Like Button

Monday, June 10, 2024

Been There, Done That

For Christians we have biblical certainty that those who are in God's hand cannot be removed (John 10:27-29). We have absolute assurance that He "is able to keep you from stumbling, and to make you stand in the presence of His glory blameless with great joy" (Jude 1:24). These texts and many others are clear that if we are one of His own, it is a sure thing that we will remain so. But ... how many of us have wondered, "Am I really saved?" Why? Well, almost without fail, it's because we all struggle with sin. Often repeated sin. "I just repented of that last week and here it is again." There is not one of us who does not sin and we hate it ... and do it again. So we may well ask, "Do I actually belong to Him, or am I fooling myself?" And it's not a bad question. Paul told us to "Test yourselves to see if you are in the faith; examine yourselves!" (2 Cor 13:5). Jesus warned of those who thought they were His but weren't (Matt 7:21-23). It happens. So we should ask. But, what if we ask and come to the conclusion that we are trusting Christ alone for our hope of salvation and can do nothing else? What do we do then?

Paul experienced the same issue. Yes, the Apostle Paul. "For what I am doing, I do not understand; for I am not practicing what I would like to do, but I am doing the very thing I hate," he wrote (Rom 7:15). "I joyfully concur with the law of God in the inner man, but I see a different law in the members of my body, waging war against the law of my mind and making me a prisoner of the law of sin which is in my members" (Rom 7:22-23). Have you experienced that? (Be assured. Every true believer has.) Paul cries out, "Wretched man that I am! Who will set me free from the body of this death?" (Rom 7:24). Note his answer to himself. "Therefore there is now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus" (Rom 8:1). Did you catch that? He isn't expecting perfection in this life, although he is striving for it (Php 3:12-14). He doesn't think that he will arrive at it in his lifetime. Neither his "proof of salvation" nor his comfort despite his failures don't lie in sinless perfection. His hope lies in the absolute assurance that there is no condemnation when you belong to Christ.

I would be surprised (and a bit skeptical) if you, too, had never experienced this questioning. I think the realization that we are not free of sin and cannot seem to get free of sin and we hate it is the universal experience of all true believers. In fact, I see it as an evidence of faith, since those who don't know God don't have the same Spirit in them convicting them of sin. So I want to remind you. We are not saved by attaining perfection. We are saved by being in Christ Jesus. In Christ, we no longer have condemnation ... even if we condemn ourselves. If we confess our sin, He's faithful and just to forgive us our sin ... and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness -- past, present, and future (1 John 1:9). Our salvation isn't reliant on us; it depends on Him. Our perseverance is not our doing; it's His (Php 2:12-13). And we can rest fully in Him knowing that He is able even though we know we are not.

Sunday, June 09, 2024

What Does Our Music Tell Us About Our Beliefs?

Paul wrote,
Let the word of Christ richly dwell within you, with all wisdom, teaching and admonishing one another with psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing with thankfulness in your hearts to God. (Col 3:16)
I've been in churches all over the country for my entire life, and in my experience very few have connected "psalms and hymns and spiritual songs" with either "let the word of Christ richly dwell within you" or "teaching and admonishing one another." Oh, there have been some, but not a lot. Why is that? I'm not sure, but I think the kind of worship music a church uses can tell us a lot about their theology.

A lot of churches have shifted to contemporary songs because they find the older ones "boring." Now, I'm not at all suggesting that "contemporary songs" are the equivalent of "bad theology." Not at all. There are some outstanding contemporary worship songs. It's just that so many are not. The most popular theme, of course, is "God loves me." Too many are what is termed "Jesus is my boyfriend" songs that speak vaguely enough about that love that it could be sung as a secular relationship song. And, of course, there's the ongoing communication problem where we hear "God loves me," run "love" through our modern lexicon, and come away with "God has deeply warm affection for me." (This is an anomaly, but one "church" I heard about in California incorporated sex acts in their services because "God is love" and "Love is sex." You see what I mean.) If not the "God is love" theme, the general sense of most modern worship music is to engender warm feelings toward God. They use music as an appeal to the emotions largely because music itself has the capacity to bypass the brain and engage with emotions. So if "worship" is "happy feelings toward God," then that's good music for church. But that's not worship and that's not what Scripture calls for.

These mistakes and others would be avoided if the aim of worship music was to incorporate Scripture into our lives and to teach and admonish through music. If the worship leadership was aiming at teaching and admonishing in music, I think we'd see some real changes in our churches. Of course, it wouldn't appeal to those who come for the entertainment. But ... is that a bad thing? Is our worship music declaring that our good feelings are paramount, or are we being turned to God and His Word? I think the answer speaks to our basic theology.

Saturday, June 08, 2024

News Weekly - 6/8/2024

Trump Made Me Do It
With 5 months before the election Biden has signed the order to close the southern border. "Trump gave me no choice." Wait ... what? That's what he said. Then, "We must face the simple truth, to protect America as a land that welcomes immigrants, we must secure the border and secure it now." Umm, yes ... I think that's what a lot of America has been saying ... for a long time. Too bad he was "forced" by his political opponent to act. (And to top off the madness, Trump promised to reverse Biden's closing of the border. Is he going for a policy position of "Whatever Biden wants I don't"?)

Unexpected
A Maricopa County judge has ruled that Arizona Governor Hobbs (D) acted illegally by avoiding state law in appointing allies in charge of 13 state agencies while, at the same time, she is being investigated for taking $400,000 from an organization headed by a CEO who was on her inaugural committee that ended up with the organization getting more money from the state. (On a sidenote, Hobbs was the Secretary of State in charge of the 2020 election contested by Trump and, last year, called for Trump to be indicted in Arizona for the crime of believing there were election irregularities.) Of course, none of these accusations can be true because she's a Democrat and they don't do this kind of thing.

Equality?
In Colorado the Republican party called for LGBTQ Pride flags to be burned. I personally think it's mindless -- what difference will it make if you burn a few "pride" flags? -- but I wonder if the left will be outraged at the burning of "pride" flags when they're unconcerned at the burning of American flags?

Those Crazy Christians
The Southern Baptist Convention voted to expel two churches (One was the Rick Warren's megachurch, Saddleback) from the SBC for having female pastors. A ratio something like 9 for expulsion to 1 against. Those nutty Southern Baptists, leaning so far into Scripture like that (1 Tim 2:11-14). They're even voting on making it a policy. What's wrong with them? Everyone knows the Bible was all wrong on that point. Of course, the media won't get it and boldly declared they're aiming to "ban women from most leadership roles." Not really. Just the ones Scripture talks about -- leading and teaching men. (They specified just pastors.) But, of course, truth is rarely an issue here.

