology! Woohoo!! The bad news, I suppose, is that it's about politics ... and religion.
Every functioning conservative knows that the "enemy" (using the term loosely) is "liberals". Those darned liberals will be the end of us all. Indeed, most liberals don't like being labeled with the term. It appears to be an epithet primarily applied by conservatives. So we are all pretty sure that "liberal" is not intended as a compliment.
Well, let's take a moment on that. Years ago my then junior-high-aged son came home from public school excited. "Dad," he said, "I finally learned the difference between a liberal and a conservative!" "Oh? What's that?" "My teacher told me that liberals want to share with everyone and conservatives just want to keep their own." Indeed, that is a popular perspective, is it not? I keep hearing that same concept offered by the Democratic Party these days. "The Republican platform is 'I have mine; you're on your own.' Well, the Democrats think we're all in this together!" (Wild cheers from the crowd.) Of course, I had to explain to my son that he had been the victim of a lie, but where did it come from? Quite clearly it came from the word.
From the dictionary,
"Liberal adjective
1. favorable to progress or reform, as in political or religious affairs.
2. (often initial capital letter) noting or pertaining to a political party advocating measures of progressive political reform.
3. of, pertaining to, based on, or advocating liberalism.
4. favorable to or in accord with concepts of maximum individual freedom possible, especially as guaranteed by law and secured by governmental protection of civil liberties.
5. favoring or permitting freedom of action, especially with respect to matters of personal belief or expression."
Okay, now running with the dictionary definitions, what do we find? Liberals "favor progress", advocate "liberalism", favor the "maximum individual freedom possible", and favor "permitting freedom of action, especially with respect to matters of personal belief". By inference, then, "conservative" would be opposing progress, denying freedom, and disrespecting matters of personal belief. Now you tell me; which side is good and which is bad?
Wait! It gets worse! One helpful way to figure out what a term means is by the synonyms available for it. So for "liberal" we find, "Progressive, broad-minded, unprejudiced, beneficent, charitable, openhanded, munificent, unstinting, lavish. See generous."
Oh, that's helpful. So the antonyms beyond "conservative" are "reactionary, intolerant".
See? It's all clear now. You may have thought that "liberal" was a bad thing, but what does that make you? You're narrow-minded, prejudiced, stingy, selfish! That, my friends, is "conservative". Who wants to be conservative? I know I don't!
The problem, of course, is that these terms do not rightly reflect the concept of liberalism, the ideas trying to be put across by the use of the term. Liberalism, for instance, favors "individual rights", but not for all individuals. Taxation for the rich, for instance, must be massively higher than taxation for those with less. Rich individuals are not to be afforded the same rights as those with less. Liberalism encourages religious tolerance. Thus, being intolerant of Muslims, for instance, is wrong. Being intolerant of Christians is acceptable. (Isn't it odd that so many liberals rise to the defense of Muslims and then deride conservative Christians as being too much like Muslims?) Liberalism is very much about limited government. Except, of course, where big (and apparently ever-growing) government is required to accomplish the goals. In one definition of liberalism I find my biggest problem with it: "A political theory founded on the natural goodness of humans and the autonomy of the individual and favoring civil and political liberties, government by law with the consent of the governed, and protection from arbitrary authority." Beyond the political theory, liberalism is found in religion, such as " A 19th-century Protestant movement that favored free intellectual inquiry, stressed the ethical and humanitarian content of Christianity, and de-emphasized dogmatic theology."
So, let's see if we have this right now. A liberal is one who advocates liberalism. Liberalism is based on the belief that people are basically good. It de-emphasizes dogmatic theology (which would be necessary if you're going to go with "people are basically good") and encourages "limited government" when it serves the purpose and not when it doesn't and "individual rights" when the rights in question belong to the larger block of voters, but not the rights of the smaller numbers of people outside their favor. It is "generous" in the sense that it plans to take from those who have more in order to give to those who do not have as much. It fundamentally "emphasizes freedom from tradition and authority" and "the adjustment of religious beliefs to scientific conceptions."
Wow! That's not at all what the first definitions of "liberal" suggested, was it? And this was my point. The term means one thing and the way it is carried out is another thing and the two seem to be completely unrelated. Every Christian ought to be identified as "liberal" in the sense of giving, caring, generous, tolerant, freedom-loving, even limited government. But the word and the concepts have so devolved that the language doesn't get that across anymore. And we're not paying attention, so we don't get that. (And as I had to explain to my son, "conservative" does not mean, "I have mine; you're on your own.")
Every functioning conservative knows that the "enemy" (using the term loosely) is "liberals". Those darned liberals will be the end of us all. Indeed, most liberals don't like being labeled with the term. It appears to be an epithet primarily applied by conservatives. So we are all pretty sure that "liberal" is not intended as a compliment.
Well, let's take a moment on that. Years ago my then junior-high-aged son came home from public school excited. "Dad," he said, "I finally learned the difference between a liberal and a conservative!" "Oh? What's that?" "My teacher told me that liberals want to share with everyone and conservatives just want to keep their own." Indeed, that is a popular perspective, is it not? I keep hearing that same concept offered by the Democratic Party these days. "The Republican platform is 'I have mine; you're on your own.' Well, the Democrats think we're all in this together!" (Wild cheers from the crowd.) Of course, I had to explain to my son that he had been the victim of a lie, but where did it come from? Quite clearly it came from the word.
From the dictionary,
"Liberal adjective
1. favorable to progress or reform, as in political or religious affairs.
2. (often initial capital letter) noting or pertaining to a political party advocating measures of progressive political reform.
3. of, pertaining to, based on, or advocating liberalism.
4. favorable to or in accord with concepts of maximum individual freedom possible, especially as guaranteed by law and secured by governmental protection of civil liberties.
5. favoring or permitting freedom of action, especially with respect to matters of personal belief or expression."
Okay, now running with the dictionary definitions, what do we find? Liberals "favor progress", advocate "liberalism", favor the "maximum individual freedom possible", and favor "permitting freedom of action, especially with respect to matters of personal belief". By inference, then, "conservative" would be opposing progress, denying freedom, and disrespecting matters of personal belief. Now you tell me; which side is good and which is bad?
Wait! It gets worse! One helpful way to figure out what a term means is by the synonyms available for it. So for "liberal" we find, "Progressive, broad-minded, unprejudiced, beneficent, charitable, openhanded, munificent, unstinting, lavish. See generous."
Oh, that's helpful. So the antonyms beyond "conservative" are "reactionary, intolerant".
See? It's all clear now. You may have thought that "liberal" was a bad thing, but what does that make you? You're narrow-minded, prejudiced, stingy, selfish! That, my friends, is "conservative". Who wants to be conservative? I know I don't!
