Like Button

Friday, May 08, 2009

Culture Wars

Culture is defined (in one sense) as the set of values held by a group of people that determines what is considered normal. Cultures are derived from the people that hold the shared values ... from people. And cultures will obviously change with time. Consider, for instance, the family from Leave It To Beaver. June wasn't an unusual wife when they shot the series. Theirs was a normal family life. Today, of course, June is considered an oddity, quite bizarre. And Beaver's hi-jinks would be considered bland compared to today's youth. "Who lives like that?" we ask. Well, in the '50's, most of America did. Today? Hardly anyone. You see, the values that are held in common have changed and that which is considered normal with them.

American Christians tend to be somewhat unclear on culture. We know (mostly) that Man is sinful. Human beings are sinners -- yeah, we get that. But culture, from our perspective, is good ... neutral at worst. And it stands to reason. Since culture defines what is considered normal, we think that it's, well, normal. We incorporate culture into our worship, into our preaching, into our lives. We willingly separate "public life" from "private life", the sacred from the secular. We've gotten used to high divorce rates, sexual sin of all types, the music and entertainment of our time, and so on. We like to think we're a little above it (morally), but it's not wrong; it's normal. So we hear phrases like "redeeming the culture" because, well, culture is essentially neutral.

The problem, of course, is that it's not true that culture is good or even neutral. Devised by sinful humans and informed by sinful values, today's culture is defining sinful as normal. You know, just like Paul says: "Though they know God's decree that those who practice such things deserve to die, they not only do them but give approval to those who practice them" (Rom 1:32).

What we are mostly oblivious to is how culture has invaded our own thinking. That's because it's ... normal. We've mixed Christian values with cultural values and come up with a hybrid that is, in fact, a contradiction. You're pretty sure it hasn't affected you? Let's see if I can suggest some views you might hold without thinking that come not from Scripture, but from today's culture. "Personal fulfillment is an important thing." "Theology is important, but what is much more important is my personal relationship with Christ." "It is important to first love yourself, then others." "It's important to do what makes me feel satisfied." "We shouldn't let things get in the way of achieving our dreams." I have even heard Christians defend pornography at home. "It's in the privacy of our bedroom for our own use. We're not lusting after them, so what's the problem?" We've bought the lies. Well, it's the central lie. Without even being aware of it, we've "exchanged the truth about God for the lie and worshiped and served the creature rather than the Creator" (Rom 1:25). To a large extent, we are the important ones. God expends His efforts on us because we are the point. Self-healing, self-fulfillment, self-satisfaction, self-realization, self-esteem, self-help ... we're steeped in self and self first. Our culture says it's normal. We buy it. We decide what church to go to by how it makes us feel. We decide whether to stay married by how our spouse makes us feel. We decide our career by how it makes us feel. We decide our view of God by how it makes us feel. We've bought the lie.

Some of you may wonder who I have in mind. "Is it generic, or is he thinking about specific people?" Some of you who know me may be thinking, "I wonder if I know who he's thinking about?" Yes, when I write this, specific people come to mind. The problem for me is that all of my readers know the first person who comes to my mind because it's me. I'm not ranting here because you are all so bad. I'm on a rant because I see such nonsense in my own thinking. Sadly, it's not just me. Do you find that you're in there, too? Do you see some room for you, too, to adjust your thinking ... like I do? Do you suspect that you, too, have bought the lie?

7 comments:

Dan Trabue said...

I agree that it is very easy to let negative, unhealthy trends from a popular culture become part of our thinking, even in church.

I saw with some dismay (but no surprise) the other day, a survey that suggested that the more you go to church, the more likely you are to support torture! Egad!

It's as if they get their theology of treatment of enemies from the TV show, "24" than from the Bible.

And perhaps we all can agree that materialism is a rampant negative influence in our culture that effects we in the church too much.

Humility in our thinking and living is always a good thing and a trait that I too often come up short in within my life.

Stan said...

I find it easy to point fingers when I see things I think are wrong. I also find that I come up short myself. I guess I need to keep both in mind -- things are wrong, and I need to keep an eye on those things in my life, too.

Dan Trabue said...

Amen.

Nick said...

Dan

Here's a question you can't answer: If water boarding was a means of saving the life of someone you love, would you be willing to use it? If you say yes, you vendicate those whom you hate, if you say no you are saying that saving a person from the discomfort of this so called torture is more important than the very life of your loved one. So you'll have to dance the political dance and say things that there is no way you can know for sure, like there's no way that anyone can know if the "tortured" actually have information that can help, or some other equivocation you dredge up from the ocean of hatred that resides in your heart. I was once like you, filled and motivated from morn to dusk with hatred, and I had the single tracked politcial mind that you do, and even hated some of the very people that you hate. Then I was washed clean of such hatred, and you can be too. You only need acknowledge it and ask for forgiveness. Then you may one day wake up, and to your own surprise discover that you are against real torture, like the torture that occurs during late term abortions.

I go to church, and I am for what you now qualify as torture, and dispise what you will not admit is torture, because to me those lives saved are not numbers on a tally sheet, they are moms, dads, sons and daughters, perhaps even my own, perhaps even yours.

Danny Wright said...

I heard R.C Sproul Jr. say once that "we confuse what we experience with what is normal, and we confuse what is normal with what is right".

I agree with you on this. There's always a battle being waged between my flesh and my spirit. It is a daily challenge to fix my mind on the spirit where there is life and peace.

Stan said...

It's amazing to me how this stuff sneaks into my thinking. It's disappointing when someone points out, "This is the wrong way the world thinks" and I realize, "Wait a minute! That's how I was thinking!"

Dan Trabue said...

Nick said:

Here's a question you can't answer: If water boarding was a means of saving the life of someone you love, would you be willing to use it? If you say yes, you vendicate those whom you hate, ... So you'll have to dance the political dance... like there's no way that anyone can know if the "tortured" actually have information that can help

And all manner of similar comments. A few thoughts...

1. I was merely agreeing with Stan that more worldly thinking sneaks into our churches pretty easily, as you demonstrate here.

2. You're not making the argument that torture (or "torture" as you call it) is Godly or biblical, but rather, that it is (in your opinion) prudent and necessary.

3. I consider waterboarding torture because a. It fits the definition of torture, and b. We have always recognized it as torture (we prosecuted Japanese in WWII for war crimes for using waterboarding)

4. I didn't bring up waterboarding, you did. I believe that the survey in question was asking merely, "Do you think torture is okay?" not specifically "waterboarding.

5. Your argument seems to be, "We need to torture to save lives," but you're not asking the question first: Is it the right thing to do? I posit that Christians have no business in the torture business (even if that torture is a less deadly, more lightweight torture, in some people's opinions.) This seems to me to be what Stan's post is about: Are we striving to live according to Christian ideals OR are we letting worldly thinking get in our way?

Are you trying to make the case that Jesus would torture people? Or that the early church would? Really?