Lawfare
I learned a new term the other day: lawfare. "What's that?" you might ask. It's built on an original "warfare" in which people use the law -- the justice system -- to wage war. You know, like we're seeing today. Trump was convicted of juggling the books, but there are so many questions. I'm not even a Trump fan, but even I can see real problems here. The selection of the judge was ostensibly random, but that's certainly in question. The prosecutor merged a felony charge by connecting a New York misdemeanor to a federal campaign finance law which, as it turned out, was not the charge. The judge prevented the defense from bringing in an expert witness who was going to testify about federal campaign finance law. The specific crime was not specified throughout the course of the trial. And at the end, the judge instructed the jury that they didn't all have to agree on what the crime actually was. Now they're talking about sending him to jail without protection, which is surely tantamount to an assassination attempt. For some reason the anti-Trump crowd sees all that and says, "Hmmm, seems pretty just to me." Go figure.

California ... Again
California is moving ahead with CA SB53, a bill aimed at taxation and movie picture credit ... oh, wait ... they redlined that ... oh, okay, it's firearms storage. Yeah, I see the connection. Not at all. They don't care. Bait and switch. So if you aren't holding your weapon, it must be stored in a California/DOJ-approved container. First offense will get you fined and lose the right to own a firearm for a year. After that it can be jail time. Right up there with the coming bill that would require new cars to beep at you if you're speeding. In other words, California continues to invade your life in every detail.

Sharp as a Laser Bee
Ouch! In the wake of Trump's felony conviction, the Bee pointed out that American voters can look forward to choosing between a convicted felon and an unconvicted felon in the next election. Nice. On that "Trump made me do it" story on Biden closing the border, the Bee claimed Biden announced plans to pretend to care about the border until November 6. (Do you suppose Trump made him do that, too?) And, apropos to nothing, there was the story about the man who resolved to be productive but ended up deeply into a Wikipedia story about the great molasses flood of 1919. Oh, wait ... there was a great molasses flood of 1919. Hang on a minute, I'm going to ...

Must be true; I read it on the Internet.

Friday, June 07, 2024

The Power of the Tongue

It was James who wrote, "For we all stumble in many ways. If anyone does not stumble in what he says, he is a perfect man, able to bridle the whole body as well" (James 3:2). My regular readers know I've often made a big deal about the use of words. I would like to point out, then, that I'm not alone. James warns about the power and danger of the tongue (James 3:2-12). I think, if you look around, you might be able to see it. You are certainly a victim of it. You might even be doing it.

We are way too flippant about our use of words. There are lots of easy examples. Our society uses "homosexual" as an identity rather than an act, so we do, too. Our culture claims "love is love" without the slightest regard for the nonsense of the claim. (Do we all really believe that "love of pizza" and "love of mother" and "love of my pet" and "love of my spouse" are all the same thing?) Today we tell our kids, "Don't let anyone stop you from reaching your dream." Really? What if that dream is to be a serial killer? Shouldn't we actually evaluate these "dreams"? Almost all of us have embraced the "self-esteem" concept that says, first, "We all must love ourselves" alongside, "We don't." The Bible disagrees (Eph 5:29). Today, warning someone that they're overweight and it could be detrimental is "fat shaming" instead of "concern for their physical wellbeing." We -- all of us -- have incorporated lies into our vocabulary and given the nod to our societal fabrications of identity, choice, love, sex, marriage ... on and on. We've relinquished words with their intended concepts and accepted substitute concepts without new words for the original concepts. Those original concepts, then, are tossed out, marginalized, erased. Biblical love, marriage, identity, sin, and more cannot be discussed because the words are gone.

I often find myself walking a fine line here. As an example, our culture (and, therefore, most of my readers) think of "LGBT+" as a monolithic group whose identity is in their sexuality. If I want to speak of those who support and/or practice sex between the same sexes or alternate genders as a group, the most expedient way is to use their language -- "LGBT+" -- but I don't actually believe in their concept. Just a single example. There is so much more. I find that if I am to actually communicate the ideas in my head to my readers, I am not allowed the words and would have to use too many other words and definitions to accomplish it. So how can I not stumble in what I say and still be understood in today's world? It's a dilemma.

Thursday, June 06, 2024

A Defining Moment

In July of 2008 California's Supreme Court ruled not only that marriage between two people of the same sex was okay, but that it was mandated. That is, as part of their ruling, they required the state to start issuing licenses. Mind you, the people had voted to define marriage as the union of a man and a woman. The court, instead, admitted that they were knowingly violating, in their own words, the "longstanding, traditional definition of marriage" and establishing a new one. Well, no. Just rejecting the longstanding, traditional one. In response, in November of 2008, the people voted again to define marriage as the union of a man and a woman, but this time they did so by making it part of the state constitution. Of course, the court struck that down, too, and we know the outcome, but here's the question. How do we define marriage?

I have long said that marriage was the lifelong union of a man and a woman for purposes of procreation and mutual support. Most people will say, "Fine, that's your definition, but it's just opinion." Actually, it's biblical. More to the point, the One who created the world and created male and female also created and defined marriage. I go with His definition. Go ahead. Look it up in the Bible under "M" for "marriage." No, of course not. The Bible isn't a dictionary. But we do have a definition ... from the lips of Jesus. When the Pharisees asked Jesus if there was any lawful reason to divorce (Matt 19:3), Jesus replied,
"Have you not read that He who created them from the beginning made them male and female, and said, 'Therefore a man shall leave his father and his mother and hold fast to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh'? So they are no longer two but one flesh. What therefore God has joined together, let not man separate." (Matt 19:4-6)
Jesus was not obscure or unclear. Notice what He did there. First, He quoted Scripture to answer them because Scripture is authoritative. "Have you not read ...?" Then He gave the source. "He that created them ... said ..." Keep up now. Jesus is saying that Scripture says that God gave us this institution of marriage. It's not merely a human institution. Then Jesus broke down the definition. First, it is "a man" and "his wife." (In the Greek, that "wife" is gunē -- woman. It is translated "wife" because of the context.) Biblically, according to God, marriage is purely between two heterosexuals, one man and one woman. No other options. Second, they were leaving their own families. Marriage established a new family. Thirdly, they became "one flesh." The sexual aspect of marriage (and marriage alone -- all other sex was defined as sin) was a union (cp 1 Cor 6:16). The sex act unites in more than a merely physical way, which is one of the reasons it was designed for and limited to marriage. Finally, since it is God that joins them, it is a lifelong union. We have no right to sever that tie.