The problem, of course, is that these terms do not rightly reflect the concept of liberalism, the ideas trying to be put across by the use of the term. Liberalism, for instance, favors "individual rights", but not for all individuals. Taxation for the rich, for instance, must be massively higher than taxation for those with less. Rich individuals are not to be afforded the same rights as those with less. Liberalism encourages religious tolerance. Thus, being intolerant of Muslims, for instance, is wrong. Being intolerant of Christians is acceptable. (Isn't it odd that so many liberals rise to the defense of Muslims and then deride conservative Christians as being too much like Muslims?) Liberalism is very much about limited government. Except, of course, where big (and apparently ever-growing) government is required to accomplish the goals. In one definition of liberalism I find my biggest problem with it: "A political theory founded on the natural goodness of humans and the autonomy of the individual and favoring civil and political liberties, government by law with the consent of the governed, and protection from arbitrary authority." Beyond the political theory, liberalism is found in religion, such as " A 19th-century Protestant movement that favored free intellectual inquiry, stressed the ethical and humanitarian content of Christianity, and de-emphasized dogmatic theology."
So, let's see if we have this right now. A liberal is one who advocates liberalism. Liberalism is based on the belief that people are basically good. It de-emphasizes dogmatic theology (which would be necessary if you're going to go with "people are basically good") and encourages "limited government" when it serves the purpose and not when it doesn't and "individual rights" when the rights in question belong to the larger block of voters, but not the rights of the smaller numbers of people outside their favor. It is "generous" in the sense that it plans to take from those who have more in order to give to those who do not have as much. It fundamentally "emphasizes freedom from tradition and authority" and "the adjustment of religious beliefs to scientific conceptions."
Wow! That's not at all what the first definitions of "liberal" suggested, was it? And this was my point. The term means one thing and the way it is carried out is another thing and the two seem to be completely unrelated. Every Christian ought to be identified as "liberal" in the sense of giving, caring, generous, tolerant, freedom-loving, even limited government. But the word and the concepts have so devolved that the language doesn't get that across anymore. And we're not paying attention, so we don't get that. (And as I had to explain to my son, "conservative" does not mean, "I have mine; you're on your own.")
Labels:
Politics
Friday, November 02, 2012
Taken for Granted
The Bible seems to like to use the word, "granted". The Lord granted Isaac's prayer (Gen 25:21), granted Isaac success (Gen 27:20), granted salvation to Israel (Judges 15:18), granted a child to Hannah (1 Sam 1:27), and so it goes. In the New Testament Pilate granted their demand to crucify Jesus (Luke 23:24), God granted the Son to have life in Himself (John 5:26), and granted the lives of all who sailed with Paul (Acts 27:24). So ... what is this thing called "granted"?
The word is fairly straightforward. It means "to give, to bestow". Not complicated. To grant means to give. In the examples above, God gave Isaac what he prayed for, gave him success, gave Israel salvation, gave Hannah her child. God gave Jesus life in Himself, gave the lives of those who sailed with Paul to live through the storm, and so on. Not complicated.
When we start to look at what God grants, it gets interesting.
Writing to Timothy about being a pastor, Paul tells him be careful to correct his opponents with gentleness. He gives the reason:
And, hold on a second. That previous one there, over in Philippians. We skipped right over part of it. Yes, clearly, suffering for Christ is granted, a gift from God. But Paul also says that believing in Him is granted. That is, we don't muster it up, drum it up, produce it on our own. It is a gift.
In light of all that, what do we make of Jesus's words when He says, "This is why I told you that no one can come to Me unless it is granted him by the Father" (John 6:56)? Do we assume that actually coming to Christ is something that is a gift rather than something we accomplish? Well, it would seem so unless we want, at this late date, to redefine "grant".
So, if the things granted to us include grace, salvation, a calling, suffering, repentance, faith, even being able to come to Christ in the first place, I suppose Peter wasn't kidding when he said, "His divine power has granted to us all things that pertain to life and godliness." We don't supply the faith, repentance, or even ability to come. Now that really is impressive gifting from God.
The word is fairly straightforward. It means "to give, to bestow". Not complicated. To grant means to give. In the examples above, God gave Isaac what he prayed for, gave him success, gave Israel salvation, gave Hannah her child. God gave Jesus life in Himself, gave the lives of those who sailed with Paul to live through the storm, and so on. Not complicated.
When we start to look at what God grants, it gets interesting.
His divine power has granted to us all things that pertain to life and godliness, through the knowledge of Him who called us to His own glory and excellence, by which He has granted to us His precious and very great promises, so that through them you may become partakers of the divine nature, having escaped from the corruption that is in the world because of sinful desire (2 Peter 1:3-4).Not hard to follow, but good stuff. God, by His power, has given us all things that pertain to life and godliness. That is, we didn't earn them, obtain them, merit them, accumulate them, seize them -- nothing of the sort. They were a gift. Past tense, by the way. He already gave all things that pertain to life and godliness. His power, indeed, gives us His precious and very great promises. That is, that which He promises He supplies, even so far as making us "partakers of the divine nature". Really good stuff. And none of us are likely to think, "I did that by my own effort and will." No, it was granted.
Therefore do not be ashamed of the testimony about our Lord, nor of me His prisoner, but share in suffering for the gospel by the power of God, who saved us and called us to a holy calling, not because of our works but because of His own purpose and grace, which He granted us in Christ Jesus before the ages began (2 Tim 1:8-9).Would anybody really doubt that God's grace is a gift, granted to us in Christ? We don't earn His favor. He gives it. And that gift of grace includes salvation and "a holy calling". Wonderful stuff.
For it has been granted to you that for the sake of Christ you should not only believe in Him but also suffer for His sake (Php 1:29).That one is a little touchier, I think. Paul says that God grants that we "suffer for His sake". It's a gift from God. We don't earn it. He gives it.
Writing to Timothy about being a pastor, Paul tells him be careful to correct his opponents with gentleness. He gives the reason:
God may perhaps grant them repentance leading to a knowledge of the truth, and they may come to their senses and escape from the snare of the devil, after being captured by him to do his will (2 Tim 2:25-26).Well, now, that's interesting, isn't it? Apparently Paul thought that repentance was something that was granted. Indeed, it was something that may or may not be granted. Now that one I'm pretty sure we typically think of as supplying on our own. Apparently Paul disagrees.
And, hold on a second. That previous one there, over in Philippians. We skipped right over part of it. Yes, clearly, suffering for Christ is granted, a gift from God. But Paul also says that believing in Him is granted. That is, we don't muster it up, drum it up, produce it on our own. It is a gift.
In light of all that, what do we make of Jesus's words when He says, "This is why I told you that no one can come to Me unless it is granted him by the Father" (John 6:56)? Do we assume that actually coming to Christ is something that is a gift rather than something we accomplish? Well, it would seem so unless we want, at this late date, to redefine "grant".
So, if the things granted to us include grace, salvation, a calling, suffering, repentance, faith, even being able to come to Christ in the first place, I suppose Peter wasn't kidding when he said, "His divine power has granted to us all things that pertain to life and godliness." We don't supply the faith, repentance, or even ability to come. Now that really is impressive gifting from God.