Jesus was not unclear. Marriage, established by and defined by God, is limited to two people, one male and one female, consumated in their sexual union, for purposes of creating a new family (procreation) and mutual support (Gen 2:18). I didn't make that up. It's not a simply traditional or conservative view. It is a biblical view. Those who opt to alter it (and, by the way, I have yet to see anyone who adopts the "same-sex marriage" option offer any other definition with any sort of support at all) do so in opposition to Scripture which claims that it was God who established and defined it. Therefore, to do as that court in 2008 did -- reject the "longstanding, traditional definition of marriage" -- is a rejection of God and His Word. Do so at your own peril. As for me, I have no room to maneuver. Here I stand. I can do no other.

Wednesday, June 05, 2024

Not Good Enough

In Psalms 37 David writes, "Delight yourself in YHWH; and He will give you the desires of your heart" (Psa 37:4). Now, you get the point, right? If the desires of your heart are in the Lord, He will satisfy those desires. The Bible talks a lot about being satisfied with God. In Psalm 16 David writes, "You make known to me the path of life; in Your presence there is fullness of joy; at Your right hand are pleasures forevermore" (Psa 16:11). "Pleasures forevermore." We know with confidence "He who did not spare His own Son, but delivered Him over for us all, how will He not also with Him freely give us all things?" (Rom 8:32). Scripture makes it clear that we have every reason to count on God for our best interests and satisfaction.

So we know this and, on Sunday, we go to church and sing His praises. We thank Him for His goodness and praise Him for His grace and mercy. We even have a term for God: "Providence." Because God is our provider. But we often have a different message, don't we? You and I know it as "sin," but what is sin? We know Jesus is Lord, but sin says, "You're not the boss of me." We know that "Every good thing given and every perfect gift is from above" (James 1:17), but sin says, "That's not enough." In the Old Testament, God referred to Israel's idolatry as adultery. Why? Because He was Israel's "husband" and she was His "wife," but she said, "You're not good enough; I need another, better husband." Thus, in the same way, every sin we commit is telling God, "You're not my boss" and "You're not good enough for me."

If we could keep that in mind, I think it would have to have an impact on our lives. The psalmist wrote, "I have stored up Your word in my heart, that I might not sin against You" (Psa 119:11). If we kept His goodness and authority foremost in our minds and found our greatest satisfaction in Him, perhaps we'd stop hunting around for satisfaction elsewhere. And if we recognized what we were saying to our beloved Savior when we sin, we'd be less willing to sin. I think that's a certainty.

Tuesday, June 04, 2024

Dwell On These Things

This verse was rolling around in my head the last couple weeks. I'm sure you've seen it.
Finally, brethren, whatever is true, whatever is honorable, whatever is right, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is of good repute, if there is any excellence and if anything worthy of praise, dwell on these things. (Php 4:8)
I thought, "Do I?" Truthfully, I'd have to answer, "Not enough." In fact, not nearly enough. What do I "dwell on"? There's the whole problem of the "alphabet community" -- LGBT ... whatever else is tacked on. They're redefining morality, marriage, sex, love, even trying to redefine Christianity, and so much more. And I hear, "Dwell on these things, not those." There's the entire political scene, with Trump and Biden, the right and the left, the GOP and the Dems, the November election, the serious questions of political weaponization of the judicial branch and the assault on the judicial branch by the legislative branch and ... oh, so much stuff under that term, "political scene." And I hear, "Dwell on these things, not those." Or how about today's media? Any news source you want to consider. Do we have a reliable source? Is anyone accurately reporting the facts, or are all our sources just giving us their spin? Why does it look so much like Orwell's 1984? And I hear, "Dwell on these things, not those." And those big, international concerns -- Ukraine vs Russia, Israel vs Gaza, Iran and Yemen and all the fighting we see. There are international conspiracies like the World Economic Forum that openly suggest we end capitalism and democracy and are quietly working toward that end ... in my very backyard, even. And I hear, "Dwell on these things, not those." There are closer issues like will my retirement hold out against inflation or why are people so evil to one another so much of the time or who taught that guy to drive? Things like that. And I hear, "Dwell on these things, not those." The list goes on. You know how it is. Our modern world is in turmoil politically, environmentally, financially, geopolitically, physically ... on and on. So much to concern ourselves over. And I hear, "Dwell on these things, not those."

I wonder what that would look like? I wonder how it would be dwelling only on that which is true, honorable, right, pure, lovely, of good repute. If, instead of looking at the storms all around, we were looking at those things that are excellent and worthy of praise, wouldn't we be living differently? Wouldn't we be worrying less and wringing our hands less? Wouldn't we be calmer, less angry, less agitated? Wouldn't we be closer to the joy and peace that Christ came to bestow on us? Funny thing. There may not be a lot we can do about so much of what's going on in our world, but our failure, even refusal to "dwell on these things" rather than all that other garbage is something we can do. They can't prevent us. We are the ones that aren't doing it. And then we complain to God about how things are so bad. And He's saying, "Dwell on these things, not those." Why not? My high school driving instructor told me, "Don't watch the parked cars; keep your eyes where you're going. You will always go where you are looking." So where do we want to go? The good or the bad? I suppose, more to the point, who are you going to obey? The world and all its uproar or God: "Dwell on these things, not those."

Monday, June 03, 2024

Short-Handed

In the book of Daniel, Babylonian King Nebuchadnezzar had that dream about multiple kingdoms (Daniel 3). Later, he had a second dream. Daniel had done such a good job of interpreting the first that the king asked Daniel to do the second. Daniel was dismayed (Dan 4:19), but the king insisted on the truth. The dream foretold that the king would be driven from mankind, eat grass, and be drenched with dew for "seven periods of time" (Dan 4:24-25). The text goes on to say that a year later, the king was looking at his kingdom and boasting to himself about his power and majesty. And the prophecy came true. He went mad. He ran out, ate grass, and was basically wild (Dan 4:30-33). After the prescribed amount of time, he returned to his senses and blessed the Most High and Him alone. In his praise, he made an astounding statement.
"All the inhabitants of the earth are accounted as nothing, but He does according to His will in the host of heaven and among the inhabitants of earth; and no one can ward off His hand or say to Him, 'What have You done?'" (Dan 4:35)
Nebuchadnezzar was a pagan king who got slapped in the face by God. This king claimed that "no one can ward off His hand." He claimed that we do not have the right to challenge God -- "What have You done?"

I wonder how many of us would claim the same? I mean, how many of us faithful believers? How many of us actually believe that God does whatever He pleases? It seems to be a prevalent perspective that we can limit God by our sin or lack of faith. We seem to believe that if we don't do what we ought, God cannot accomplish what He intends. I am constantly amazed at this notion. Do we really believe that the God of Creation can be limited by His creation? Is that not what Paul warned about when he warned Christians "not to think more highly of himself than he ought to think" (Rom 12:3)? Is that really the God of Scripture? Not that I can see. God's hand is not that short. You can count on it.

Sunday, June 02, 2024

The Big Picture

As it turns out, we are human. I know! What a surprise, right? Of course not, but it appears that we assume that because we are human and "the top of the food chain," so to speak, God must be a lot like us. That's largely because we don't know the idea of "holy" as it was intended -- "other." But if you examine, for instance, the life of Christ, you'll find that He spoke in human terms but saw things in much larger terms.

That was patently obvious at the Sermon on the Mount when Jesus redefined things like "murder" (Matt 5:21-26) and "adultery" (Matt 5:27-30) from God's view rather than our own. But He seemed to do that most of the time. I already wrote about how He spoke of the "poor" and those who "hunger and thirst," for instance, but meant it in a spiritual sense rather than a merely earthly sense. Or think about His language regarding the bread and wine. He scared away disciples when He told listeners, "He who eats My flesh and drinks My blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up on the last day" (John 6:54). Really, Jesus? Cannibalism?? Of course not! He was speaking of spiritual things, bigger things. He used the ordinary to refer to the extraordinary. Or consider how confused His disciples were. The Old Testament promised a Savior who would establish His "kingdom" (e.g., Dan 7:27). Jesus's first gospel presentation was, "The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is at hand; repent and believe in the gospel" (Mark 1:15). So His disciples repeatedly asked Him, "Are you going to do it now?" They expected freedom from Rome ... maybe even Herod. They expected Him to establish His kingdom. And He did, but not in the way they thought. His kingdom, He explained to Pilate, "is not of this world" (John 18:36). His kingdom was established through His death and resurrection. He reigns now, currently from heaven and eventually on earth. His kingdom already is; we just have too small of a vision to notice.

God is not a man like us. He is not troubled with tunnel vision or narrow thinking. He is not concerned in the same way that we are about the here and now, the everday difficulties, the "little stuff," but has a much bigger version that incorporates all things to work together for good. So when you find life pressing or oppressing, be assured He is still in charge, still on hand, still working all things. Always for good. Always for the best. Always for a "best" that, in so many cases, we can't even imagine. He sees the bigger picture. And He likes it, because it's His.

Saturday, June 01, 2024

News Weakly - 6/1/24

Disturbing News
Pew Research last year reported that half of Americans assiduously get their news from the most reliable of all sources ... social media. A place without control or verification where any claim can be made without consequences. The joke was always, "I know it's true; I read it on the Internet." Apparently, to at least 50% of Americans, it's no joke. They really believe it. In a world where 50% get their news from a mainstream media that has decided their job is not to inform you, but to tell you what to think, and the other 50% get their "best information" from uncurbed drivel (from all sides), is it any wonder we're in this mess and getting worse every day?

The Story in the Details
The story from the Israeli/Hamas conflict was that Israel denied the Hamas claim that they captured some Israeli soldiers in northern Palestine. The thing that struck me was a statement in the story that "The Washington Post could not independently verify the IDF's reports." Oddly enough, the media appears to have no problem taking Hamas claims at face value without hedging with "couldn't independently verify" (like the claim that "35,984 people have been killed ... since the war began") but, apparently, they're definitely not going to trust Israel's claims.

Having A Voice Gives You A Voice?
Dua Lipa is a singer/songwriter. She has called for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza. I suppose, if Dua Lipa says it, we must. You guys get right on that, okay?

We've Got To Suppress These Judges
In what appears to be a blatantly political attempt to eliminate a conservative voice in the Supreme Court, Democrats demanded Justice Alito recuse himself from cases involving the riot on January 6, 2021. Alito rejected their demands. It was stunning how biased the USA Today story was. The "offending" flags were "connected" with "false claims" that the 2020 election had been stolen, according to "experts." "Experts" determine the purposes of flying an historical flag? Senators Durin and Whitehouse tattled on Alito's refusal to Chief Justice Roberts, hoping to get Alito on an ethics violation. Clearly they want a Supreme Court Justice to not be allowed to serve if they think he holds views they don't approve. Sounds a lot like tampering with the Judicial Branch, if you ask me. (And, in a stunning discovery, it turns out that the city of San Francisco was part of the "Stop the Steal" movement since they've flown that same "Appeal to Heaven" flag for 60 years.)

Another "Not News"
I'm sure you've already heard, but the jury convicted Trump on all 34 counts of falsifying documents. (I'm pretty sure no one else currently in office -- including Biden -- has ever falsified documents. No, really!) He is now officially a felon. Mind you, it doesn't disqualify him from running and it won't diminish him in the eyes of his avid fans. Nor does it exonerate those who brought the charges of any political malice. He was tried in a state that hates him and it was never a question of whether he'd be convicted. Those who care will continue to care, and those of us who don't won't. (I still can't figure out why some hateful commenters think I'm a Trump fan. Haven't I made it quite clear that I'm not? Is it just that I don't hate him like they want me to?)

Another Genuis Move in California
In 2014, California became the first state to ban those single-use plastic bags for groceries. Californians were required to get reusable bags and bring them to the story or pay a fee. Now they're planning to ban any plastic bags, including reuseable or even recyclable ones. Apparently their plastic ban only resulted in more plastic waste. Now you'll need to pay for paper bags with at least 50% recycled content ... or maybe juggle your groceries getting out to the car?

Here's Your Bill, Big Oil
Vermont passed a law that will require fossil fuel companies to pay for their share of the damage caused by flooding last summer "caused by climate change." Proving how much flooding climate change caused or obtaining a reasonable amount fossil fuel companies should pay seems really elusive to me. And, of course, I'd be tempted, if I was some "Big Oil" company in Vermont, to pull out. "See how you like 'no gas or oil' where you are." But, I suppose, that's why I'm not "Big Oil." If "justice" is a thing in America anymore, I'm not hopeful that this will succeed at obtaining it.