Thursday, November 01, 2012
Audacious Intent
Recently I asserted that God is Sovereign. By "Sovereign", I included the assertion that God "intended" sins to occur that He would use to accomplish His good purposes. Now, by no means was I suggesting that God causes sins to occur. By allowing a sin to occur which He could prevent (Gen 20:6), I would say that 1) God intends sin without causing it and 2) He intends it for good. Never suggesting that sin is good, it is still my contention that God uses the evil that men do for His good purposes.
Understandably, this wasn't well received. It was not acceptable. "These things cannot be!" I say "understandably". Every moral person will balk at the suggestion that God plans for sin to occur while still holding it as sinful and without causing it because, well, sin is sin. After all, "God is not the author of sin", is He? I understand that response. So, why in the world would I make such an outlandish assertion?
I will offer two reasons. First, and most importantly, I read that, as an overall statement, God "works all things after the counsel of His will" (Eph 1:11). Now, I understand "all things" to mean, well, all things. And "all" would include evil. Further, I read that, when faced with his brothers who sold him into slavery, Joseph said, "You intended it for evil, but God intended it for good" (Gen 50:20). In this statement there are two intents. One is evil, and those who intended evil are culpable for that evil. The other, however, is God's intent. That intent is for good. And that tells me that God intends evil for good. That does not tell me that God causes evil for good, but that He sees it, anticipates it, and when it fits with His purposes, allows it. Intent. I read that, speaking about Jesus's impending betrayal by Judas Iscariot, Jesus understood that it was 1) predetermined and 2) that Judas was culpable for His actions (Luke 22:22). God's intent without cause. I read that God actually "anointed both Herod and Pontius Pilate, along with the Gentiles and the peoples of Israel, to do whatever your hand and your plan had predestined to take place" (Acts 4:27-28). Did you get that? God put Herod, Pilate, the Gentiles, and the Jews in place to perpetrate the worst sin in all history. That sin was "predestined". They were culpable for their sin. But it was God's plan. His will. His intent. Why would I have the audacity to claim that God intends sin for His good purposes? Because that's what I read repeatedly in my Bible.
Look, you can start from what you think you know, what you think God is or should be like, what you think morality should be, or you can start from what God declares Himself to be and, following on that, what He says is good or bad. I guarantee you your selection of a starting point will lead you to a radically different conclusion than the other would have. So I choose to operate from the basis of "God said" (rather than "Did God say ...?") and run with those things He said about Himself and assume those to be true. With that basis, I can then filter other things in Scripture, in my thinking, in life that will certainly lead me to conclusions that do not conform to standard human thinking. And, in truth, that actually gives me some measure of comfort because if I ended up on the popular side, I'd do so against Scripture's repeated claim that the world hates God and His people. I, therefore, understand that my claim is not popular, but I am required to operate from the revealed nature of God before I operate from my own personal feelings about what should or shouldn't be. Indeed, to me it is pure audacity to claim that my feelings and perceptions trump God's clear Word.
There is a second reason, as I said. That one is a logical, practical one. Scripture says "God intended it for good", where "it" in that quote was the evil Joseph's brothers did to him. Paul says that God works all things together for good to those who love God. If God works all things after the counsel of His will and works them for good, what am I to conclude when bad things happen? Logic would dictate that I conclude that those things are "after the counsel of His will" and that, although they are indeed evil, God intended it for good. Practically speaking, then, the answer I need to hear when bad things happen to me is, "Yes, that was evil and it's painful and regrettable, but rest assured, in the final analysis, that God will work that for good according to His purposes."
Consider, then, the alternative. If God does not intend (will, plan, expect, allow) evil to occur, then it occurs outside of His will, intent, plan, expectations. He could prevent it but doesn't. That means that either God is not willing or able to act. Maybe He didn't see it coming in time. Maybe His hands are tied by His prior commitment to Human Free Will. Maybe He just doesn't care enough about the little things. Here, let me restate that. He is either unloving, not omnipotent, not omniscient, not good, or not sovereign. These are the alternatives. If evil happens outside of God's will and intent, then God's will and intents are being subverted by His creation. That's the only alternative. And I don't know about you, but for me, the alternative doesn't help.
That doesn't work for me. It doesn't align with Scripture. It isn't logical. It isn't practical. As many problems that the claim that God intends for evil to occur for His good purposes causes, the alternative causes far, far more problems. If God does not intend evil for good, then Joseph was wrong, Job suffered outside God's will, Jesus was mistaken about Judas Iscariot, the believers in Acts were wrong about God using those around them to carry out the Crucifixion, and God is not God. Now, maybe that works better for you, but it doesn't work at all for me. So, I'll stick with the "audacious" claim that I think is the only biblical, logical, reasonable, practical position to take. Feel free to take your own.
Understandably, this wasn't well received. It was not acceptable. "These things cannot be!" I say "understandably". Every moral person will balk at the suggestion that God plans for sin to occur while still holding it as sinful and without causing it because, well, sin is sin. After all, "God is not the author of sin", is He? I understand that response. So, why in the world would I make such an outlandish assertion?
I will offer two reasons. First, and most importantly, I read that, as an overall statement, God "works all things after the counsel of His will" (Eph 1:11). Now, I understand "all things" to mean, well, all things. And "all" would include evil. Further, I read that, when faced with his brothers who sold him into slavery, Joseph said, "You intended it for evil, but God intended it for good" (Gen 50:20). In this statement there are two intents. One is evil, and those who intended evil are culpable for that evil. The other, however, is God's intent. That intent is for good. And that tells me that God intends evil for good. That does not tell me that God causes evil for good, but that He sees it, anticipates it, and when it fits with His purposes, allows it. Intent. I read that, speaking about Jesus's impending betrayal by Judas Iscariot, Jesus understood that it was 1) predetermined and 2) that Judas was culpable for His actions (Luke 22:22). God's intent without cause. I read that God actually "anointed both Herod and Pontius Pilate, along with the Gentiles and the peoples of Israel, to do whatever your hand and your plan had predestined to take place" (Acts 4:27-28). Did you get that? God put Herod, Pilate, the Gentiles, and the Jews in place to perpetrate the worst sin in all history. That sin was "predestined". They were culpable for their sin. But it was God's plan. His will. His intent. Why would I have the audacity to claim that God intends sin for His good purposes? Because that's what I read repeatedly in my Bible.
Look, you can start from what you think you know, what you think God is or should be like, what you think morality should be, or you can start from what God declares Himself to be and, following on that, what He says is good or bad. I guarantee you your selection of a starting point will lead you to a radically different conclusion than the other would have. So I choose to operate from the basis of "God said" (rather than "Did God say ...?") and run with those things He said about Himself and assume those to be true. With that basis, I can then filter other things in Scripture, in my thinking, in life that will certainly lead me to conclusions that do not conform to standard human thinking. And, in truth, that actually gives me some measure of comfort because if I ended up on the popular side, I'd do so against Scripture's repeated claim that the world hates God and His people. I, therefore, understand that my claim is not popular, but I am required to operate from the revealed nature of God before I operate from my own personal feelings about what should or shouldn't be. Indeed, to me it is pure audacity to claim that my feelings and perceptions trump God's clear Word.