Bee Reasonable
The Bee had a lot to say on the Trump trial and outcome. A recent story out of the Bee tells us that the judge in the Trump case has instructed jurors that they need not believe Trump is guilty to convict him. I think it's kind of sad that it sounds almost possible. From Australia, kangaroos are protesting the comparison of the current American justice to them. After the conviction, one story talks about Donald Trump being convicted for being Donald Trump, and another warns that 12 jurors voted unanimously to ensure his reelection. I think that probably represents the sentiment of the pro-Trump crowd.

Must be true; I read it on the Internet.

Friday, May 31, 2024

Better Than The Statue of Liberty

Here's a quote. See if you can place it. "Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free." Sure you can. Most of us know that's written on a plaque on the Statue of Liberty. Many today wonder, not in a positive sense, if it should be removed because we don't seem to be quite so willing anymore to embrace all "your tired, your poor, your huddled masses." Is it false advertising? But ... just who are these tired and poor and huddled masses? On the statue, it's those tired, poor, huddled masses from around the world. And, no, we aren't willing or even able to take them all.

At the opening of Jesus's public ministry, He walked into a synagogue in Nazareth one Sabbath, opened a scroll from Isaiah, and read.
"The Spirit of the Lord is upon Me, because He has anointed Me to proclaim good news to the poor. He has sent Me to proclaim liberty to the captives and recovering of sight to the blind, to set at liberty those who are oppressed, to proclaim the year of the Lord's favor." (Luke 4:18-19)
He went on to say, "Today this Scripture has been fulfilled in your hearing" (Luke 4:21). The Social Justice Warrior types want us to believe that the Gospel (He did say He proclaimed the "good news") is just that. Jesus had come to proclaim liberty to captives, sight to the blind, freedom for the oppressed, and relief for the marginalized. (They add that last one because Jesus didn't know what it meant back then.) And the Synoptic Gospels bear out that Jesus helped some (and so should we) poor and some blind and gave some relief to some oppressed (I don't recall Him freeing any captives), but quite clearly He did not finish that task. Instead, He told His followers, "You always have the poor with you, but you will not always have Me" (Matt 26:11). Apparently it was not His plan to end poverty, blindness, captivity, or oppression. If it was, He failed. So what was Jesus talking about? Jesus was talking about the actually marginalized rather than socially marginalized -- those removed from a relationship with God, those who were under God's wrath (Rom 1:18). In the Beatitudes Jesus refers to "the poor" and "those who hunger and thirst" and "the meek" and so on (Matt 5:3-12), but He clearly isn't talking about those lacking funds or food or the like. He's talking about the poor in spirit and those who hunger and thirst for righteousness. While we tend to focus on the very real, but very temporal versions of "poor" and "captive" and such, Jesus was looking at the much deeper problem of spiritual poverty, spiritual starvation, and spiritual captivity (Matt 20:28). These kinds of things are bigger problems because 1) they have eternal consequences and 2) we aren't even aware of them, so we can't find a remedy for them.

Jesus said "Today this Scripture has been fulfilled in your hearing" because the solution to the spiritual darkness -- the spiritual marginalization that all humans suffer -- had arrived. Three years later, He died and declared "It is finished" because at that moment He made "peace by the blood of His cross" (Col 1:20) and canceled our certificate of debt for sin by nailing it to the cross (Col 2:14). Jesus spent His ministry distributing kindness and help to the needy -- physical and spiritual -- to illustrate that He was there to do so and capable of doing it. In fact, look at the account of the paralytic in Capernaum. You remember. His friends tried to get him in to see Jesus to be healed, but they couldn't (The KJV says "They could not come nigh unto Him for the press" (Mark 4:2) -- apparently the media was everywhere.), so they opened up the roof and dropped him in. Jesus did not tend first to his very obvious ailment. Instead, He said, "Son, your sins are forgiven" (Mark 2:5). This, of course, upset the religious leaders there, so Jesus went on to say, "Which is easier, to say to the paralytic, 'Your sins are forgiven,' or to say, 'Rise, take up your bed and walk'? But that you may know that the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins" -- He said to the paralytic -- "I say to you, rise, pick up your bed, and go home" (Mark 2:9-11). The primary concern was freedom for the captives to Satan, liberty for the spiritually oppressed, resources for the poor in spirit, sight for the spiritually blind. In that sense, then, Jesus was vastly better than the Statue of Liberty because the solutions He brought to the "tired," "poor," "huddled masses" was a permanent solution, restoring a relationship with His Father and given freely because His resources are infinite. Now that is really good news.

Thursday, May 30, 2024

Ananias and Sapphira

In Acts 5 we have the strange story of Ananias and Sapphira. Chapter 4 ends with how Barnabas sold a tract of land and gave the money to the church. So chapter 5 starts with, "But a man named Ananias, with his wife Sapphira, sold a piece of property, and kept back some of the price for himself, with his wife's full knowledge, and bringing a portion of it, he laid it at the apostles' feet" (Acts 5:1-2). The opening word, "but," signifies a difference, a contrast with Barnabas (and the others) in the previous chapter. What was different? It was not that they sold property. It was not that they gave money to the church. The difference was ... they lied about it. Ananias went to Peter and laid the money at his feet and said, "This is the whole price." He could have said nothing. Or he could have said, "This is some of it." We know that would have been just fine because Peter told him, "While it remained unsold, did it not remain your own? And after it was sold, was it not under your control? Why is it that you have conceived this deed in your heart? You have not lied to men but to God" (Acts 5:4). The problem wasn't that he kept some back. "After it was sold, was it not under your control?" That was just fine. No, it was the lie. For that lie, "Ananias fell down and breathed his last" (Acts 5:5), and when his wife, Sapphira, came in and confirmed, "Yes, that was the price," she, too, died on the spot (Acts 5:8-10).

Some suggest this is a story about how socialism reigned in the early church. But Peter's assurance that they had every right to keep it or to sell it and give whatever they wanted kind of deflates that idea. No, their error wasn't in keeping some back. It was in the claim that they didn't. Their error was, in Peter's words, "You have not lied to men but to God." Lying to God is a bad thing. In their case, fatal. But it occurs to me that we're often in the same mode. Maybe it's in our interaction with fellow believers. "Oh, that's sad. I'll be sure to pray for you." But we never do. Or maybe it's in our church gatherings where, maybe, we're asked to pray and we make it the best show we know how. I think we all have things that we just don't talk about to others. Problems, troubles, concerns, failures ... things that we're pretty sure no one else is experiencing and certainly things that no one else would accept as something they need to uphold and encourage you in. No, you're pretty sure if they found out "that" about you, they'd likely throw you out. So we make ourselves hypocrites by trying to look like a good Christian when we know we aren't. We hide our failings and needs because we want everyone to think well of us ... like Ananias and Sapphira.

I get it. Really. We Christians, as a group, can be way too judgmental. The world has its "unpardonable sins," but we who believe in divine forgiveness have our own, don't we? "Divorced? Oh ..." "You have a problem with what??!" Our doctrine holds that we -- all Christians -- are forgiven from all sin by faith in Christ, but we can be unforgiving of others ourselves. We are called to restore one another, but we can be judgmental much quicker than we're willing to bear one anothers burdens. I get it. But that doesn't make it right. And Jesus had a real problem with hypocrisy. Well, so does God, thinking about Ananias and Sapphira. So maybe that's not our best option.

Wednesday, May 29, 2024

Stolen Symbols

Justice Alito is in trouble lately because his wife flew an upside-down American flag. Now, the upside-down flag has ... or had ... a specific meaning. It was a symbol of distress or danger per the Flag Code. Some from the "Stop the Steal" movement opted to fly the flag that way on January 6, which obviously meant, "The election was fraudently stolen" and not an indication of distress or danger. Or ... was it? We'll never know. Now Dems want to silence Supreme Court Justice Alito because his wife put one up because she felt distressed and in danger. And that will never do. So the Legislative Branch is seeking to silence "opposing voices" in the Judicial Branch. And we can no longer fly an upside-down American flag as a distress symbol because some movement stole it. Same thing with the Appeal to Heaven flag. A Revolutionary War flag, now it's been stolen by some far right group and anyone who has one had better be arrested or go into hiding.

Symbols are powerful tools ... or weapons. The swastika that we all connect with fascist Nazi Germany came from Hinduism as a symbol of prosperity and good luck. The rainbow was a symbol of peace and was coopted to symbolize LGBT stuff. So many symbols have been stolen, twisted, and fed back with a new meaning. Of course, the most common symbols stolen and twisted are words. Words are symbols of thoughts and ideas. Like when we used to refer to "marriage" as a lifelong union of a man and a woman for purposes of procreation and mutual support (that's a lot of meaning in a single symbol). Today it means, "I like you a lot ... for now." Biblically, "love" means self-sacrifice for the best interest of the other, but we've twisted it to "I feel warmly toward you ... want to have sex?" Not even close. There's one, too -- "sex." The act was intended by God to symbolize the union of two people (marriage) as an image of Christ's relationship to His Bride, the Church (Eph 5:31-32). Now it's mostly just a recreational pasttime. "Christian" once referred to "followers of Christ". It shifted to mean "the body of people who use the term" until today it simply means "whoever claims it." And as Christ Himself said, too often those who claim the word "Christian" often have nothing to do with it (Matt 7:21-23).

As illustrated in the Alito story, appropriated symbols make a mess of things. I see an upside-down American flag and think "distress" and others think "crazy conspiracy theorists." I hear the word, "love," and want to think it's about self-sacrifice and the greater good of others, but it's not anymore. We don't have a word for that anymore. It's like George Orwell's "newspeak" from the novel, 1984. The government was controlling minds by controlling speech so that they could no longer think the concepts that the changed words intended. Our world government, the god of this world, is doing that today. Symbols are coopted. Ideas are erased. Concepts can barely be expressed anymore. And we still think we're communicating just fine because, "Hey, we both used the same word!" Same word? Maybe, but not the same idea.

Tuesday, May 28, 2024

Competing Fundamentalisms II

Recently I pointed out that "fundamentalism" can be found just about anywhere. Even though the first two that spring to mind are Islam and Christianity, most people hold to some fundamental beliefs that shape their worldview ... while they complain about people who hold to some fundamental beliefs. This time, I do want to compare the two most obvious "fundamentalists" -- Islam and Christian. Are they basically the same thing?

First, "fundamentalism," for the sake of this discussion, simply means, "strict adherence to the basic principles of any subject or discipline." As such, it cannot be automatically classified as "immoral" because "basic principles" are unavoidable. Set aside, for a moment, your conditioned response of distaste for the word. In terms of Christianity and Islam, then, fundamentalism is specifically an adherence to the literal interpretation of scripture -- either the Bible or the Quran (or Qur'an or Koran if you prefer). In both cases, then, the Christian and the Muslim would be a fundamentalist if they seek to follow what's written in their Book. So, how do these stack up? Well, the Quran has unmistakable commands regarding infidels -- unbelievers. The holy book of the "religion of peace" has over 100 references to waging war on non-Muslims. While the Bible has a few Old Testament commands from God for specific groups in Israel's history to attack specific enemies, there are no "open-ended" commands to do so in the Bible, while the commands from the Quran have no "end date." Instead, the Christ of Christ-ianity says the primary command is love -- love God and love your neighbor. Jesus included instructions like "turn the other cheek" and other such things. The New Testament left all sorts of directions to trust in God for our salvation, not some form of coercion or violence. In fact, killing infidels makes zero sense in a biblical framework. It's just not in the Bible.

Now, as we know, there are Muslims who are not violent toward infidels and there are "Christians" who are violent. In terms of "fundamentalism," clearly the Muslim who refuses to war against unbelievers is in violation of his own scriptures while the Christian who chooses violence as a means to obtain God's ends is in violation of his own scriptures. In this sense (the sense that most upsets outside observers), then, the fundamentalist Muslim would need to be at war with unbelievers and the fundamentalist Christian would need to be at peace with everyone (Rom 12:18; Rom 14:19; 2 Cor 13:11; 1 Thess 5:13; Heb 12:14). Those who classify themselves as "Christian" but reject God's Word poorly represent Christ. The fundamentalist Muslim must aim to coerce by force. The fundamentalist Christian must aim to encourage in love. Not the same thing.

Monday, May 27, 2024

Memorial Day, 2024

Veterans Day is for recognizing all who served in any capacity in the military. Memorial Day is not. Memorial is specifically designed to commemorate those who gave their lives in military service to this country. "Commemorate" ... an interesting word. I'm sure you can see the connection to "memory," right? We use the word to celebrate or show respect, but the root meaning is to "call to remembrance." And that's really what Memorial Day is intended to do ... remind us, specifically of those who gave all.

Mary Walker, to date, is the only female Medal of Honor recipient. Dr. Walker served in the Union army as a field surgeon, providing medical aid to Union soldiers, civilians ... and Confederate soldiers alike. She would cross enemy lines to help Confederate surgeons, and she would do it alone since none of the brave men with her had the courage to do it. Eventually she was arrested as a spy by Confederate forces and spent 4 months in prison before being released. For her courage, she was awarded the Medal of Honor.