There is a second reason, as I said. That one is a logical, practical one. Scripture says "God intended it for good", where "it" in that quote was the evil Joseph's brothers did to him. Paul says that God works all things together for good to those who love God. If God works all things after the counsel of His will and works them for good, what am I to conclude when bad things happen? Logic would dictate that I conclude that those things are "after the counsel of His will" and that, although they are indeed evil, God intended it for good. Practically speaking, then, the answer I need to hear when bad things happen to me is, "Yes, that was evil and it's painful and regrettable, but rest assured, in the final analysis, that God will work that for good according to His purposes."
Consider, then, the alternative. If God does not intend (will, plan, expect, allow) evil to occur, then it occurs outside of His will, intent, plan, expectations. He could prevent it but doesn't. That means that either God is not willing or able to act. Maybe He didn't see it coming in time. Maybe His hands are tied by His prior commitment to Human Free Will. Maybe He just doesn't care enough about the little things. Here, let me restate that. He is either unloving, not omnipotent, not omniscient, not good, or not sovereign. These are the alternatives. If evil happens outside of God's will and intent, then God's will and intents are being subverted by His creation. That's the only alternative. And I don't know about you, but for me, the alternative doesn't help.
That doesn't work for me. It doesn't align with Scripture. It isn't logical. It isn't practical. As many problems that the claim that God intends for evil to occur for His good purposes causes, the alternative causes far, far more problems. If God does not intend evil for good, then Joseph was wrong, Job suffered outside God's will, Jesus was mistaken about Judas Iscariot, the believers in Acts were wrong about God using those around them to carry out the Crucifixion, and God is not God. Now, maybe that works better for you, but it doesn't work at all for me. So, I'll stick with the "audacious" claim that I think is the only biblical, logical, reasonable, practical position to take. Feel free to take your own.
Labels:
The Sovereignty of God
Wednesday, October 31, 2012
All Hallows Eve
What is this thing called "Halloween"? And why are Christians either deeply outraged or having anything at all to do with it?
Well, as it turns out, the early Christian church celebrated an "All Saints Day", a remembrance for martyred Christians. And, of course, since all church holidays have an "eve", the day before was "All Hallows Eve", a holy time set aside to prepare for All Saints Day. Well, as is our wont, "All Hallows Eve" shortened over time to "Hallow-e'en" to "Halloween", effectively removing all connection with anything hallowed ... or eve-ish. (Wait a minute! Does this sound like another complaint about words? Well, maybe, but you can fill that in yourself.)
Over time, the church took pains to "redeem" their world. So, for instance, they "redeemed" December 25th from its pagan origins to make it the day they celebrated Christ's birth. This same approach was taken with the All Saints Day celebration. Druids celebrated the Samhain festival from October 31 through November 2. The church decided to "redeem" that event by placing its All Saints Day in the middle of it, and, presto-chango, October 31st became "Halloween".
Here's the problem, of course. While perhaps the church was somewhat successful in redeeming December 25th from the pagan rituals of its day, they failed to do so in the case of Halloween. While the Celtic people celebrated darkness and death in their festival, the Christian version of Halloween didn't seem to change at all. While the pagans celebrated the occult, Halloween seems to have retained that celebration. So "bobbing for apples", a call for a blessing on a couple's romance, was retained. Jack o'lanterns originally placed outside to scare off wandering spirits are still placed outside to beckon wandering children. The practice of offering gifts to haunting spirits in order to send them on their way is retained in the "trick-or-treat" practices today. In fact, nearly all Halloween practices today are derived from pagan rituals. Rather than redeeming the day, they succumbed to it.
Today, Halloween serves as a unique "holiday". It is the opportunity to celebrate everything evil. Even the liberal Huffington Post includes stories about the sexualization of little girls in Halloween costumes. Death, gore, zombies, vampires (Did you know that a "vamp" is defined as "a woman who uses her sexuality to entrap and exploit men" and comes from "vampire"?), skeletons, even evil clowns -- all of this is fair game and normal stuff on Halloween. Adults find the celebration a unique opportunity for revelry. There is typically no "family" involved on this holiday; it's a "friends" thing. You're not buying gifts for people, so its just the opportunity to be outlandish and self-centered. While most won't actually think in terms of real demons, they will certainly celebrate the concept. Indeed, since the concept of "real demons" means nearly nothing to most people, it simply serves to 1) tie them to the concept while 2) immunizing them against it.
So, what's a thinking Christian to do? Lots of churches today offer a counterpoint. They might plan a "Harvest Festival" so your kids can dress up without dressing up as demons and witches and still get their jack o'lantern-and-trick-or-treat fixes. It's a good night to invite non-Christian friends and sneak in a tract or a Gospel message. Other churches engage in "Hell House" evangelism. They'll make an alternative "haunted house", replacing demons and witches with abortions and the consequences of sin.
Others respond almost militaristically. "No! We will not take part in any way on this demonic night of revelry!" I've had some tell me that this particular night belongs to Satan. The fact that actual Satan-worship-related crime is no greater on Halloween than any other time is irrelevant. The fact that God remains just as Sovereign on October 31st as He was on October 30th is beside the point. Some just don't participate at all with the idea that we are to "come out from among them and be separate". Still others participate with the Gospel, handing out tracts to kids rather than (or, perhaps, in addition to) candy.
Others just go along. They reason "greater is He who is in you than he who is in the world" (1 John 4:4). They figure there is nothing intrinsically sinful about dressing up your daughter as a princess or your son as Spiderman and visiting neighbors and getting some candy. Sure, pagans used to carve pumpkins to ward off evil spirits, but not all carved pumpkins are for that purpose. What's the big deal? All in good fun.
I've read my Bible cover to cover. For some reason I can't find a single command, "Thou shalt not participate in anything related to Halloween." Odd, isn't it? So what do I conclude? Well, there are things we are to avoid. Involving ourselves in the occult -- witchcraft, divination, necromancy, etc. -- is specifically mentioned. Don't do it. We are expected to be distinct, separate, apart from the sins of the world, and revelry and celebration of evil is clearly not part of that. Don't do it. And we are commanded to be lights in a dark world, to share the Gospel in word and deed. Do that! How you apply all that is up to you. Whatever is not of faith is sin (Rom 14:23). Don't violate your conscience for this. Conversely, Martin Luther, the great Reformer, said "The best way to drive out the devil, if he will not yield to texts of Scripture, is to jeer and flout him for he cannot bear scorn." Running from Satan on a night that does not belong to him is not a good idea either. You decide what a good idea is within the bounds of biblical command, keeping in mind that we belong to God and are His representatives in this world. Let that be your guide.
Well, as it turns out, the early Christian church celebrated an "All Saints Day", a remembrance for martyred Christians. And, of course, since all church holidays have an "eve", the day before was "All Hallows Eve", a holy time set aside to prepare for All Saints Day. Well, as is our wont, "All Hallows Eve" shortened over time to "Hallow-e'en" to "Halloween", effectively removing all connection with anything hallowed ... or eve-ish. (Wait a minute! Does this sound like another complaint about words? Well, maybe, but you can fill that in yourself.)
Over time, the church took pains to "redeem" their world. So, for instance, they "redeemed" December 25th from its pagan origins to make it the day they celebrated Christ's birth. This same approach was taken with the All Saints Day celebration. Druids celebrated the Samhain festival from October 31 through November 2. The church decided to "redeem" that event by placing its All Saints Day in the middle of it, and, presto-chango, October 31st became "Halloween".
Here's the problem, of course. While perhaps the church was somewhat successful in redeeming December 25th from the pagan rituals of its day, they failed to do so in the case of Halloween. While the Celtic people celebrated darkness and death in their festival, the Christian version of Halloween didn't seem to change at all. While the pagans celebrated the occult, Halloween seems to have retained that celebration. So "bobbing for apples", a call for a blessing on a couple's romance, was retained. Jack o'lanterns originally placed outside to scare off wandering spirits are still placed outside to beckon wandering children. The practice of offering gifts to haunting spirits in order to send them on their way is retained in the "trick-or-treat" practices today. In fact, nearly all Halloween practices today are derived from pagan rituals. Rather than redeeming the day, they succumbed to it.
Today, Halloween serves as a unique "holiday". It is the opportunity to celebrate everything evil. Even the liberal Huffington Post includes stories about the sexualization of little girls in Halloween costumes. Death, gore, zombies, vampires (Did you know that a "vamp" is defined as "a woman who uses her sexuality to entrap and exploit men" and comes from "vampire"?), skeletons, even evil clowns -- all of this is fair game and normal stuff on Halloween. Adults find the celebration a unique opportunity for revelry. There is typically no "family" involved on this holiday; it's a "friends" thing. You're not buying gifts for people, so its just the opportunity to be outlandish and self-centered. While most won't actually think in terms of real demons, they will certainly celebrate the concept. Indeed, since the concept of "real demons" means nearly nothing to most people, it simply serves to 1) tie them to the concept while 2) immunizing them against it.
So, what's a thinking Christian to do? Lots of churches today offer a counterpoint. They might plan a "Harvest Festival" so your kids can dress up without dressing up as demons and witches and still get their jack o'lantern-and-trick-or-treat fixes. It's a good night to invite non-Christian friends and sneak in a tract or a Gospel message. Other churches engage in "Hell House" evangelism. They'll make an alternative "haunted house", replacing demons and witches with abortions and the consequences of sin.
Others respond almost militaristically. "No! We will not take part in any way on this demonic night of revelry!" I've had some tell me that this particular night belongs to Satan. The fact that actual Satan-worship-related crime is no greater on Halloween than any other time is irrelevant. The fact that God remains just as Sovereign on October 31st as He was on October 30th is beside the point. Some just don't participate at all with the idea that we are to "come out from among them and be separate". Still others participate with the Gospel, handing out tracts to kids rather than (or, perhaps, in addition to) candy.
Others just go along. They reason "greater is He who is in you than he who is in the world" (1 John 4:4). They figure there is nothing intrinsically sinful about dressing up your daughter as a princess or your son as Spiderman and visiting neighbors and getting some candy. Sure, pagans used to carve pumpkins to ward off evil spirits, but not all carved pumpkins are for that purpose. What's the big deal? All in good fun.
I've read my Bible cover to cover. For some reason I can't find a single command, "Thou shalt not participate in anything related to Halloween." Odd, isn't it? So what do I conclude? Well, there are things we are to avoid. Involving ourselves in the occult -- witchcraft, divination, necromancy, etc. -- is specifically mentioned. Don't do it. We are expected to be distinct, separate, apart from the sins of the world, and revelry and celebration of evil is clearly not part of that. Don't do it. And we are commanded to be lights in a dark world, to share the Gospel in word and deed. Do that! How you apply all that is up to you. Whatever is not of faith is sin (Rom 14:23). Don't violate your conscience for this. Conversely, Martin Luther, the great Reformer, said "The best way to drive out the devil, if he will not yield to texts of Scripture, is to jeer and flout him for he cannot bear scorn." Running from Satan on a night that does not belong to him is not a good idea either. You decide what a good idea is within the bounds of biblical command, keeping in mind that we belong to God and are His representatives in this world. Let that be your guide.
Tuesday, October 30, 2012
The Perfect Storm
On September 11, 2012, a group of armed assailants attacked and overran the American embassy in Benghazi, Libya. Four Americans, including the ambassador, died in that attack. As the smoke from the attack drifted off, Hillary Clinton and then the president informed America of the assault and the deaths. It was, we were assured, the result of protestors-gone-bad over an anti-Muslim Internet video. A small group of bad people. Others tried to help, even carting the dying ambassador off to the hospital. "We’re going to have that person arrested and prosecuted that did the video," Hillary assured us.
Of course, it didn't take long for that story to collapse under the weight of the lies. It turns out that the embassy was warned in advance by the Libyans that the attack was coming, that requests for more security before the event were denied, that the attack was not due to the video (although the president via the American media did an effective job of notifying the rest of the Muslim world that such an offense existed about which they could riot), that the government knew all this, and that there was even military force available that was denied during the attack.
Let's see if we have all this, then. 1) The White House lied ... and then ran off to Vegas to campaign. 2) An American has been arrested (and, oddly enough, his bail hearing is set for 3 days after the election) for a video that did not cause the events. 3) The State Department knew about the event in advance and didn't act. 4) Military relief during the attack was denied by some authority higher than the CIA. (Hmmm ... who is higher than the CIA?) Still, the Obama campaign has fallen back to bayonets, binders, and Big Bird as its primary offensive without responding to all this.
Hurricane Sandy has been dubbed "Frankenstorm", another "perfect storm". Lots of rain and damage and such. How is this stuff from Benghazi not the "perfect storm" here at the edge of electing a president? (And, remember, "Pay no attention to that looming $16 trillion debt behind the curtain!")
Of course, it didn't take long for that story to collapse under the weight of the lies. It turns out that the embassy was warned in advance by the Libyans that the attack was coming, that requests for more security before the event were denied, that the attack was not due to the video (although the president via the American media did an effective job of notifying the rest of the Muslim world that such an offense existed about which they could riot), that the government knew all this, and that there was even military force available that was denied during the attack.