One of the recipients from World War I was Corporal Jake Allex. Engaged in a fierce battle in France, all of Allex's platoon officers became casualties after coming into range of a German machine gun nest. Lacking direction from leadership, Allex took rifle in hand and advanced alone toward the nest, firing until he ran out of ammunition. Then he charged and attacked the 20 enemy soldiers with his bayonet, killing 5, and subduing the rest with his rifle butt until they were captured.

In World War II at the Battle of the Bulge, Army Private James Hendrix (no relation to the guitar player) was part of a leading element attempting to break through German lines at Bastogne. At one point, in a hail of artillery and small arms fire, Hendrix dismounted from his half-track and walked alone toward two German 88 mm guns. Firing his rifle, he forced the gun crews to take cover and then surrender. Later that day, he left his vehicle again to assist two wounded soldiers caught in a crossfire. His counter-fire gave them sufficient time to get to safety. Later that same day, Hendrix voluntarily braved mines, guns, and snipers to reach a fellow soldier in a burning vehicle. Hendrix dragged him to safety and put out his flaming clothing before the vehicle exploded.

To date there are 3,520 Medal of Honor winners. Nineteen of them won two. They came from all services and all walks of life. Many received them posthumously. Of the 3,520 recipients, 61 are still alive. As the saying goes, all gave some, and some gave all. Today we honor those who gave their lives for something higher than themselves. We owe them a debt of gratitude.

Sunday, May 26, 2024

What? A "Photography" Label? Huh.

I had forgotten that I had an entire category labeled "Photography." I mean, if I have the label, I might as well use it, right?

This is a roadrunner that was on our pool deck. He was hunting. We have bird feeders across the pool there and he was looking for a nice, juicy little sparrow. (Note: He caught one.) As a sidenote, roadrunners do not say, "Meep, meep!" Nor are they mild-mannered birds, but, rather, quite aggressive. A couple of lies in my youth I got from those "Coyote and Roadrunner" documentary cartoons.


This would be a popular food choice for the roadrunner if he could catch it. It's a verdin. They're smaller than a sparrow and enjoy drinking out of hummingbird feeders.


It's only fair, I suppose, that this bobcat would be just as willing to catch himself a fine, juicy roadrunner. (I know; it's not the best picture. The cat was sitting on the wall outside our window and I had to get the picture through the window without disturbing him. "Smile and say cheese" doesn't work with wild animals for some reason.)


This shot illustrates why I cannot quite fathom how it is that northern cardinals are native to the desert where we are. I mean, they're not well camouflaged. They are prey birds. You'd figure any halfway-attentive hawk could pick this guy off in a moment. But this particular one has lived here for more than 10 years. (Amazing, given their normal average lifespan is more like 3 years.)


I hope you've enjoyed the show. I may do more going forward. Let me know if that's a good idea.

Saturday, May 25, 2024

News Weakly - 5/25/24

Anti-Christ Christians
More on that story of the Roman Catholic football player who gave a Roman Catholic speech at a private Roman Catholic college. Now a "Christian organization" has petitioned for him to apologize because, while his comments did not reflect their version of "Christian values," they certainly did reflect biblical values, and if there's anything we know, it's that modern "Christians" will not abide biblical values. I'm wondering if we can sign a petition to have those who reject biblical values removed from the term "Christian." To be clear, just because the story refers to it as a "Christian petition" does not make it actually Christian. They're defining "Christian" much the same as they define "marriage" -- not really anything, but they're going to use the term anyway.

Reverse Cancel Culture?
Secretary of State Blinken was chided by China for congratulating Taiwan's Lai Ching-te for being elected President. China demands "the U.S. immediately correct their mistakes." And former Congressman Mike Gallagher was sanctioned by China for visiting Taiwan. I don't know. Is that a bad thing? Because I'd tend to view it as an endorsement of Blinken and Gallagher. But, maybe that's just one of the reasons my blog is banned in China.

Side By Side
These stories came out on the same day. First, a new study reports that daily marijuana use is outpacing daily drinking in the U.S. Of course, we must question that since people are generally known to be careful drug users, whether it's alcohol or narcotics. Almost the very next story on my newsfeed reported that cannabis use causes the risk of psychosis to skyrocket among teens. Recreational use of marijuana is now legal in 24 states and for medical purposes in 38. I mean, seriously, what could go wrong?

Too Many Questions
In February, 2024, NBC reported that Mexican drug cartels had "flooded" Montana with fentanyl and meth, including "operations on Indian reservations." That's a red flag, but when South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem made a similar statement about South Dakota, she was banned from all Sioux tribal lands. Is that, "No, we have no Mexican drug cartels here" or is that, "No, we don't want anyone to know"? Or is it, "We won't allow people here who kill dangerous dogs"?

Now We Understand
For several years now people have been complaining about police departments. Perhaps we've discovered the underlying problem. Recent research has reported that ultra-processed foods can increase the risk of cognitive problems. Foods like packaged snacks, donuts, and carbonated drinks. Foods like police are known to consume. And college students! Processed foods and cannabis! Aha! Now we're getting somewhere!!

Tyranny of the Minority
Eight Alaskans, ages 11 to 22, are suing Alaska for planning a natural gas project. They claim the project infringes on their constitutional protections because the greenhouse gases will harm their health and livelihood. If this suit succeeds, I see two obvious ramifications. First (and this is already true), it will only take an extremely small number to do this. Here it's eight -- eight young Alaskans that will decide for Alaska and the downstream recipients whether or not they'll get the natural gas. Second, the logic requires that simple lawsuits from very small (and apparently terrorized) numbers should be able to successfully stop all fossil fuels in America because, hey, it infringes on their constitutional protections. Welcome to anarchy. Oh, and a verifiable threat to democracy.

The Right Spin
The news tells us that new unemployment claims are down ("That's good!") while the U.S. Treasure Secretary voices concerns that the cost of living is getting too high ("That's bad!"). The government wants to eliminate fossil fuel vehicles in favor of electric vehicles ("That's good!"), but EV sales are slowing and EV manufacturer, Lucid, is cutting their workforce by 6% ("That's bad!"). So where are the spin doctors who will take the 3 hostages found dead in Gaza and turn it to "Hamas continues to return hostages as a show of good faith"?