Let's see if we have all this, then. 1) The White House lied ... and then ran off to Vegas to campaign. 2) An American has been arrested (and, oddly enough, his bail hearing is set for 3 days after the election) for a video that did not cause the events. 3) The State Department knew about the event in advance and didn't act. 4) Military relief during the attack was denied by some authority higher than the CIA. (Hmmm ... who is higher than the CIA?) Still, the Obama campaign has fallen back to bayonets, binders, and Big Bird as its primary offensive without responding to all this.
Hurricane Sandy has been dubbed "Frankenstorm", another "perfect storm". Lots of rain and damage and such. How is this stuff from Benghazi not the "perfect storm" here at the edge of electing a president? (And, remember, "Pay no attention to that looming $16 trillion debt behind the curtain!")
Monday, October 29, 2012
Confident and Judgmental
Recently Denny Burk, an Associate Professor of Biblical Studies at Boyce College, wrote a response to Rachel Held Evans on the Today Show. Good response. All well and good. What was interesting was the comments. One commenter said, "I’m reminded of Paul saying in Acts 20:30 that 'from among your own selves will arise men speaking twisted things, to draw away the disciples after them.'" Another commenter responded to that comment with "That’s an intense verse to hurl at your sister in Christ. ... Please search for grace in the Bible you love before condemning your sister in the faith." To which another commenter commented, "'Sister in the faith?' What makes you think this woman is saved? ... She needs to repent of her blasphemy against our Lord and ask forgiveness from the Christian church and recant from the lies and slander she has spread across the internet." From there it devolved into a fight rather than a discussion of the post or its merits.
I don't offer Burk's post as a standalone argument. I offer it as an example. I've heard it a lot myself before. Too judgmental. Too arrogant. "We don’t get to judge others and decide when they need to repent." One thing that is universal, it seems, is that it is wrong to be sure.
And then I read this:
Christians, like all humans, can tend to be abrasive when they're sure. (Don't be deceived into thinking it's a "Christian" or even a "religious right" thing. Atheists and liberals are just as confident about their views and just as judgmental of those who disagree.) However, based on Scripture (and reason), it seems as if there certainly is a time for us to be sure, to be confident, and even to be condemning of false teaching and false teachers. Anything else would not be biblical ... or loving.
I don't offer Burk's post as a standalone argument. I offer it as an example. I've heard it a lot myself before. Too judgmental. Too arrogant. "We don’t get to judge others and decide when they need to repent." One thing that is universal, it seems, is that it is wrong to be sure.
And then I read this:
If anyone teaches a different doctrine and does not agree with the sound words of our Lord Jesus Christ and the teaching that accords with godliness, he is puffed up with conceit and understands nothing. He has an unhealthy craving for controversy and for quarrels about words, which produce envy, dissension, slander, evil suspicions, and constant friction among people who are depraved in mind and deprived of the truth (1 Tim 6:3-5).Wow, Paul, I mean, wow! Apparently you didn't get the memo. We don't get to judge others. It is wrong to be that judgmental. Your confidence is commendable, I'm sure, but, look, you're only human, right? What makes you so sure you're right and they're wrong?
Christians, like all humans, can tend to be abrasive when they're sure. (Don't be deceived into thinking it's a "Christian" or even a "religious right" thing. Atheists and liberals are just as confident about their views and just as judgmental of those who disagree.) However, based on Scripture (and reason), it seems as if there certainly is a time for us to be sure, to be confident, and even to be condemning of false teaching and false teachers. Anything else would not be biblical ... or loving.
Sunday, October 28, 2012
Unique Sovereignty
Anyone who has, for much time, read what I write knows where I stand on the Sovereignty of God. I capitalize the term "Sovereignty" because this sovereignty is in a category all its own. I use the word in a sense that exceeds our standard usage. We have "sovereigns". We understand "sovereign powers". In human existence, there are people who are "in charge" -- "sovereign". Their charge is limited, of course. Their powers are limited. Their domain is contained. And, let's face it, even within these limitations they are only just "sovereign". An absolute monarch of the realm, for instance, couldn't actually dictate all the actions of his subjects. He could try, but they would always be free to violate his commands. At best, they may disobey simply out of ignorance. Nor are we ourselves ultimately sovereign over ourselves. We do things that violate what we want. Maybe it's physical. I mean, when I suffer from heartburn, it's not because I choose to. Maybe it's feelings. I know each of us has feelings we don't want. And I've never met a Christian who is satisfied with his or her own Christianity. We want to be much more, but we are not absolutely sovereign even over ourselves, so we fall short.
God's Sovereignty, then, falls in a different category. It is His Sovereignty in which I rest, His genuine Sovereignty that gives me hope. In a world where our political choices are "bad" and "worse" (and don't kid yourself; they've always been thus), the comfort that God is, in all cases, ultimately Sovereign is comfort indeed. When terrorists strike or criminals accost or disease causes dis-ease, knowing that a good and powerful Sovereign is in charge is the only place to go for any real peace. Many try to strip off God's absolute Sovereignty. I won't go there myself.
The problem, of course, is that this kind of Sovereignty -- the one with the capital "S" -- doesn't exist elsewhere. What makes me think it exists in God? Here's what Paul said to Timothy. He told him
To Him, then, be honor and eternal dominion! Amen!
God's Sovereignty, then, falls in a different category. It is His Sovereignty in which I rest, His genuine Sovereignty that gives me hope. In a world where our political choices are "bad" and "worse" (and don't kid yourself; they've always been thus), the comfort that God is, in all cases, ultimately Sovereign is comfort indeed. When terrorists strike or criminals accost or disease causes dis-ease, knowing that a good and powerful Sovereign is in charge is the only place to go for any real peace. Many try to strip off God's absolute Sovereignty. I won't go there myself.
The problem, of course, is that this kind of Sovereignty -- the one with the capital "S" -- doesn't exist elsewhere. What makes me think it exists in God? Here's what Paul said to Timothy. He told him
to keep the commandment unstained and free from reproach until the appearing of our Lord Jesus Christ, which He will display at the proper time -- He who is the blessed and only Sovereign, the King of kings and Lord of lords, who alone has immortality, who dwells in unapproachable light, Whom no one has ever seen or can see. To Him be honor and eternal dominion. Amen (1 Tim 6:14-16).Do you see that? When it comes to Sovereignty, Paul says that there is only one. He is the "only Sovereign." We have heard of "the King of kings and Lord of lords", but often miss the impact. There is none higher. There is none other that is absolute. There is only one.
To Him, then, be honor and eternal dominion! Amen!
Labels:
The Sovereignty of God
Saturday, October 27, 2012
This Just In ...
According to Campus Reform.org, "The University of North Carolina - Chapel Hill has removed the word 'freshman' from official university documents, citing as their reason an attempt to adopt more 'gender inclusive language.'"
Fascinating. Once again the necessity to not hurt anyone's feelings instead of using language and concepts as intended has resulted in further foolishness. Now, to be fair, it's not some deep devotion to the term "freshman" that has me commenting on this. It's just an illustration of uninformed stupidity.