Bee Satirical or Bee Quiet
Just too true this time, Bee. The story is about how a Trump/Biden debate again is a clear sign of God's judgment on America. Can't argue with that. In another story, after the death of Iran's president, Israel accidently let it slip that they had developed a terraforming machine that could, for instance, quickly build a mountain in front of, say, a flying helicopter. Not connected to any current events, I'm sure. And, not the Bee, but the Genesius Times is carrying the story of how the January 6 protesters have all been released because they claimed they were just protesting for Palestine. I can see that.

Must be true; I read it on the Internet.

Friday, May 24, 2024

Competing Fundamentalisms

Psychology Today published a "helpful" article back in 2018 about "How Religious Fundamentalism Hijacks the Brain." The only two versions of this fundamentalism, apparently, were Islam and Christianity, with heavier emphasis on Christian fundamentalism. The author compared it to a "parasitic manipulation" that commands individuals to act and think a certain way -- "a rigid way that is intolerant to competing ideas." Now, I find that interesting, because it seems to me that there are all sorts of versions of this "parasitic manipulation" that "inserts itself into brains," rejecting competing ideas. In fact, don't (almost?) all ideologies do just that?

I was reading about "Scientific Fundamentalism," the belief that all knowledge gained through, and all conclusions drawn from, the scientific method are true. Interestingly, the willingness of some to question the veracity of "all conclusions" is regarded by most as "radical," because Science today is sacrosanct (which, being interpreted, means "treated as if holy; immune from criticism or violation"). At this point, it is impossible to think of Science as anything but right, a feat accomplished by rejecting all evidence to the contrary (which is not a small amount of evidence). Science.org, for instance, reported that "fake scientific papers are alarmingly common" and reported numbers like "34% of neuroscience papers" (as opposed to the 2% reported in 2022 ... which would appear to be a false report). Scientific Fundamentalism is a thing, and a large part of our culture has bought it, rejecting and intolerant of competing ideas.

Here's the difficulty. The nature of Truth is that there is that which is true and that which is not true. When "true" is rightly determined, it requires that every other competing idea be rejected as false. It is intolerant of competing truth claims. According to Psychology Today, that's a problem. And they didn't even seem to notice that they were practicing it in the article -- rejecting competing ideas. If, however, we are to cling to truth as a valid data set to hold and reject what is known to be non-truth (read "lies"), we know a good source for truth, don't we? (John 17:17)

Thursday, May 23, 2024

If You Love Me

The Apostle, John, spends more time in his Gospel than any other in the upper room with Jesus that last night before He was crucified. John covers that evening from chapter 13 through 17. Nestled there in a lot of "Jesus speaking" is an interesting claim ... from the lips of Christ.
"If you love Me, you will keep My commandments." (John 14:15)
That is an interesting statement. Some translations phrase it to place the cause of the second clause on the basis of the first: "If you love Me, obey My commandments." Others (like the NASB or the ESV) reverse that. In the end, it doesn't really matter which way you say it; it ends up the same.

In this text Jesus ties "love Me" to "obey Me." Looking at it in the negative, if you negate one, you negate the other: "If you do not love Me, you will not obey Me." Looking at it from a cause-and-effect perspective, we find something very striking. Jesus is putting "love" as the deciding factor for "obey." It's helpful, if a bit disturbing, to see what's really going on. Our obedience is not conditioned on our fortitude, our wills, our strength, or our humility. It is conditioned on ... our love for Christ. Or, to put that in the negative, our failure to obey isn't a failure of effort, but a failure to love Christ as we should. John picked this up in that upper room and repeated it elsewhere.
By this we know that we have come to know Him, if we keep His commandments. The one who says, "I have come to know Him," and does not keep His commandments, is a liar, and the truth is not in him; but whoever keeps His word, in him the love of God has truly been perfected. By this we know that we are in Him: the one who says he abides in Him ought himself to walk in the same manner as He walked. (1 John 2:3-6)
Every genuine Christian fails to obey at times. It's a given (1 John 1:8-10). What do we do with that? Well, confess, of course (1 John 1:9), and repent, but the direction we repent toward isn't "Work harder." It is "Love Christ better." It is "lay aside every encumbrance and the sin which so easily entangles us" (Heb 12:1) by "fixing our eyes on Jesus, the author and perfecter of faith" (Heb 12:2). Pursuing obedience is elusive, but pursuing a love for the Savior is a singular direction, especially when we realize that obedience is contingent on that love.

Wednesday, May 22, 2024

The New Inclusivity

While it is true that our current culture is starting to become disenamored with the whole diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) concept, there are still loud voices calling for it. In fact, the fact that companies and universities and such are starting to drop DEI departments is actually a problem on the face of it. The concept is that we need to promote fair treatment and full participation of all people, and, seriously, why would we want to disagree with that? So what's the problem?

Our society has taken a patently good concept, wrenched it from its actual meaning, and substituted ... something else. The earlier "inclusivity" meant that we included those we knew, those we were comfortable with, those who agreed with us. And some rightly said, "That's not inclusivity." So they set out to right that wrong. When the owner of Chick-Fil-A was caught giving some of his money to organizations that did not support the current public perspective on marriage, the DEI community went wild. "That's not inclusive!" So we heard people like the mayor of Chicago say things like, "We will not allow a Chick-Fil-A to be built in our town because they aren't inclusive and we are an inclusive city." Which is, being translated, "We will exclude those who are not inclusive." When a private Roman Catholic college invited a Roman Catholic football player to give a commencement speech and he spoke from Roman Catholic values ... that ran counter to society's values, the outrage was quick and vicious. Silence him. Have him fired. Make him apologize. Because in our new "inclusive" world we will not include those who disagree with our own perspective. So this new "inclusivity" was that we would include those who we knew, who we were comfortable with, who agreed with us. Only now it was with the force of law and/or policy. The old, "I may not agree with what you are saying, but I will defend your right to say it" is right out the window, and we call that "inclusivity."

Consider for a moment. How is, "We will not allow those who hold opinions different than our own to have a voice" any different than, "We will not allow those we deem communists to have a voice"? How have we moved on from McCarthyism, for instance? We are not more tolerant today. We still turn on those who say what we don't want them to say. We still seek to silence those who speak what we don't want others to hear. We may have shifted our inclusivity to a different group, but it is still "those we support" and definitely not "those who disagree with what we have approved." The Declaration of Independence claimed that we are all created equally with equal rights and the Bill of Rights was written to uphold that principle. As always, we humans may have good intentions, but we also have evil ways, and, as always, some are more equal than others. What has changed is "our own group" and not the hearts of men.