You know, if I were going to eliminate a term from "official university documents", it wouldn't be "freshman". I mean, really ... who cares? No, for me it would be "sophomore". Apparently no one knows what that one means. Rooted in Greek, it comes from sophos, "wise", and moros, "foolish, dull." (Hint: moros is the root for our word, "moron".) That's right. A "sophomore" is most literally someone who thinks themselves wise but is actually foolish. Nor am I being outlandish. What does "sophomoric" mean? What do we mean when we describe something as acting like a sophomore? It means "conceited and overconfident of knowledge but poorly informed and immature." That is what it means to be a sophomore. But that isn't offensive. "Freshman" is.
Sigh.
________
In other news, who does the world want to win our election? According to the BBC, the world favors Obama over Romney by an unbelievable margin. Interestingly, the biggest support from Obama comes from the socialist nation of France. Huh. Now, when I consider that most of the world hates the U.S., that gives me pause. Would we be wise to elect the guy that those who would like to see us fail prefer? I'm just sayin'.
________
I love this ad from a local candidate. (And what a candidate! She is on public record as declaring that stay-at-home moms are leeching off their husbands or boyfriends. She favors every possible tax increase and new spending. Okay, not every possible increase; only for those who make $75,000 or more. The New York Times lauded her as a leftist extremist. Beyond this, two special groups are hoping she wins. She would be the first Congresswoman in office as a openly-avowed bisexual and an openly-avowed atheist.) So what is it that is so interesting in this ad? Here's what she says: "I sponsored this ad so I can change Washington and get things done." That's it. There you go. Those are her goals. What change? Oh, she's not saying. Get what done? Nope ... nothing. Indeed, I have to admit it's the first time I actually believe a campaign promise. If she does get elected, her presence will be a change in Washington (because she hasn't been in Congress before) and she will have gotten that done. Whoopee! A success! No ... really ... what?
________
I do have to wonder sometimes when ads cross the line from "attack" to slander. One local ad against a Republican congressional candidate is a classic example. "He's fighting for his principles," it begins. "He is trying to eliminate what is bad." So, what is bad? They show you a picture of a little school girl. Yeah, that's what he's up for. They move from "He wants to eliminate the Department of Education" to "He wants to destroy your children's education." Now, wait! I'm not really following that particular race and I'm not really up on that particular candidate, but I'm pretty sure it is not his goal to destroy education. Pretty sure. But, then, "truth in advertising" laws, sadly, don't apply to political ads. So, don't slander laws?
________
You know, if I were to judge by the news, I'd have to conclude that "who gets elected president" is moot. Fortunately, my world is not defined by the news media.
Fascinating. Once again the necessity to not hurt anyone's feelings instead of using language and concepts as intended has resulted in further foolishness. Now, to be fair, it's not some deep devotion to the term "freshman" that has me commenting on this. It's just an illustration of uninformed stupidity.
You know, if I were going to eliminate a term from "official university documents", it wouldn't be "freshman". I mean, really ... who cares? No, for me it would be "sophomore". Apparently no one knows what that one means. Rooted in Greek, it comes from sophos, "wise", and moros, "foolish, dull." (Hint: moros is the root for our word, "moron".) That's right. A "sophomore" is most literally someone who thinks themselves wise but is actually foolish. Nor am I being outlandish. What does "sophomoric" mean? What do we mean when we describe something as acting like a sophomore? It means "conceited and overconfident of knowledge but poorly informed and immature." That is what it means to be a sophomore. But that isn't offensive. "Freshman" is.
Sigh.
________
In other news, who does the world want to win our election? According to the BBC, the world favors Obama over Romney by an unbelievable margin. Interestingly, the biggest support from Obama comes from the socialist nation of France. Huh. Now, when I consider that most of the world hates the U.S., that gives me pause. Would we be wise to elect the guy that those who would like to see us fail prefer? I'm just sayin'.
________
I love this ad from a local candidate. (And what a candidate! She is on public record as declaring that stay-at-home moms are leeching off their husbands or boyfriends. She favors every possible tax increase and new spending. Okay, not every possible increase; only for those who make $75,000 or more. The New York Times lauded her as a leftist extremist. Beyond this, two special groups are hoping she wins. She would be the first Congresswoman in office as a openly-avowed bisexual and an openly-avowed atheist.) So what is it that is so interesting in this ad? Here's what she says: "I sponsored this ad so I can change Washington and get things done." That's it. There you go. Those are her goals. What change? Oh, she's not saying. Get what done? Nope ... nothing. Indeed, I have to admit it's the first time I actually believe a campaign promise. If she does get elected, her presence will be a change in Washington (because she hasn't been in Congress before) and she will have gotten that done. Whoopee! A success! No ... really ... what?
________
I do have to wonder sometimes when ads cross the line from "attack" to slander. One local ad against a Republican congressional candidate is a classic example. "He's fighting for his principles," it begins. "He is trying to eliminate what is bad." So, what is bad? They show you a picture of a little school girl. Yeah, that's what he's up for. They move from "He wants to eliminate the Department of Education" to "He wants to destroy your children's education." Now, wait! I'm not really following that particular race and I'm not really up on that particular candidate, but I'm pretty sure it is not his goal to destroy education. Pretty sure. But, then, "truth in advertising" laws, sadly, don't apply to political ads. So, don't slander laws?
________
You know, if I were to judge by the news, I'd have to conclude that "who gets elected president" is moot. Fortunately, my world is not defined by the news media.
Friday, October 26, 2012
Is God Sovereign?
I have long asserted that God is Sovereign. Not merely sovereign (lowercase "s"), but Sovereign. I believe that the Bible teaches that nothing happens by chance or accident, but that God works all things after the counsel of His will (Eph 1:11). Oddly, I believe that because, well, the Bible says it. As a huge example, the indisputably worst sin of all time -- the false arrest and subsequent cruel and wanton murder of the Son of God -- was ordained by God. It was His plan before Jesus was ever born and was carried out be evil men who were anointed by God "to do whatever Your hand and Your plan had predestined to take place" (Acts 4:28). It's a fine line. The claim is not that God causes sin, but that God intends sin to achieve His good purposes (Gen 50:20; Rom 8:28). Thus, sin is still evil and sinners are culpable for their sin, but God remains Sovereign and works all things after the counsel of His will.
I'd have to guess, however, that the entire unbelieving world and, likely, the vast majority of the believers in this world disagree with that assessment. Here, test yourself and see. In a debate this last Tuesday night Indiana GOP U.S. Senate candidate Richard Mourdock made this statement on the question of abortion:
I was interested at the delivery, myself. Mourdock was clearly disturbed by his own statement. That is, he knew when he was about to make it that it was hard to swallow and wouldn't go over well. And I looked carefully to see what he claimed. The statement was about life, not rape. Using standard English, the subject of his statement "it is something that God intended to happen" is not rape, but life. Still, it's not clear if anyone actually heard that.
So we're left with a dilemma. Apparently it is not the position of Mitt Romney that life occurs by God's intent. Nor is it the position of Obama (quite clearly since he is by far the most pro-abortion president we've ever put in office). Nor is it the position of the unbelieving world or, apparently, most of the believing world. Therefore, it can only be concluded that life occurs by accident. "No, that's a leap." No, that's the only possibility. Surely you can't argue that life occurs by God's intent when it's not rape, but by accident when it is. That's as crazy as Rep. Todd Akin's stupid comments that women's bodies prevent pregnancy in cases of rape!
What is your response? Is life an accident or is it God's intent? Does life that occurs in a rape occur by God's intent or is it an accident? Does justice demand that we imprison the rapist and murder the victim of that rape, the unborn child? But the broader question is the one I started with. Is God Sovereign? Or is He only mostly sovereign, kind of handcuffed, tied down to His creation and sometimes overwhelmed by sinners? Mourdock's statement is that God is Sovereign and life occurs by His design. Is that false, or do you stand with the "extremist"? More to the point, is it more extreme to say that God is Sovereign even in matters of sin or that He is not sovereign?
________
As a postscript, I need to address the question I did not address in the post. By his words and by his subsequent clarifying remarks since, Mourdock did not intend to say that rape was God's will. I've been asked, however, "Do you see how that is offensive to rape victims and their loved ones, to hear someone saying, 'You know, don't you, that your rape is part of God's will ... that God's desire was for you to be raped, so that even that wrong could be used for God's glory?'"
First, this tells me that people (not just the questioner, but apparently a lot of them) were not listening. Mourdock argued that life is God's will, even if it occurs by means of rape. I don't actually believe that Mourdock believes in the Sovereignty of God. He just believes in a bigger view of God's sovereignty than most. Most would argue that pregnancy by rape cannot be God's will, so murdering a baby who is a product of rape is not wrong. So be it. If your view of justice allows for the imprisonment of a rapist and the murder of one of his victims, then you have, from my perspective, an odd view of justice.
But in response to the question, I would first point out that I stated at the beginning that Scripture quite clearly states that God intends to use the evil that men intend for His good purposes. It was undeniable in the case of Joseph. It was undeniable in the case of Christ. Should I then conclude that these are the exceptions, and that all other cases occur outside of God's control? Do I conclude that God "works all things after the counsel of His will" ... except when bad things happen?
The second question I would ask appears to have no answer. If we assume that God has no intent when evil occurs -- that evil occurs completely outside of God's will (with all the attending troubles with Scripture that such a position would include) -- then what are we to tell the rape victim? "Yes, very sad. No, no, God didn't intend it. It wasn't His will. Oh, sure, He could have intervened and stopped it, but He didn't. Sorry. Bad things happen. God was either unwilling or unable to prevent it in your case. Take comfort in that." Is that really the best we can offer? Is that really a superior position?
I'd have to guess, however, that the entire unbelieving world and, likely, the vast majority of the believers in this world disagree with that assessment. Here, test yourself and see. In a debate this last Tuesday night Indiana GOP U.S. Senate candidate Richard Mourdock made this statement on the question of abortion:
You know, this is that issue that every candidate for federal or even state office faces.Romney's camp, who has endorsed Mourdock, offered this statement: "Mr.Mourdock's comments do not reflect Gov. Romney's views." The press has practically taken up arms at this "extremist" remark and seem ready to hang the entire GOP for it. The president has called on Romney to fully disown Mourdock for his "rape comments".
And I, too, certainly stand for life.
I know there are some who disagree and I respect their point of view but I believe that life believes at conception.
The only exception I have for – to have an abortion is in that case for the life of the mother.
I just – I struggled with it myself for a long time but I came to realize that life is that gift from God, and I think even when life begins in that horrible situation of rape that it is something that God intended to happen.
I was interested at the delivery, myself. Mourdock was clearly disturbed by his own statement. That is, he knew when he was about to make it that it was hard to swallow and wouldn't go over well. And I looked carefully to see what he claimed. The statement was about life, not rape. Using standard English, the subject of his statement "it is something that God intended to happen" is not rape, but life. Still, it's not clear if anyone actually heard that.
So we're left with a dilemma. Apparently it is not the position of Mitt Romney that life occurs by God's intent. Nor is it the position of Obama (quite clearly since he is by far the most pro-abortion president we've ever put in office). Nor is it the position of the unbelieving world or, apparently, most of the believing world. Therefore, it can only be concluded that life occurs by accident. "No, that's a leap." No, that's the only possibility. Surely you can't argue that life occurs by God's intent when it's not rape, but by accident when it is. That's as crazy as Rep. Todd Akin's stupid comments that women's bodies prevent pregnancy in cases of rape!
What is your response? Is life an accident or is it God's intent? Does life that occurs in a rape occur by God's intent or is it an accident? Does justice demand that we imprison the rapist and murder the victim of that rape, the unborn child? But the broader question is the one I started with. Is God Sovereign? Or is He only mostly sovereign, kind of handcuffed, tied down to His creation and sometimes overwhelmed by sinners? Mourdock's statement is that God is Sovereign and life occurs by His design. Is that false, or do you stand with the "extremist"? More to the point, is it more extreme to say that God is Sovereign even in matters of sin or that He is not sovereign?
________
As a postscript, I need to address the question I did not address in the post. By his words and by his subsequent clarifying remarks since, Mourdock did not intend to say that rape was God's will. I've been asked, however, "Do you see how that is offensive to rape victims and their loved ones, to hear someone saying, 'You know, don't you, that your rape is part of God's will ... that God's desire was for you to be raped, so that even that wrong could be used for God's glory?'"
First, this tells me that people (not just the questioner, but apparently a lot of them) were not listening. Mourdock argued that life is God's will, even if it occurs by means of rape. I don't actually believe that Mourdock believes in the Sovereignty of God. He just believes in a bigger view of God's sovereignty than most. Most would argue that pregnancy by rape cannot be God's will, so murdering a baby who is a product of rape is not wrong. So be it. If your view of justice allows for the imprisonment of a rapist and the murder of one of his victims, then you have, from my perspective, an odd view of justice.
But in response to the question, I would first point out that I stated at the beginning that Scripture quite clearly states that God intends to use the evil that men intend for His good purposes. It was undeniable in the case of Joseph. It was undeniable in the case of Christ. Should I then conclude that these are the exceptions, and that all other cases occur outside of God's control? Do I conclude that God "works all things after the counsel of His will" ... except when bad things happen?
The second question I would ask appears to have no answer. If we assume that God has no intent when evil occurs -- that evil occurs completely outside of God's will (with all the attending troubles with Scripture that such a position would include) -- then what are we to tell the rape victim? "Yes, very sad. No, no, God didn't intend it. It wasn't His will. Oh, sure, He could have intervened and stopped it, but He didn't. Sorry. Bad things happen. God was either unwilling or unable to prevent it in your case. Take comfort in that." Is that really the best we can offer? Is that really a superior position?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



